Stargate: SG-1 Vs SGA Vs SGU

[Gamma_Winstead]

Which is your favorite Stargate series?

It's a hard choice for me, but I'm going with SGA.

[Billz]

You know, if you were an actual stargate fan, then you wouldn't be pitching all 3 shows against each other.

SG-1, SGA and SGU all rock, aswell as the original movie. FACT!

[un4gvn94538]

as you probably would say im not a true fan, i cannot stand stu. sg1 was cool and im currently watching it on netflex and at season 5 right now. sg1 started sucking (for me) when mcgyver left. atlantis was cool too. i would have to say sg1 for the win for the years i liked it then atlantis. the thing that gets me is that they seem to try and regurgitate the same character types. that may work with some characters but not all and for every show.

[jja]

There were 3 posts before mine but only 1 vote ???

The movie was surpisingly very good, and SG-1 was great with a pretty good segway from the movie. SGA okay, I've never even seen SGU.

[naturephoto1]

My favorite was Stargate SG-1. I also really liked the original movie, particularly the release as the 15th Anniversary Ed.

Rich

[wickerjay]

Any who votes SGU should be banned.

[krazeyeyez]

Originally Posted by wickerjay

Any who votes SGU should be banned.

[MarcelS1]

I like them all but Richard Dean Anderson in SG-1 is the main reason I pick SG-1

[owa]

SG-1 is my favorite although I didn't like it quite as much once RDA left the show. It took me a bit to warm-up to SGA but then I really liked it as well. SGU is just too different so I really don't consider it a part of Stargate.

I wish they would have combined some of the casts from SG1 and SGA. For example, I think Joe Flanigan would have been a good replacement for Richard Dean Anderson. Reading on gateworld they said at one point they were considering a movie that combined all the casts. I think that would have been fun but oh well, guess all that is dead now.

[SpaceDog]

Stargate SG-1 by far. It's better than the theatrical film. Atlantis never gelled - it was decent, but definitely a retread of SG-1 without much of its own direction.
SGU just wasn't very good. I never cared about any of the characters.

[Arvin Clone]

I couldn't get enough of SG-1. It's definitely my favorite followed by Atlantis and SGU. I don't think SGU is as bad as some other people do. It's problem is it's so much different than the other two.

[FrellingFrakker]

I love SG-1. I'm currently watching it through yet again on DVD. It just never gets old. I really enjoy Atlantis as well and I'm very excited to see it coming out on Blu!

[MarcelS1]

Originally Posted by Arvin Clone

It's problem is it's so much different than the other two.

For me it was very important is was going to be different! It was darker, I loved it, although the first few episodes it had it's problems. I love all three but I'm still glad they didn't copy Universe from it's predecessors.

[Tony208]

Originally Posted by wickerjay

Any who votes SGU should be banned.

[SleeperAgent]

Having finished all 3 shows recently I will miss them. I even like SGU. I'm sad SGA and SGU won't really get proper endings for the unresolved plots.

[-RONIN-]

I don't know why but I like SGA the most.

[Groge511]

SGA because it's the one I got into first. Still love SG-1 though but haven't seen enough of it to really say. SGU was meh...

[arcadeforest]

Sg-1

[stevo4264]

Sg-1, the best of the lot