kiskiboy97

Dear Mr. Liebman,

Thank you for the astute and detailed review of "Funny Girl". I have discovered one error, something that, I believe, you can easily fix. It is my understanding that the term you wished to use is not "shoe-in", but "shoo-in". Please consult a dictionary if you wish. I consulted Merriam Webster at www.m-w.com/. Otherwise, well done!

Kevin Courtemanche

The African Queen couldn't have been a bigger disappoint. The Blu-ray presentation was great, but I found the story and movie the opposite of your review. Clunky script, contrived MacGyver- like recoveries from disaster, slow and not believably interesting. I cannot believe it's held in such high regard. Wow.

Martin, why does such a great movie as the new 3:10 To Yuma always sell for $5? I've just pre-ordered the original from Criterion you reviewed.

Why do you think Jason Clarke gives the best performance over Chastain in Zero Dark Thirty?

Re. your review of "Meet the Browns", you mention 5.1 audio, but the box says 7.1, is that an error on the cover (although more Tyler Perry movies are 7.1)? Thanks!

I have a few questions about the aspect ratios of BR releases. If I click any movie on this site, it will say "Aspect Ratio" and "Original Aspect Ratio". If a film was shot in 2.39:1, how did it change to 2.40:1 or 2.35:1? Also, virtually every Warner release says the film's aspect ratio is 1.85:1 when it's really 1.78:1 (if it was shot in that general ratio). Can you clarify what's going on there?

sure..whats his e-mail?

Hi Martin, is the runtime of Joshua Tree really 102 minutes or is that what it says on the box? I have the Artisan DVD and it says the same thing, but in fact it is the unrated cut that runs 106 minutes.

Hello Martin, any reason why the Top Gun 3D review was pulled? Thanks

Have you tried enabling 48hz mode (with the source outputting 24p) for 3D viewing on your Panasonic plasma? I know that mode looks terrible for normal 2D viewing, but you can't see the awful flickering in 3D and it somehow eliminates crosstalk on my GT30 even with very strong 3D movies like Hugo.