||09-03-2011 07:03 PM
Originally Posted by phansson
I guess we will have to disagree on the yoda getting cgi'ed into the OT. I just really wouldn't put it past Lucas to do anything now. The small changes I understand, Wicket's blinking give him some sort of life, etc, Now changing dialogue to the climax of a 3 part movie? He is not right in the head.
And yet there´s method to his madness as far as the Vader dialogue change is concerned. Yes, adding the ´no´, then ´no......................!´ is awful and cringeworthy, especially the cheesy way its delivered with that echo effect, but one can see what George is thinking, even if its flawed reasoning and totally unnecessery, even going so far as to greatly undermine the power of the scene as it originally was (one of the best/most iconic scenes in the entire trilogy, perfect as it was IMO).
He´s trying to create symmetry between the PT and OT by having both trilogies end with Anakin/Vader going ´No................................!´, linking OT Vader to PT Vader and emphasising that they´re the same person. I know, its like storytelling 101, emphasising a point that is already obvious, but in George´s mind it was absolutely necessery
There´s no reason that I can see for changing puppet Yoda into digital Yoda. It would be expensive and for no real purpose. That´s why I think George will never do it, however nuts he may seem to us now.