How would you grade your collection?

[_Bolt_]

I would grade my collection as a B

I have 160 titles

I have 19 of the top 20 most popular movies as per My Collection feature on Blu Ray.com

Now I give myself a B because I do own some stinkers. Yes, I did pay very minimal for them, but that doesnt make the movies good. (Hannah Montana concert, High School Musical 2, Fools Gold, Camp Rock, and wait for it... Meet the Spartans) all by default, but they still sit on my shelf.

[ckent22]

I'd grade mine as A-. I have 185 and have some great ones such as the Godfather trilogy, The Matrix collection, etc. I have a few disney films but not like the ones you've mentioned except HMS2. But, I'd definitely go with A-. Because I don't think it will be a solid A until things like Back to the Future, Star Wars, the original Indiana Jones films, The Lord of the Rings, and Toy Story 1 and 2 hit my shelf on Blu.

[reginaroadie]

While I think every title I have is top notch quality for the films themselves, I think I'd have to rate my collection as a B+. I have a lot more catalog titles than new releases. And even those ones are more critical darlings and regular successes than record breaking box office hits that happen to be reference material. I'm holding off on IRON MAN just so that I can get it at Christmas, as well as the two James Bond volumes, HELLBOY II: THE GOLDEN ARMY and THE DARK KNIGHT. I only have one of the most popular titles (NO COUNTRY)

Hell, most of them I haven't even looked at fully because not only am I too busy with work and just my library DVD's to get through the Blu's, but I still can't establish a BD-Live link with my stand alone Sony BDPS350. (BTW, if anyone can explain to me how to fix my link in a way that a five year old can understand, that would be great. I'll send you the details.)

I dunno. I only have 42 titles, so going through them will be quick. Let me know if my collection is good. I'm pretty sure it is, I'd just like a second opinion.

[thegame]

i'll give my collection an A+ this is because i have 93 blus plus i'm a college student struggling to get by but i'm addicted to blus. Started collecting blus in june and every since then it has been a crazy ride goal is to have 200 by next june.

[Xen]

A+ because it's all titles that I want to have and none that I don't want, and I think that's all that matters.

[tqmilymi]

Originally Posted by Xen

A+ because it's all titles that I want to have and none that I don't want, and I think that's all that matters.

Agreed. I love having Surf's Up, Bridge to Terabithia, and Step into Liquid in my collection, while my wife loves having loves Sex in the City in our collection. Surprisingly, I love having Resident Evil: Extinction and BOTH Alien Vs. Predator movies, and my wife is enjoying going through Mad Men Season 1. Rate our collection an F if you want, but it's what we want.

[cartman781]

A+

[ckent22]

Well obviously you own what you want. It would be stupid to buy something you don't want. But, I think until the original Star Wars, Toy Story 1 and 2, Lord of the Rings, Back to the Future, and Indiana Jones the originals come out, my grade will be an A -. These will bump it up to an A+

[Beta Man]

I'd say "F-" for mine.... yep.... but a solid F- though.... not the bad kind of F-

[crazyBLUE]

A+ for me ! Because I enjoy every one I have!!!!!

[Petra_Kalbrain]

I'd grade mine as a B- because, as a reviewer, I don't have much say in what I get. And, unfortunately, I am unable to sell/trade the copies that I don't wish to keep. My only option is to destroy them... but I could never do that to a Blu-ray... no matter how bad the film is ('One Missed Call', 'Primeval', 'Benchwarmers', etc). Perhaps someday when I am desperate for Blu-ray cases and don't want to pay for them...

[_Bolt_]

Well I guess this has turned in who can say they have an A+. I dont get how you can have a perfect collection when you dont have EVERY single movie.

[ckent22]

Originally Posted by _Bolt_

Well I guess this has turned in who can say they have an A+. I dont get how you can have a perfect collection when you dont have EVERY single movie.

Agreed. Especially when some of the greatest films of all time aren't even released on Blu yet.

[Driver_King]

I would rate mine as an A. It's not quantity that counts, it's quality. (That's my excuse and what I'm sticking to until I allow monies for more Blu's)

[Beta Man]

Originally Posted by Petra_Kalbrain

I'd grade mine as a B- because, as a reviewer, I don't have much say in what I get. And, unfortunately, I am unable to sell/trade the copies that I don't wish to keep. My only option is to destroy them... but I could never do that to a Blu-ray... no matter how bad the film is ('One Missed Call', 'Primeval', 'Benchwarmers', etc). Perhaps someday when I am desperate for Blu-ray cases and don't want to pay for them...

I'd love to be a reviewer........ Put my opinionated rants to good use

[Marquoz]

Originally Posted by crazyBLUE

A+ for me ! Because I enjoy every one I have!!!!!

That's exactly what I was going to put. If somebody else graded it, it would be a lower score, but I buy the movies I want to see not what everybody else wants to see.

[PanasonicPlasmaMan]

how about you grade it for me?

Batman Begins
Black Hawk Down
Incredible Hulk
Indiana Jones
Iron Man
Planet Earth
Transformers

I only have a few titles. but i think i got the best ones

(this list will get longer after christmas)

[Canada]

Originally Posted by Xen

A+ because it's all titles that I want to have and none that I don't want, and I think that's all that matters.

exactly my thought.

[ixlegitballinxl]

C+, too many of my fav movies aren't on blu yet

[Therickus]

Originally Posted by reginaroadie

While I think every title I have is top notch quality for the films themselves, I think I'd have to rate my collection as a B+. I have a lot more catalog titles than new releases. And even those ones are more critical darlings and regular successes than record breaking box office hits that happen to be reference material. I'm holding off on IRON MAN just so that I can get it at Christmas, as well as the two James Bond volumes, HELLBOY II: THE GOLDEN ARMY and THE DARK KNIGHT. I only have one of the most popular titles (NO COUNTRY)

Hell, most of them I haven't even looked at fully because not only am I too busy with work and just my library DVD's to get through the Blu's, but I still can't establish a BD-Live link with my stand alone Sony BDPS350. (BTW, if anyone can explain to me how to fix my link in a way that a five year old can understand, that would be great. I'll send you the details.)

I dunno. I only have 42 titles, so going through them will be quick. Let me know if my collection is good. I'm pretty sure it is, I'd just like a second opinion.

Haha....Hellboy 2 will actually make your collection drop 2 grades.....it was that bad.....


I joke I joke....personal opinion....

Back to the actual thread....I would give my collection a B+. Of all the movies out, I have most of the great ones, and I only own a couple movies generally regaurded as terrible.