A freaky coincidence, or something else?

[MifuneFan]

So my gf and I like to play what I call "the guessing game" on the phone, where we think of a number or a card between 1 and 100 and have the other person guess it. I kind of feel like I have ESP, and my mom does too. We've done this successfully numerous times, but last night was particularly interesting.

Test 1: My number was 53, her guess was 54
Test 2: My card was 3 of Clubs, her guess was 4 of Clubs
Test 3: Her card was 9 of Diamonds, I guessed 9 of Diamonds

With that last one, I saw 9 of Diamonds flash before me, and it just came out.

So anyway, I decided to up the ante and have us guess a number between 1 and a million, which we've never tried before.

Her number: 374,826
My number: 248,683

So obviously not the same, but you can see similarities in the digits. Now, here's what happens if you put the digits in numerical order:

Her number: 234,678
My number: 234,688

To me, I feel the probability of that happening is more than just a mere coincidence, especially after the success of the more simpler guessing games earlier. I know there's a thing where if you're looking for connections you'll find it, but I'm just not sure.

What's everyone's thoughts on this?