Mad Men Season 1 under review by AMZ, Defects?

[Adrock]

Originally Posted by jwbbud

Problem Solved, no need to speculate. Amazon does this alot based on complaints received

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0017JKEL8

Thanks, jwbbud! I appreciate it.

[Adrock]

Originally Posted by SquidPuppet

With some of the MEGA-SUPER-OCD people on this site, I wouldnt be surprised.

*cough* adrock41 *cough*

[borninusa]

I hate to say it, but it was me who froze out Mad Men being sold. What the deal was I had bought season one...got most of the way through it then on the episode "Long Weekend"...around the 46min 20sec mark, you hear a pop and the sound goes out. I contacted Amazon...got a replacement, and it happened again. The same thing happened on both players I own (and on a buddies system I know). There was no firmware update. Upon researching it a tad, if you read some of the reviews on Amazon for the set, a few other people have had the exact same problem. So, when I request yet another replacement, Amazon comes back and tells me to just send it back for a refund. Well, I didnt want to do that and wanted to try another copy and told them so. Basically, I was told to ship it back for the refund and they would research it. That happened this morning.

I applaud Amazon for actually taking the steps to check out the problem (if they did so).

Anyways...sorry for those who went to order it today. If I have a problem with a disc, I will try to get a replacement but upon the second try...it wasnt happening.

[borninusa]

...btw...apparently the problem is not 'wide spread'..not at all...and I told Amazon that. Must just be a bad batch not diggin' certain players.

[Adrock]

Originally Posted by borninusa

I hate to say it, but it was me who froze out Mad Men being sold. What the deal was I had bought season one...got most of the way through it then on the episode "Long Weekend"...around the 46min 20sec mark, you hear a pop and the sound goes out. I contacted Amazon...got a replacement, and it happened again. The same thing happened on both players I own (and on a buddies system I know). There was no firmware update. Upon researching it a tad, if you read some of the reviews on Amazon for the set, a few other people have had the exact same problem. So, when I request yet another replacement, Amazon comes back and tells me to just send it back for a refund. Well, I didnt want to do that and wanted to try another copy and told them so. Basically, I was told to ship it back for the refund and they would research it. That happened this morning.

I applaud Amazon for actually taking the steps to check out the problem (if they did so).

Anyways...sorry for those who went to order it today. If I have a problem with a disc, I will try to get a replacement but upon the second try...it wasnt happening.

Ah ha! I had kind of hoped this to be the case! Thank you very much for citing your problems specifically! I really appreciate it. I figured it may have been someone whom participated on this forum. I will check my copy tonight at that mark on the episode and see if I have any audio problems. Thank you so much for citing your specific defect so that I can check my copy out. I, as I am sure others do, really appreciate it!

Thanks, borninusa!

[Adrock]

Originally Posted by borninusa

...btw...apparently the problem is not 'wide spread'..not at all...and I told Amazon that. Must just be a bad batch not diggin' certain players.

I actually received my copy today, I ordered it on Monday, and happened to notice on Amazon today (after I received it) that it was no longer up for sale. I started this thread to see if anyone had experienced issues as I am worried my copy may be affected, but as I stated, now I can check it out! Thanks for your help.

[borninusa]

Again, sorry about that but I dont do a defective product. I did a quickie search and someone on dvdtalk had the same problem. I take that back, his problem varied just a bit. When he heard the pop, his sound didnt go out like mine but for the next 30 seconds there was a 'noise'. I am fairly sure its the 46min 20 second mark though.

[SquidPuppet]

Originally Posted by borninusa

I hate to say it, but it was me who froze out Mad Men being sold. What the deal was I had bought season one...got most of the way through it then on the episode "Long Weekend"...around the 46min 20sec mark, you hear a pop and the sound goes out. I contacted Amazon...got a replacement, and it happened again. The same thing happened on both players I own (and on a buddies system I know). There was no firmware update. Upon researching it a tad, if you read some of the reviews on Amazon for the set, a few other people have had the exact same problem. So, when I request yet another replacement, Amazon comes back and tells me to just send it back for a refund. Well, I didnt want to do that and wanted to try another copy and told them so. Basically, I was told to ship it back for the refund and they would research it. That happened this morning.

I applaud Amazon for actually taking the steps to check out the problem (if they did so).

Anyways...sorry for those who went to order it today. If I have a problem with a disc, I will try to get a replacement but upon the second try...it wasnt happening.

Unbelievable. You ruined contless lives with your selfish behavior.

[borninusa]

btw.....if you play that specific episode...and skip to that point...skip to the point 'before' the potential defect. If you skip to after the defect and 'rewind' a bit, it seems to play. Go to like the 46 min mark and just let it play.

[borninusa]

Originally Posted by SquidPuppet

Unbelievable. You ruined contless lives with your selfish behavior.

