Blu-ray Forum - View Single Post - Blu-ray Rating System Criteria Adjustment?

Spicoli · 03-27-2013, 04:26 AM

I've been following this site since the Blu/Red war and I love the reviews that the writers write.
But I feel the "Five" incremental scale is not accurate enough.

More especially the PQ. I'll see a move that is rated a 4.5 and another one that was "rated" 4.5 and i agree they are both superior, but one was better.

Are you happy with the 5 part rating system?

I just watched Lawrence of Arabia and that now just raised the bar. Yes it is a 5 and so is Pi, but Lawrence looks better IMO of course.

Thoughts?

03-27-2013, 04:26 AM	#1
Spicoli Blu-ray Guru Member since:Sep 2010 Location:East of Seattle Trading Score:5	Blu-ray Rating System Criteria Adjustment? I've been following this site since the Blu/Red war and I love the reviews that the writers write. But I feel the "Five" incremental scale is not accurate enough. More especially the PQ. I'll see a move that is rated a 4.5 and another one that was "rated" 4.5 and i agree they are both superior, but one was better. Are you happy with the 5 part rating system? I just watched Lawrence of Arabia and that now just raised the bar. Yes it is a 5 and so is Pi, but Lawrence looks better IMO of course. Thoughts?