Grade Comic films(and non superhero comic adaptions)

[mdtulp]

Ok, comic films are getting so much better and better I thought Id post my grades for all comic adaptions,post your own if you want , heres mine

A+
Iron Man
Spider Man 2
Batman Begins

A
Spiderman
X-Men
Superman: The Movie

A-
Superman II
300

B+
Batman (1991)
Sin City
Blade

B
From Hell
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer
Road to Perdition
Hellboy

B-
The Punisher( Thomas Jane)
Constantine
Swamp Thing (1982?)

C+
X-Men 3
Spiderman 3
Fantastic Four
Batman Returns
Superman Retuns
Batman:The Movie(66)

C
Ghost Rider
Batman Forever
The Punisher ( Dolph)
Blade II

C-
DareDevil
Superman III
The Hulk

D(no + or -, a D is a D)
Superman IV
Captain America
Blade III

F
Batman and Robin
Elektra


Did I forget any?

[Beta Man]

I'm not a big fan of the Genre.... but as far as the order you have them in, I more or less agree I guess? All of the original Superman movies are towards the top for me, and the first Batman is an "A" if anything is

[rebfandan]

Slight disagreement. Superman IV should be an F. I borrowed my brother's copy over the weekend and watched that turd out of sheer morbid curiosity. Oh my God! There could be an entire thread dedicated to all that is wrong with that movie. One point of consolation: it could have been much worse. After watching the deleted scenes, I was actually thankful to watch the theatrical cut. Good Lord, how awful.

[Marine Mike]

Son of the Mask
Catwoman
Garfield the Movie
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
Pathfinder
Virus
Monkeybone
Judge Dredd
Alien vs. Predator
Alien vs. Predator 2
Bulletproof Monk
The Crow: City of Angels
Steel
Supergirl
Howard the Duck
Spawn
TMNT
Richie Rich
Dennis the Menace
Barb Wire
The Shadow
Men in Black
Men in Black II
Tank Girl
The Phantom
Casper
Timecop
The Addams Family
Popeye
From Hell
Heavy Metal
Mystery Men
The Rocketeer
Dick Tracy

[aramis109]

Forgot Spawn. Which... I'd put in the D's. It was really bad.

Not a bad list. I really like Hellboy and Constantine and would've put those as higher but I'm sure everyone has those that they disagree with.

[Clark Kent]

Pretty good ratings. I would've rated Daredevil(the director's cut) and Constantine higher.

[Nameless Evil]

V for Vendetta [A] - Epic Fail for missing that one
Generation X (1996) [D]
Supergirl (1984) [D]

[jadedeath]

Captain America getting a worse grade than Superman Returns?

I'm not going to say that kids attention spans can be bought with a hefty chunk of CGI nowadays but come ON!

At least the Captain America movie not only

A} didn't f**k with the costume, but:
B} followed almost exactly the plotline of the character

Captain America was a FAR superior movie to Superman Returns. Period. End of Statement. Discussion ended.

This is not an opinion, it is simple fact. Captain America didn't have an egomaniac writer penciling in children that the character didn't have in a gin-induced hooker rage.

Logan

[mdtulp]

I knew i would forget some, and I just bought V

[savage1984]

Originally Posted by mdtulp

I knew i would forget some, and I just bought V

great flick, I think my favorite that came out that year

[M]

I actually really enjoyed the Spawn movie, I would like to own it on Blu-Ray.

[savage1984]

Originally Posted by M

I actually really enjoyed the Spawn movie, I would like to own it on Blu-Ray.

you may be the only one....

[cajmoyper]

Constantine is an A to me. I would put Iron Man as a B-. Didn't live up to the hype, there wasn't enough of him in his red and gold suit. But they definitely made Gwyneth Paltrow look hot.

[savage1984]

Originally Posted by cajmoyper

Constantine is an A to me. I would put Iron Man as a B-. Didn't live up to the hype, there wasn't enough of him in his red and gold suit. But they definitely made Gwyneth Paltrow look hot.

I liked them both A LOT!

[M]

Originally Posted by savage1984

you may be the only one....

Maybe, but that doesn't bother me. I just like the movie, the whole dark fantasy style is great.

[Chris60119]

Dare Devil should of been rated Try Again. Try it with out Ben Can't Act.

[savage1984]

Originally Posted by M

Maybe, but that doesn't bother me. I just like the movie, the whole dark fantasy style is great.

i was just messin' with you man.

[AlexG]

How about this: The Top 10 worst movies Comic Related

1. Howard The Duck
2. Super Girl
3. SuperMan IV
4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III (or all 3)
5. Tank Girl
6. Batman & Robin
7. Judge Dredd
8. SuperMan III
9. Catwomen
10. The Phantom

Others: Spawn, Mystery Men

[M]

Originally Posted by savage1984

i was just messin' with you man.

Yeah, I got it.

Originally Posted by AlexG

How about this: The Top 10 worst movies Comic Related

1. Howard The Duck
2. Super Girl
3. SuperMan IV
4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III (or all 3)
5. Tank Girl
6. Batman & Robin
7. Judge Dredd
8. SuperMan III
9. Catwomen
10. The Phantom

Others: Spawn, Mystery Men

Howard the Duck, something I've heard alot about and everyone I know who has seen it has told me they loved it.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles I and II were great, the third movie was OK but not as good.

Catwoman was terrible, although for some reason I have seen it 2 or 3 times now.

Mystery Men actually put me to sleep years ago when I tried to watch it.

[GreenScar]

30 Days of Night was a Graphic Novel