Quote:
Originally Posted by Geoff D
Who says what it should or shouldn't have hit, aside from the people actually doing the grading? Low brightness HDR doesn't equal "fake HDR", it's an aesthetic choice that's been made and if the folks crying foul just said "I don't like dim HDR, I want everything to pop" then I'd have a lot more respect for them than when they try to justify their personal preferences behind a bunch of technobollocks and gatekeeping bullshit like how it looks worse on supermarket special HDR TVs, like they're the 'true voice' of HDR or something.
I literally laughed out loud when Vincent said of The Mandalorian that doing "proper" i.e. eyebrow-roastingly bright HDR.....
|
I mean, Im not really concerned with the mandalorian, it is what is. But in regards to the movies, if you grade the ST one way, and then release the other movies with completely different brightness ranges, that seems a bit out of place, no?
It almost seems like a waste of Dolby Vision, which who knows if it will be on disc anyhow. Im not saying the movies have to hit 10k nits, but I would expect the grading to be more in line with the movies that were already released in HDR.