View Single Post
Old 09-16-2021, 01:52 AM   #4011
KMFDMvsEnya KMFDMvsEnya is online now
Power Member
 
Jun 2014
UT
Default

ST - TWOK Director's Cut:
LRC+LFE are the same between the 16bit and 24bit tracks.

However with the surround channels they are 3dBs higher on the 24bit track and this sounds in better balance with the mains.

Personally, I could not hear a difference between them when listening to the main channels isolated nor soloing the LFE. The surround channels I can definitely hear the increased amplitude with the 24bit version but no improved fidelity.

Star Trek - TWOK 4K - 16bit DTHD
Code:
				Left		Right		Center		Low Frequency Effects	Left Surround	Right Surround	Left Surround Direct	Right Surround Direct
Peak Amplitude:			-3.06 dB	-2.23 dB	-0.39 dB	-10.25 dB		-11.12 dB	-6.30 dB	-9.88 dB		-5.67 dB
True Peak Amplitude:		-3.06 dBTP	-2.23 dBTP	-0.39 dBTP	-10.25 dBTP		-11.12 dBTP	-6.28 dBTP	-9.88 dBTP		-5.66 dBTP
Maximum Sample Value:		21776.00	22644.00	27400.00	9497.00			9104.69		15027.44	9842.94			16911.19
Minimum Sample Value:		-23048.00	-25348.00	-31320.00	-10064.00		-8536.25	-15873.13	-10500.50		-17066.81
Possibly Clipped Samples:	0		0		0		0			0		0		0			0
Total RMS Amplitude:		-31.98 dB	-30.50 dB	-28.24 dB	-45.61 dB		-41.57 dB	-41.48 dB	-41.57 dB		-41.21 dB
Maximum RMS Amplitude:		-11.83 dB	-9.90 dB	-9.55 dB	-14.86 dB		-17.83 dB	-14.13 dB	-16.47 dB		-12.46 dB
Minimum RMS Amplitude:		-75.85 dB	-83.18 dB	-90.24 dB	-96.51 dB		-88.17 dB	-92.16 dB	-95.72 dB		-97.49 dB
Average RMS Amplitude:		-44.56 dB	-41.96 dB	-39.66 dB	-73.91 dB		-52.35 dB	-53.31 dB	-53.20 dB		-53.54 dB
DC Offset:			0.02 %		-0.01 %		0.00 %		0.01 %			-0.01 %		-0.01 %		0.00 %			0.00 %
Measured Bit Depth:		20		20		20		16			20		20		20			20
Dynamic Range:			64.02 dB	73.28 dB	80.69 dB	81.65 dB		70.34 dB	78.03 dB	79.24 dB		85.04 dB
Dynamic Range Used:		55.05 dB	56.85 dB	61.70 dB	63.10 dB		59.70 dB	63.05 dB	67.95 dB		70.25 dB
Loudness (Legacy):		-25.33 dB	-24.13 dB	-23.70 dB	-36.20 dB		-37.10 dB	-33.86 dB	-36.35 dB		-36.03 dB
Perceived Loudness (Legacy):	-22.18 dB	-20.56 dB	-21.43 dB	-34.41 dB		-33.26 dB	-31.08 dB	-33.93 dB		-33.38 dB
ITU-R BS.1770-3 Loudness:	-22.96 LUFS



Star Trek - TWOK 2K - 24bit DTHD
Code:
				Left		Right		Center		Low Frequency Effects	Left Surround	Right Surround	Left Surround Direct	Right Surround Direct
Peak Amplitude:			-3.06 dB	-2.23 dB	-0.39 dB	-10.04 dB		-8.11 dB	-3.29 dB	-6.87 dB		-2.66 dB
True Peak Amplitude:		-3.06 dBTP	-2.23 dBTP	-0.39 dBTP	-10.04 dBTP		-8.11 dBTP	-3.27 dBTP	-6.87 dBTP		-2.65 dBTP
Maximum Sample Value:		21774.61	22641.92	27400.82	9789.88			12879.00	21252.09	13923.89		23916.82
Minimum Sample Value:		-23048.60	-25348.58	-31322.96	-10310.30		-12074.07	-22445.85	-14850.18		-24135.91
Possibly Clipped Samples:	0		0		0		0			0		0		0			0
Total RMS Amplitude:		-31.97 dB	-30.50 dB	-28.24 dB	-45.30 dB		-38.56 dB	-38.46 dB	-38.56 dB		-38.20 dB
Maximum RMS Amplitude:		-11.83 dB	-9.90 dB	-9.52 dB	-14.68 dB		-14.82 dB	-11.11 dB	-13.46 dB		-9.44 dB
Minimum RMS Amplitude:		-75.85 dB	-83.18 dB	-90.23 dB	-98.44 dB		-85.17 dB	-89.16 dB	-92.74 dB		-94.49 dB
Average RMS Amplitude:		-44.56 dB	-41.95 dB	-39.66 dB	-73.48 dB		-49.34 dB	-50.30 dB	-50.18 dB		-50.52 dB
DC Offset:			0.02 %		-0.01 %		0.00 %		0.01 %			-0.02 %		-0.02 %		0.00 %			0.00 %
Measured Bit Depth:		24		24		24		24			24		24		24			24
Dynamic Range:			64.02 dB	73.28 dB	80.71 dB	83.77 dB		70.35 dB	78.05 dB	79.28 dB		85.05 dB
Dynamic Range Used:		55.05 dB	56.80 dB	61.70 dB	63.35 dB		59.70 dB	63.10 dB	67.95 dB		70.25 dB
Loudness (Legacy):		-25.33 dB	-24.41 dB	-25.02 dB	-34.12 dB		-34.10 dB	-30.62 dB	-33.35 dB		-33.23 dB
Perceived Loudness (Legacy):	-22.18 dB	-20.56 dB	-21.43 dB	-33.68 dB		-30.26 dB	-28.04 dB	-30.95 dB		-30.39 dB
ITU-R BS.1770-3 Loudness:	-22.65 LUFS


https://imgur.com/a/nWobfcQ

Last edited by KMFDMvsEnya; 09-16-2021 at 02:24 AM. Reason: Director's Cut
  Reply With Quote
Thanks given by:
bbeck (09-16-2021), BillieCassin (09-16-2021), bleakassassin (09-16-2021), Geoff D (09-16-2021), IronWaffle (09-16-2021), Jason One (09-16-2021), malakay (09-16-2021), Maxwell Everett (09-16-2021), Pagey123 (09-16-2021), rickardl (09-16-2021), Tshane72 (09-17-2021)