How will the masses function tonight? I just dont know

[Adrock]

Originally Posted by borninusa

Again, sorry about that but I dont do a defective product. I did a quickie search and someone on dvdtalk had the same problem. I take that back, his problem varied just a bit. When he heard the pop, his sound didnt go out like mine but for the next 30 seconds there was a 'noise'. I am fairly sure its the 46min 20 second mark though.

Hey! I'm with you brother! I would have hated to find this was defective in like a month when I actually find time to watch the whole season I appreciate your help and your tip! I'll check my copy out tonight. Thanks, again!

[borninusa]

It sucks cause I want the title in my collection. I will order it again down the road for maybe I just got a bad pressing.

Anyways...hopefully this is not some widespread thing...and it doesnt appear to be.

[hardtosayx]

Originally Posted by adrock41

Hey! I'm with you brother! I would have hated to find this was defective in like a month when I actually find time to watch the whole season I appreciate your help and your tip! I'll check my copy out tonight. Thanks, again!

Same.. now I'm worried that mine won't work so I'm gonna try mine later before it's too late. Because I know I won't be watching it any time soon with everything else I'm in the middle of watching.

[nathanp]

Bought mine when it was first released, and have had no problems with it.

[Russell_L]

Originally Posted by hardtosayx

Well a couple weeks ago I bought Season 1 but when I got it, the cover looked like it was soaked in water and dried. Then I got a new one and it was still that way a little bit but figured whatever. It could be because of the weather, but it's never happened before. Not sure.

So this could be why? I haven't watched it yet though so I don't know if it's anything with the discs.

Mine was that way as well. (Got it from Amazon on Black Friday.) Turned out that the cover was just ever-so-slightly too large for the case and so was crimped under the clear plastic. But rather than trim the cover with scissors (which I'm sure I would have botched), I replaced the case with a spare one that I had lying around (it was either the 'Up' or 'Sleeping Beauty' case that I replaced with steelbooks). Fits perfectly now, and the cover has smoothed out.

BTW, I've noticed the exact same crimped cover with MMS1 copies at several Best Buys, so it must be pretty common.

[Crimson King]

Will people actually return the movie just because of the cover? It's what's inside that really counts, right?

[borninusa]

Another btw...I have a Sony 550..and a 300(crap...I forget the model number on that one)...but the disc screwed up in both players

[Adrock]

Originally Posted by borninusa

Another btw...I have a Sony 550..and a 300(crap...I forget the model number on that one)...but the disc screwed up in both players

Borninusa, I am very sorry to hear of your troubles with MMS1, so I got home and watched the entire episode you mentioned (along with trying all 3 discs) and I experienced *NO* audio drop outs, pops, or errors. It played like a dream.

I would assume anyone looking to purchase MMS1 is safe to do so, especially as if Amazon stopped selling it today, and already began reselling it, any remainded defective copies have been isolated and/or removed (one could assume).

FWIW, the case being 'squished' is disappointing, but as a previous poster said, I have seen copies from many sources (BB, Amazon,etc) that do in fact all have that issue. I would not send back a BD for this problem, but if there was audio drop outs and pops, that is another story!

Anyways, Borninusa, I would assume you to be safe to add this to your collection unless it is in fact caused by your player(s). I have a Panasonic DMP-BD60 and had no issue with MMS1.

Ended up being a great day, my Canadian issues showed up today, I got From Dusk Til Dawn and Swingers, and I don't have to send back Mad Men! Hoo-Rah!

If anyone has any questions, feel free to post or PM me. Thanks everyone for your help and chiming in, I appreciate it.

[The_Basterd]

Originally Posted by borninusa

I hate to say it, but it was me who froze out Mad Men being sold. What the deal was I had bought season one...got most of the way through it then on the episode "Long Weekend"...around the 46min 20sec mark, you hear a pop and the sound goes out. I contacted Amazon...got a replacement, and it happened again. The same thing happened on both players I own (and on a buddies system I know). There was no firmware update. Upon researching it a tad, if you read some of the reviews on Amazon for the set, a few other people have had the exact same problem. So, when I request yet another replacement, Amazon comes back and tells me to just send it back for a refund. Well, I didnt want to do that and wanted to try another copy and told them so. Basically, I was told to ship it back for the refund and they would research it. That happened this morning.

I applaud Amazon for actually taking the steps to check out the problem (if they did so).

Anyways...sorry for those who went to order it today. If I have a problem with a disc, I will try to get a replacement but upon the second try...it wasnt happening.

Oh my gawd. I am having the same problem. Same episode and I bought mine from Best Buy a couple weeks ago. I am so glad I am not having the same problem.
After I got to disc 2 I threw out my receipt and thought nothing of it. Then I get to that episode and boom, there is this loud noise. I have to do a quick fast forward to make it go away. I am so glad to hear I am not the only one having this problem.

If I explain to Best Buy what happened, do you think they will let me exchange without a receipt?

[The_Basterd]

Does anyone think that will work?