Top 25 comic book movies of all time

[ArmyOfDarknessAW]

IGN link
IGN rated the top 25 comic book movies here is the list in descending order.

25. The Rocketeer
24. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
23. The Crow
22. Hellboy
21. Blade
20. Batman Returns
19. Men In Black
18. Superman 2
17. Ghost World
16. Dick Tracy
15. Sin City
14. American Splendor
13. Watchmen
12. Kick-Ass
11. 300
10. A History Of Violence
09. Batman: The Mask Of Phantasm
08. Spider-Man
07. X2: X-Men United
06. Iron Man
05. Batman Begins
04. Road To Perdition
03. Superman: The Movie
02. Spider-Man 2
01. The Dark Knight

It's an interesting list i like and love many on the list but i think it would be in a different order if i did it.

[csdot]

only thing i think should be on there thats not is Oldboy
could definitely replace Dick Tracy

[ArmyOfDarknessAW]

Originally Posted by csdot

only thing i think should be on there thats not is Oldboy
could definitely replace Dick Tracy

I am actually a fan of Dick Tracy but the list could use Iron Man 2.

[tommyboy81]

I'm just glad Spawn isn't on there and LXG

[ArmyOfDarknessAW]

Originally Posted by tommyboy81

I'm just glad Spawn isn't on there and LXG

They where both fun movies IMO but don't belong anywhere near a top 25 list.

[tommyboy81]

Guess I have to find this one

09. Batman: The Mask Of Phantasm

[csdot]

Originally Posted by tommyboy81

Guess I have to find this one

09. Batman: The Mask Of Phantasm

GREAT movie, especially if you enjoyed the show. one of those movies i really consider myself lucky for having seen it theatrically.

[Beast]

The two modern Nolan films shouldn't be on there. But the original Burton film should be.

[ArmyOfDarknessAW]

Originally Posted by Beast

The two modern Nolan films shouldn't be on there. But the original Burton film should be.

You don't think TDK is a top 25?

[Beast]

Originally Posted by ArmyOfDarknessAW

You don't think TDK is a top 25?

No. I think the movie was terrible. Nothing worked for me.

From Bale's gravel gargling Batman Growl, the lackluster Joker, to the tediously boring story, etc.

I can go into detail, but I don't want to drag the thread off on a tangent.

[Lepidopterous]

Originally Posted by Beast

No. I think the movie was terrible. Nothing worked for me.

From Bale's gravel gargling Batman Growl, the lackluster Joker, to the tediously boring story, etc.

I can go into detail, but I don't want to drag the thread off on a tangent.

What do you find terrible about Batman Begins?

[Beast]

Originally Posted by DjMethod

What do you find terrible about Batman Begins?

A boring tedious crime drama with the Bale trying to cosplay as Batman.

[ArmyOfDarknessAW]

Originally Posted by Beast

No. I think the movie was terrible. Nothing worked for me.

From Bale's gravel gargling Batman Growl, the lackluster Joker, to the tediously boring story, etc.

I can go into detail, but I don't want to drag the thread off on a tangent.

Originally Posted by Beast

A boring tedious crime drama with the Bale trying to cosplay as Batman.

Wow you really don't like them. I happen to love them but i respect your opinion.

[GLaDOS]

Originally Posted by ArmyOfDarknessAW

IGN link
IGN rated the top 25 comic book movies here is the list in descending order.

25. The Rocketeer
24. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
23. The Crow
22. Hellboy
21. Blade
20. Batman Returns
19. Men In Black
18. Superman 2
17. Ghost World
16. Dick Tracy
15. Sin City
14. American Splendor
13. Watchmen
12. Kick-Ass
11. 300
10. A History Of Violence
09. Batman: The Mask Of Phantasm
08. Spider-Man
07. X2: X-Men United
06. Iron Man
05. Batman Begins
04. Road To Perdition
03. Superman: The Movie
02. Spider-Man 2
01. The Dark Knight

It's an interesting list i like and love many on the list but i think it would be in a different order if i did it.

I think Superman 2 should be a bit higher. Decent list, but still not that great.

[Lepidopterous]

Originally Posted by Beast

A boring tedious crime drama with the Bale trying to cosplay as Batman.

Fair enough. I feel bad for you though honestly that you can't enjoy a film like that (I hope that doesn't offend you). I know everyone has different tastes though.

[Beast]

Originally Posted by DjMethod

Fair enough. I feel bad for you though honestly that you can't enjoy a film like that (I hope that doesn't offend you). I know everyone has different tastes though.

Don't feel bad for me. I have at least 3 good Batman films.

Batman: The Movie, Batman (1989), and Batman Returns. I'm good.

[Batman1980]

Honestly? This list sucks and that's not IGN's fault, there aren't enough good comic book films yet to make a top 25 list.

[SixSpeedSamurai]

Originally Posted by Beast

No. I think the movie was terrible. Nothing worked for me.

From Bale's gravel gargling Batman Growl, the lackluster Joker, to the tediously boring story, etc.

I can go into detail, but I don't want to drag the thread off on a tangent.

Ah OK, Nolan has been far truer to comics than Burton ever cared to be. Not to start a arguement, but it sounds like you got it in for the Nolan films. It's hard to deny them as good films. They probably are ont superhero movies though when it comes down to it.

Anyway, glad Mask of the Phantasm is on there. I think Spider-Man 2 is way too high on the list. While I do like Batman Returns, it does not belong over Batman '89.

[Beast]

Originally Posted by Gandalf Stormcrow

Honestly? This list sucks and that's not IGN's fault, there aren't enough good comic book films yet to make a top 25 list.

Nah. It really is IGN's fault. Half the time they don't know what they're yammering on about.

[Beast]

Originally Posted by SixSpeedSamurai

Ah OK, Nolan has been far truer to comics than Burton ever cared to be.

No. He was true to one incarnation of the comics. As Burton was as well.

It's just that Burton's films are actually good. And Nolan's are terrible.

But then, he hasn't done anything good outside of Memento.

So yeah, I can easily deny them as good movies. Because they are not.