Quote:
Originally Posted by Croweyes1121
Maybe that says more about the poor mixing of other films rather than this one, but it isn’t consistent. Sometimes it’s fine…the place I really noticed it was when Kirk arrived at Starfleet Headquarters. His dialogue sounded far too loud and pinpoint to be in a wide shot in an open space like that.
|
The new mixing in that scene didn't work for me at all. They basically removed nearly all of the background noise so you could hear Kirk more clearly, but now it sounds totally unnatural. In fact it sounds so "canned" and clear that it's like you're in the ADR room with the actors and not in an expansive surrounding with people all around them.
Also I didn't feel the compositing in that scene was very good either. I can't do screen shots but it's a case where the new matte work is hardly an improvement on the old matte work.