Godfather Trilogy or Kill bill 1 and 2

[animefan08]

Hi trying to decide which film to get next on blu ray for september preorder list and was wondering which you would recommend out of godfather trilogy or kill bill 1 and 2 thanks

[cartman781]

Thats a hard one, If you can save up and get both. If not get the Godfather then save up for kill Bill 1& 2

[MOONPHASE]

if i were you i would go with Kill Bill

[Rob71]

No question, Godfather Trilogy. And this is coming from a Tarantino fan who loves Kill Bill. The Godfather is just an epic story.

[BaronVH]

I have to say that I am somewhat depressed with the thought that the two would even be considered in the same sentence. The Godfather is a classic of historic preportions and will still be watched 100 years from now. Kill Bill is by far my least favorite Tarantino movie. I would rank his as Pulp Fiction, Reservoir Dogs, Jackie Brown, Grindhouse, and then Kill Bill. Don't get me wrong, I like Tarantino a lot as a director. I can't wait for Inglorious Bastards (hopefully the Germans will speak German in it), and I may be one of the few that really loved Grindhouse (the theatrical version, mind you). While I think Godfather 3 is certainly not up to the first two, I just don't see any question as to the comparison. Get Godfather or you will wake up with the fishes.

[animefan08]

ok thanks for the replies

[Kaldaim]

Originally Posted by BaronVH

I have to say that I am somewhat depressed with the thought that the two would even be considered in the same sentence.

get over it. people have different tastes in movies.


Regardless of what you choose, you can expect Kill Bill to get excellent blu-ray treatment from Miramax (disney/BV) and it will probably be the bigger blu-ray upgrade from the DVD given its style, age, and studio alone.

[DetroitSportsFan]

I've never seen Godfather (I will on Blu) so right now I say Kill Bill, but that could change.

[richieb1971]

Glad I'm fortunate enough not to have to make these kinds of decisions!

[theblueboat]

The Godfather. One of the best and the blu-ray is sure to be stellar.

I'm debating if I should wait for Kill Bill: The Whole Bloody Affair. I love both movies but I can't stand double dipping. I went through that too many times with DVDs and refuse to with blu-ray (I say that now but I know I'll do it).

[sfmarine]

I can't want to see the new restoration of the Godfather on Blu. I'd say get that! Kill Bill can wait and I'd also hold off until the whole bloody affair comes out...which will be sometime around when Star Wars makes it's mark on blu lol.

[gaeljet]

kill bill pack

[Blu Titan]

Godfather Trilogy first...not even close. Kill Bill later.

[GoBlu08]

Godfather. Kill Bill can wait.

[drobswim13]

Godfather first, then Kill Bill much later. No question

[Groo The Perverted]

can we ban anyone that voted Kill Bill over The Godfather Trilogy?

Please?

That's an offensive statement if I've ever heard/read one.

[MartinMan]

Godfather Trilogy, no doubt about it

[fdm]

Godfather for sure. [One of the few reasons I wish it was the end of September already. Actually, it's about the only reason. ]

Kill Bill, love it too, but me I already have the DVDs so I'm holding out for "The Whole Bloody Affair" if/when that ever makes it to blu-ray. Just not seeing it being worth another 40 bucks at this point in time. [Edit: Not that I really think 80 bucks is what Godfather Trilogy should be costing these days, but in this case it should be worth it.]

[wnicholas76]

If I were you, I'd pick The Godfather Trilogy. Because if it's not in your Blu-ray collection, then you don't have a Blu-ray collection!

[BaronVH]

Originally Posted by Kaldaim

get over it. people have different tastes in movies.


Regardless of what you choose, you can expect Kill Bill to get excellent blu-ray treatment from Miramax (disney/BV) and it will probably be the bigger blu-ray upgrade from the DVD given its style, age, and studio alone.

I agree that people have different tastes and that Kill Bill will be given a great treatment on Blu-ray, but my post was my way of giving my subjective opinion as to what to get. With more information of the person I could give a better recommendation. A 15 year old that is into the old cheesy kung-fu movies from the 70's: Kill Bill. A person with a deep affection of film as art or somebody that enjoyes complex crime dramas: Godfather. Clearly many people would enjoy one over the other and be right.