Quote:
Originally Posted by dixonhill
Really, you guys are so desperately clinging to your arguments and opinions
but to me it seems you gain absolutely nothing from it.
There is just no final and in a manner of speaking "binding" solution!
I'm not trying to patronize anyone in this thread,
but regarding the never ending discussion of film grain or no film grain,
what about thinking of it as a kind of a generation gap?
|
Because it isn't!
This *isn't* a matter of opinion I'm afraid. The movie is the movie. What exists on that camera negative is God! To get maximum quality from that negative requires talent and artistic integrity. To hack at it with computer software that doesn't recognise blue skies from blue shirts is entirely inappropriate.
To quote Dixon Hill (aka Captain Picard): "The line must be drawn here!"