Gremlins vs Gremlins 2: The New Batch

[kylor]

Which one will come out on top? Vote now!

[CyberpunkCentral]

Original. Second feels like a spoof or something.

[Winslow Leach]

Gremlins 2: The New Batch

[DR Herbert West]

The New Batch

[Troll2fan]

First one. Second one had very few redeeming qualities.

[Mikezilla3k]

New Batch.

[Gizz]

As a kid I would of said Gremlins 2: The New Batch but as a adult I like Gremlins a little better don't get me wrong they are both fantastic.

[traths]

Gremlins

[liamjaco1998]

The original is a dark horror Christmas classic I’m planning to slip it in this Christmas to add a little darkness to the season. The sequel is an entirely different thing, it’s better on a technical level and talent involved on really up there. Gremlins 2 is a cult classic in so many ways, it’s Joe Dante’s baby basically.

[thecooldud]

I accidentally voted for 2. Don't count that one.

It's the original. A Christmas classic. Never fathomed people preferring the second one - it lacks almost everything that makes the original great, and isn't really that funny either.

[dallywhitty]

They're pretty much on par for me, but I'd give the edge to the original for its cosy Christmas atmosphere.

[L.J.]

Like them both equally but my vote goes to the original.

[BluRayTim]

Neither has aged well in my opinion but the first and it’s not even close.

[J999]

Love them both. The first is a more solid story, and I watch it every Christmas, but the second is funnier and has better special effects.

Its kind of a draw and depends on my mood ...but I went with the second, just because I figured the first would get most of the votes.

[Michael24]

The sequel is fun, but I've always preferred the first. It was also one of the first movies I ever saw in the theater.

[stvn1974]

First but both are classics.

[JediJones77]

Gremlins. The unrealistic jokes in the second one ruin the believability of the fairy tale story.

[Dark City Denizen]

I knew I’d be going uphill but the sequel got my vote. Both great movies but the second one is so inventive & the comedy so wildly funny. I mean, the Hulkster in a movie theatre addressing Gremlins who’ve eaten the projector? It’s so creatively entertaining & the movie never levels off with that stuff.

First movie is excellent but has always felt just a little on the over-rated side to me.

[Alan T]

Gremlins

[Cruel Angel]

Gremlins