Alien³ (1992) vs. Panic Room (2002)

[Leslie Dame]

vs

[DR Herbert West]

Alien³

Panic Room is a solid film, but it doesn't have much rewatch value for me.

[Damon1281]

Alien³

Awesome. And I'm glad that Hicks and Newt were unceremoniously dead at the beginning of the film. A brilliant start to the darkest and most satisfying entry to the trilogy.

[Leslie Dame]

Originally Posted by Damon1281

Alien³

Awesome. And I'm glad that Hicks and Newt were unceremoniously dead at the beginning of the film. A brilliant start to the darkest and most satisfying entry to the trilogy.

but what about poor Jonesy the cat?

[Darthvaderrocks]

Panic Room.

I like both but i rarely rewatch them meanwhile i play The Game, Gone Girl and Fight Club frequently in my BD player.

[Mister_Kidd]

Always liked Alien 3. Shit, I even like Alien 4. I’ve only seen Panic Room once. It was ok.

[Damon1281]

Originally Posted by Leslie Dame

but what about poor Jonesy the cat?

Well...there is that. Still.

[Gacivory]

Panic Room

[John1701D]

Originally Posted by Damon1281

Alien³

Awesome. And I'm glad that Hicks and Newt were unceremoniously dead at the beginning of the film. A brilliant start to the darkest and most satisfying entry to the trilogy.

Originally Posted by Leslie Dame

but what about poor Jonesy the cat?

Originally Posted by Damon1281

Well...there is that. Still.

Alien 3 is worthless trash. And Ripley left Jonesy behind at her apartment.

[jess1581]

Panic Room is the better film, but it also benefitted from a more thought out screenplay, and without any studio interference or production woes. It was made with a plan.

Despite that, I'm an Alien fan and biased.... and Alien 3 turned out WAY better in spite of its troublesome history.

[Leslie Dame]

Originally Posted by John1701D

And Ripley left Jonesy behind at her apartment.

I know. I was only kidding.

[formula_nebula]

Panic Room

[originalHDphantom]

Panic Room. Easily.

[Cruel Angel]

Panic Room (2002)