POTC: Dead Man's Chest... WTF?

[Blu Falcon]

Okay, I was straddling the fence for the longest, and this is the movie that finally pushed me over the edge. When I walked into Circuit City or Best Buy and saw this movie being used as a demo on the display monitors I was totally blown away. I mean, the picture quality was unreal. I really felt like I could reach out and touch the tentacles when the Kraken was attacking the ship. The motion was buttery smooth and fluid, and the surreal image looked like it was shot in HD live and was broadcast right there in front of me. Needless to say I had to add this disc to my collection when I finally broke down and went blu. However, when viewing it at home it doesn't quite have that same effect I just described. I'm viewing it at full 1080 using a PS3 and 42" Regza. Now before you go bashing my HDTV because it's a Toshiba let me say that movies like Cars and Casino Royale look absolutely incredible. So which leads me back to the film. I know this movie is absolutely incredible in high def, but for some reason it just seems a bit... flat? It's not really that surreal high definition 3-D effect I witnessed when I saw it playing on display that made me fall in love with HD. Any ideas?