Which version do you choose?

[camper]

I'm not looking for a PS3 vs Xbox debate, but I know there are a few people on the boards who have both systems so that's who I'm asking.

To be clear, if all you have to contribute is anti-microsoft, anti-sony, or any variation of "I would never buy" or "I do not allow [insert system] in my house" or even mention the word 'fanboy' then you've got nothing useful to say so please be cool and keep out

There are a lot of great games out and coming out, and it seems like only the BIG games are sometimes given the side by side review. Grand Theft Auto IV, COD4, Burnout Paradise and a couple others come to mind. Is there a site which goes through ALL (or at least the majority) of the dual console games to compare them side by side?

If not, what makes you decide to get say...Lego Batman on the PS3 vs the 360, or vice versa?

camper

[Monkey]

When I had both (360 fried and I sold the replacement) I simply checked out user reviews as well as some professional.

ES:IV for example is far better on the PS3 (I actually double dipped on that one).

Pro Evolution Soccer 2008 played much better on the PS3 as well due to the d-pad being horrible on the 360.

Virtua Fighter 5 - better on the 360

A lot of the early sports games are better on the 360 but the current ones seem to be even from what I've played on both. Same with the Tom Clancy games like Graw 2, Rainbow 6 games.

Mercanaries 2: better on the PS3

Soul Calibur 4: Darth on PS3, Yoda on 360.

Baja: better on the 360 (but your better off getting Pure or Motorstorm anyways)

Dirt - better on the PS3


So bottom, just wait to read user reviews. It seems most multiplatform games these days are pretty even.