Sub Dilema So Many Choices HELPPPP!!!!!

[4TA23]

Ok I am on the fence for a sub:

VTF-2 MK 3 HSU
VTF-1 HSU
PB10-NSD SVS
A2-300 Elemental Design

Price is a factor for me obviously and I have the wife factor on this price. I know she will let me get the eD especially for the price and I can probably push her into the SVS and VTF-1 price range hard pressed on the Top choice up there. What do you guys think is the eD the best bang for the buck or will I get more out of the SVS or HSU for a little more money. Lokking for tight base both for movies and music but more for movies. my JBL I have now is very boomy, I like the boom and want to feel it just want nice boom not all muddy.


My room is very open have one of those open floor plans but for some odd reason I get excellent base response where my crappy JBL is now see link below for my set up, your guess is as good as mine how I can feel base in my main seat with sub positioned where it is.

https://www.blu-ray.com/community/gal...p?member=4TA23

I posted this at AVS also and got no help, I find the folks here to be alot more friendly and helpful and not so snobby, help me out guys.

Special thanks to Big Daddy for all his wonderful info he has shared with all of us here and he never talks down to you, very humble and oh so knowledgeable. Chime away...