John Carter of Mars

[dirkblack]

Had a look and couldn't find a Thread for this, which I thought was odd considering it's out Monday.

Is it really that bad

John Carter Blu-ray PRE-ORDER



John Carter 3D Blu-ray PRE-ORDER

[BellesBiggestFan]

No, it's quite good actually.

[dirkblack]

Originally Posted by BellesBiggestFan

No, it's quite good actually.

Oh good, I'm hoping HMV ship it out tonight, I have gone with the 3D Version, although I've heard the 3d's not up to much.

[mckee74]

Got mine on order from Amazon when they had the 3D version for £16 briefly. Really looking forward to watching it.

Still rather hoping that the 3D version comes with a slip.

[Gizz]

Originally Posted by dirkblack

Had a look and couldn't find a Thread for this, which I thought was odd considering it's out Monday.

Is it really that bad

For me i found it boring.

[Torgon]

It's better than the reviews IMO. If you like a decent popcorn flick this is pretty good.

[Nommag]

Originally Posted by Torgon

It's better than the reviews IMO. If you like a decent popcorn flick this is pretty good.

The reviews were tainted by everyone proclaiming this would flop even a month before the release. It was far better than plenty of higher rated films.

[dirkblack]

Originally Posted by Nommag

The reviews were tainted by everyone proclaiming this would flop even a month before the release. It was far better than plenty of higher rated films.

I must admit, I am looking forward to it, I just wish HMV would hurry up and send it, they are usually quite good.

[duggie walker]

I thought it had a really pleasant old-fashioned feel to it. The film it most reminded me of was the 1980 FLASH GORDON, which I kind-of love (though JOHN CARTER is far less campy). The campaign against it was pretty inexplicable, if you ask me, and more than likely a bit of Hollywood politics.

It's one of the best blockbusters so far this year, far superior to SNOW WHITE AND THE HUNTSMAN or WRATH OF THE TITANS. And though it's not really comparable, it's far more successful on its own terms than PROMETHEUS, imo.

Taylor Kitsch comes in for a lot of stick but he's a much more attractive presence than Sam Worthington. The visuals are imaginative and unusual, the story is coherent and the framing device gives it a unique spin.

And the 3D is fine, no better or worse than most. If it wasn't for the fact that some people seem to take against it, I'd say it was a reasonably safe blind-buy for genre fans.

[Dickieduvet]

HMV posted mine this morning, Blind buy for me but loved the Marvel comics from the 70's so know what to expect!

[beadelf]

its far better than reviews state, i enjoyed watching it at cinema, it was definatly fun.

i wouldnt buy it but i would definatly watch it again.

[dirkblack]

Originally Posted by Dickieduvet

HMV posted mine this morning, Blind buy for me but loved the Marvel comics from the 70's so know what to expect!

I just called HMV who told me that have 100 on order and NONE have been sent out yet, as they have not received them from the Supplier.

When I told him there were Members on here who had got them sent, he seemed a little Flustered, I don't see why they feel the need to lie.

[Sinthetic]

Surprisingly good film, very fun. Definitely one to pick up on the cheap.

[Boomstick_316]

Mine has been sent too.

[3Dizzle]

Just checked my account and it's status is still “waiting for stock from supplier”

[dirkblack]

Originally Posted by 3Dizzle

Just checked my account and it's status is still “waiting for stock from supplier”

Same here, the rep on the phone said, he thought it would be tomorrow morning now, which is fine it should still arrive Saturday.

Mine is the 3D version though, so maybe that's the hold up?

[Dickieduvet]

Hi RICHARD

One of the items from your order is in the post and should be with you soon. If you've pre-ordered, we'll aim to get it to you on the day of release (UK deliveries only).
Qty Format Artist Title Price Estimated Delivery
1 BLU STANTON-DIR, ANDREW: MARK STRO JOHN CARTER £12.80 2-5 days




Proof that HMV are telling porkies!!

[chip75]

Looking forward to watching this. I was hoping for a Frank Frazetta style romp but it is a Disney film after all looking for a maximum audience.

If the price is right I'll pick it up Monday.

[Dharma572]

Mine's dispatched, along with the Batman Begins/Dark Knight steelbook!!

[Pork Chop Express]

Originally Posted by dirkblack

I just called HMV who told me that have 100 on order and NONE have been sent out yet, as they have not received them from the Supplier.

When I told him there were Members on here who had got them sent, he seemed a little Flustered, I don't see why they feel the need to lie.

You rang up HMV this morning to moan about why they haven't despatched a title that isn't released till next Monday?I know they post early but a little patience is required sometimes.The HMV bloke wasn't flustered,he was probably just amazed that some people have a lot of time to spare...