thread: Reviews PQ.
View Single Post
Old 03-05-2009, 08:14 AM   #1
Paganmoon Paganmoon is offline
Active Member
 
Paganmoon's Avatar
 
Feb 2008
Sweden
45
Default Reviews PQ.

Hi,

I was wondering if in further reviews (specially reviews of catalog titles), you could another column, in between the Picture quality and Audio quality.

As it is now most reviews simply state how the quality fares against other blu-rays, tho some reviews mention difference in quality to the DVD.

I think perticularly on the catalog titles, it would be great to add something like "DVD vs Blu-ray quality". Maybe getting the reviewer to check the DVD of the movie aswell. As some films might not look super on Blu-ray (compared to reference quality), but still look far superior to their DVD counterparts (whilst some don't look much better than upscaled DVD - See Full metal jacket).

As it is now, compared to reference quality, some movies might get quite low Picture quality ratings, but would still be a great upgrade in quality from the DVD, and it would be a nice addition imo.

Now I know, some will say blu-ray is always better, but point being, how much better than the DVD is the release.

/P
  Reply With Quote