Sin City question

[ihabfan]

there are so many versions of sin city, on with all characters but 1 disc, one with all the recut extended, and one with jessica alba, which one has the best transfer? thx

[TheZoof]

I rented the one with extended cut and I own the Alliance. I prefer the Alliance release in both ways. Only problem is no extras on Alliance.

Get the one you want as I think the transfers are very similar.

[Rhylliam]

The Alliance 2-disc set w/ Jessica Alba slipcover has the better transfer, taken from the US 2-disc release.

[risingstar]

Originally Posted by Rhylliam

The Alliance 2-disc set w/ Jessica Alba slipcover has the better transfer, taken from the US 2-disc release.

Is this the extended?


P.S. Why the companies release different transfers is beyond me to explain.

P.P.S. Is the transfer diffrence that noticeable?

[zeze]

Originally Posted by risingstar

Is this the extended?


P.S. Why the companies release different transfers is beyond me to explain.

P.P.S. Is the transfer diffrence that noticeable?

Yes, the one with Jessica Alba on the cover is the extended version.

Companies release different transfers because they hope people will double-dip thus getting them more money.

I can't answer your third question as I have never seen any other transfers except the one with Jessica Alba on the front cover.

[kdawq]

Anything with Jessica Alba on the cover is a good release...

[boxterduke]

Originally Posted by Rhylliam

The Alliance 2-disc set w/ Jessica Alba slipcover has the better transfer, taken from the US 2-disc release.

Originally Posted by risingstar

Is this the extended?
P.S. Why the companies release different transfers is beyond me to explain.
P.P.S. Is the transfer difference that noticeable?

Yes the one with Jessica Alba on the Lenticular slipcover is the better transfer as Rhylliam said.
You need the one with 1.85:1 ratio and not 1.78:1

This one https://forum.blu-ray.com/attachment...1&d=1249497497
Pic pulled from this thread https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread...highlight=city

The original movie is on the first disk.
On the second disk, you have the extended version in the form of sperate stories.
So each story is alone and you can watch them one by one and each has extra scenes.

[risingstar]

Originally Posted by boxterduke

Yes the one with Jessica Alba on the Lenticular slipcover is the better transfer as Rhylliam said.
You need the one with 1.85:1 ratio and not 1.78:1

This one https://forum.blu-ray.com/attachment...1&d=1249497497
Pic pulled from this thread https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread...highlight=city

The original movie is on the first disk.
On the second disk, you have the extended version in the form of sperate stories.
So each story is alone and you can watch them one by one and each has extra scenes.

Sheesh... I really need to pay more attention to those details.
You guys are the wikipedia of bluray.
Most of us are walking blind out there... lol.

[boxterduke]

Originally Posted by risingstar

Sheesh... I really need to pay more attention to those details.
You guys are the wikipedia of bluray.
Most of us are walking blind out there... lol.

I was the same until I stumbled at this site and now I tend to check here first and at AVS forums as well before buying anything.
Give it time and you will be the same