Yet Another Headphone Recommendation Thread

[J6P]

I use the B&W P5's all day at work and the sound is phenomenal -- extremely natural, subtle and detailed.

They don't utilize any noise cancellation circuitry, but the solid plate construction and memory foam earpads conform to the ear so well that conversations right next to my desk are completely obliterated, even without anything playing through the 'phones.

I'm chained to this desk a good 70 hrs/week, so $300 was a small price to pay. Highly recommended.

[Suntory_Times]

Originally Posted by J6P

I use the B&W P5's all day at work and the sound is phenomenal -- extremely natural, subtle and detailed.

They don't utilize any noise cancellation circuitry, but the solid plate construction and memory foam earpads conform to the ear so well that conversations right next to my desk are completely obliterated, even without anything playing through the 'phones.

I'm chained to this desk a good 70 hrs/week, so $300 was a small price to pay. Highly recommended.

b&w p5's do not have a natural sound signiture nor are they very detailed. They have quite a muddy sound and lack detail. I'm glad you like your purchase though.

[J6P]

Originally Posted by Suntory_Times

b&w p5's do not have a natural sound signiture nor are they very detailed. They have quite a muddy sound and lack detail. I'm glad you like your purchase though.

You don't sound that glad.

P5 Reviews

[Suntory_Times]

Originally Posted by J6P

You don't sound that glad.

P5 Reviews

I am glad that your happy with your purchase, why wouldn't I be? I just fell that I should inform those of what they do sound like, from the perspective of someone who has tried countless headphones of all different price ranges. The reviews on there own site are more or less worthless to be honest, even bose gets some good reviews from people who don't have much knowledge of headphones.

Here's a thread with plenty of opinions on them, very few are positive (and the community was wanting to love them):
http://www.head-fi.org/forum/thread/...-p5-headphones


This is a post by skylab on that forum about the sound, I agree with everything he writes:

The P5 have a slightly muffled, muted sound, are lacking transparency, and are noticeably colored. They are maybe the darkest sounding headphones I have ever heard that were “real” headphones. The treble sounds very rolled off and lacks extension in a very noticeable way, even compared to headphones with a slightly soft treble like the JVC DX1000. As such, little musical details get lost. Cymbals don’t sound like they should – they are thrown almost behind your head since they are so muted.

The midrange is an enigma. There is definitely a lack of transparency to it. It’s lush, but there is a odd coloration I cannot quite describe to it. Some female vocals sound very good in a beautiful sort of way, but male vocals sound odd. And piano also sounds wrong – it fails to sound realistic. Patricia Barber's outstanding recordings have some of the most natural piano rendering I know of, and yet through the P5, they did not sound as I know they should.

The above two traits also lead to a lack of dynamics and good attack. The whole presentation comes across as slightly slow and soggy. It's been a long time since I listened to a headphone where I felt that the dynamics were so restricted. I guess I have become spoiled listening to headphones like the Beyer T1 and the Ultrasone Edition 8 - but the P5 didn't have the dynamics even of the PXC-350.

The bass is pretty strong, and generally good, but it lacks a little in terms of punch and definition. It’s not one-note, which is good, but it’s a little loose sounding. I have heard better defined bass in headphones costing less. I would say the bass performance is good, but not great. It has better weight than depth, too -- on Joan Armatrading's "Lover's Speak", which has some very deep bass during the chorus, this was less present than I expected it to be - the bass weight is mid-upper bass, not deep bass.

On some material, like Mae Moore’s “Love Will Bring You Back” from “It’s a Funny World”, this darkness didn’t really cause any major problems. I noticed the lack of top end extension because I am so familiar with the music, but it did not bother me, and Moore’s voice sounded good. Some tracks that are generally too bright to enjoy actually sounded great on the P5. But on other material, and especially male vocals, or music where there is musically important detailed treble, the colorations get in the way too much.

Two examples: David Gilmour's voice on "This Heaven" from "Like in Gdansk" is rendered in a muted way that is flatter and duller than it really sounds.

On the other hand, Johnny Nash's "I Can See Clearly Now" actually sounded GREAT, but that is a track that is normally is a very bright sounding. It sounded good in a way that it actually shouldn't

The lack of treble extension gives the headphones a little bit of a claustrophobic soundstage. The image isn’t all that well defined, and seems to cluster in the center of the head and around the ears, with very little forward projection and not much depth.

My main comparison was to the Sennheiser PXC350, as it’s similarly priced, and designed for the same basic application. All of my other headphones are in a much higher price/performance range. The PXC350’s are noise canceling, and as such they have a little bit of background noise when the NC circuit is on. The P5 have a blacker background. But that is the only advantage they have. The PXC350 sound better in every other way. They are more neutral, much more transparent, and have better treble extension, bass definition, and soundstaging than the P5 do. I no longer own them, but if memory serves me at all, I would say the Denon D1000/1001 outperform the P5 sonically. I wish I still had them so I could compare the two – but I’d be surprised if the P5’s outperform the Denons in terms of just sonics.

I don’t want to overplay this – it’s not like the P5 sound awful. But they are a very colored headphone, and you will have to really like their odd flavor to like them. It’s already clear that some people do, and that’s great. I have deep, deep respect for B&W. I absolutely love my B&W Nautilus 800’s. I had never owned a pair of speakers for more than 2 years before investing in the N800’s – and I have owned them for almost 10 years, and just yesterday I was listening to some nice vinyl through them and absolutely reveling in their sound. Unfortunately, B&W has a major miss with the P5, in my opinion. They could have been so much better, and they look so nice and are so well built, surely they could have made them more neutral sounding. It’s not like B&W doesn’t know what good sound is. I have a hard time imagining that they feel the P5 represent $300 worth of headphone sound. Maybe they needed to do more benchmarking.

In any case, unless you have a VERY bright set-up and want to radically change the sound of it in the other direction, I cannot recommend the P5’s at all. I think B&W needs to go back to the drawing board, or at a minimum, offer us a headphone at some point that better represents what their tradition dictates that they are capable of.

[J6P]

That's interesting but it is a board dedicated to extremely pricey setups and I haven't seen this opinion reflected in any professional reviews, and it isn't my experience.

They don't have the $1600 sound that you're accustomed to, but they certainly aren't putting out $30 sound as you stated earlier. That's just nonsense.

[Suntory_Times]

Originally Posted by supersix4

Do any others block noise as well? And could recommend some that you think do the job blocking noise as well

Sennhiesser hd25 II
Sennhiesser pxc350
Beyerdynamic dt880 (are big though)

Originally Posted by J6P

That's interesting but it is a board dedicated to extremely pricey setups and I haven't seen this opinion reflected in any professional reviews, and it isn't my experience.

They don't have the $1600 sound that you're accustomed to, but they certainly aren't putting out $30 sound as you stated earlier. That's just nonsense.

It's an opinion. Though p5's do have a unique sound sig that some will like, in terms of balance and neatrality the portapros, grado sr60's and many cheaper headphones are significantly better.