Is It Han Shot First (or)Greedo Shot First

[IndefinentBlu]

Which do you think it is??

For me i say WHO CARES!!

[JJ]

Dude.

OBVIOUSLY, George Lucas shot first.

[OG Pooh]

It should be Han.

1: I refuse to believe Greedo could have possibly missed with that setup. Had he truly shot first, Han would be dead.

2: Han was a rouge, a scoundrel, a criminal, a pirate, etc. He knew what was about to happen. Of course (given the opportunity) he shot first.

Plotwise, this was the biggest mistake GL made when altering the OT. Visually, that honor would have to go to Jabba in ANH.

[Jezza]

I'll just go with the flow and say Han.

[dag]

I distinctly remember Han firing first. That's what happened when I saw the movie at the theatre - the weekend it opened.

[blu-mike]

lol anyone see the justified season 2 promo

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wVT0B3pPsa8

[Beta Man]

I don't understand the question....... is it "what I prefer" ???

Who shot first is completely dependent on what version you're watching, i.e. pre/post Lucas-editing.

What do I prefer??? It doesn't matter... I think I've seen the film enough times to not have my views of Han being "Good" or "Bad" or anywhere in-between, changed at this point.

[GLaDOS]

Ahem.... obviously I shot first.

[Show spoiler]Han shot first.

[newginafets]

i think i'm lost.

if it's a movie i'm sure i haven't watched it.

[IndefinentBlu]

Originally Posted by newginafets

i think i'm lost.

if it's a movie i'm sure i haven't watched it.

It refers to the movie Star Wars there is a debate on whether Han solo shot first or Greedo shot first.

[720pDude]

I never viewed Han Solo as being so far off the mark as a criminal that he would shoot first. Im glad Lucas changed it. Han giving a defensive shot as opposed to offensive one fits much more into the charactor

[newginafets]

Originally Posted by IndefinentBlu

It refers to the movie Star Wars there is a debate on whether Han solo shot first or Greedo shot first.

i knew it. I've never seen any Star Wars movies!

[dallywhitty]

There's a debate? I thought it was clear that Han shot first and Lucas is a moron?

[OG Pooh]

Originally Posted by 720pDude

I never viewed Han Solo as being so far off the mark as a criminal that he would shoot first. Im glad Lucas changed it. Han giving a defensive shot as opposed to offensive one fits much more into the charactor

Do you also think he's stupid enough to not know that Greedo is about to shoot him? Han's character at that point in time was that of a criminal. Was he an all-out thug? No, but he was a criminal who was not only pirating, but was running from other criminals as well. Shooting to kill someone who's about to kill him is not at all off the mark. It wasn't even particularly frowned upon in the bar they were in.

[Duffy12]

[OG Pooh]

Originally Posted by Duffy12

Where can I buy that shirt?.. Seriously.

[perdition]

I'm going to go with who cares.

[MaCruz]

Alright fellas. Let's be good

[720pDude]

Originally Posted by OG Pooh

Do you also think he's stupid enough to not know that Greedo is about to shoot him? Han's character at that point in time was that of a criminal. Was he an all-out thug? No, but he was a criminal who was not only pirating, but was running from other criminals as well. Shooting to kill someone who's about to kill him is not at all off the mark. It wasn't even particularly frowned upon in the bar they were in.

eh..to each his own. I like the change

[ImportFanatic]

^George Lucas?