Marvel & DC Superheroes in Live-action Films: Grade the character, not the movie

[toddly6666]

How do you grade the Marvel and DC superheroes? How well have they have been adapted from comic to screen with their look, costume, personality, depth?


Joker (Nicholson)
A+
Blade (Snipes)
A+
Professor X (Stewart)
A+
Magneto (McKellen)
A+
Wolverine (Jackman)
A+
Sandman
A+
J Jonah Jameson (Simmons)
A+
Iron Man (Downey)
A+
Joker (Ledger)
A+
Gordon (Oldman)
A+
Rorschach (Haley)
A+
Dr. Manhattan (Crudup)
A+
The Comedian (Morgan)
A+
Loki (Hiddleston)
A+
Professor X (McAvoy)
A+
Magneto (Fassbender)
A+
Captain America (Evans)
A+
Vision (Bettany)
A+
Deadpool (Reynolds)
A+
Wonder Woman (Gadot)
A+
Black Panther (Boseman)
A+
Joker (Leto)
A+
Harley Quinn (Robbie)
A+
Amanda Waller (Davis)
A+
Mantis (Pom)
A+
Steve Trevor (Pine)
A+
Antiope (Wright)
A+
Batman Cast (1960s)
A
Superman (Reeves)
A
Catwoman (Phieffer)
A
Bullseye (Farrell)
A
Stryker (Cox)
A
Nightcrawler (Cumming)
A
Doctor Octopus (Molina)
A
Batman (Bale)
A
Batman (Affleck)
A
Ra's al Ghul (Neeson)
A
Scarecrow (Murphy)
A
Human Torch (Evans)
A
Thing (Chiklis)
A
Nick Fury (Jackson)
A
Abomination (Roth)
A
Two-Face (Eckhart)
A
Alfred Pennysworth (Caine)
A
Nite Owl II(Wilson)
A
Nite Owl 1 (McHattie)
A
Sabertooth (Schreiber)
A
Thor (Hemsworth)
A
Odin (Hopkins)
A
Mystique (Lawrence)
A
Peggy Carter (Atwell)
A
Winter Soldier (Barnes)
A
Bane (Hardy)
A
Superman (Cavill)
A
Crossbones (Grillo)
A
Quicksilver (Peters)
A
Star Lord (Pratt)
A
Gamora (Saldana)
A
Drax (Bautista)
A
Groot (Diesel)
A
Rocket (Cooper)
A
Yondu (Rooker)
A
Nebula (Gillan)
A
Colossus (Kapicic)
A
Blind Al (Uggmams)
A
Spiderman (Holland)
A
Captain Boomerang (Jay)
A
El Diablo (Hernandez)
A
Doctor Strange
A
X-23 (Kinney)
A
Taserface (Sullivan)
A
Spiderman (Maguire)
B+
Lady Deathstrike
B+
Sinestro (Strong)
B+
Zod (Stamp)
B
Howard the Duck
B
Batman (Keaton)
B
Penguin (DeVito)
B
Mystique (Romijin-Stamos)
B
Toad (Park)
B
Sabertooth (Mane)
B
Green Goblin (Dafoe)
B
Daredevil (Afleck)
B
Kingpin (Duncan)
B
Pyro (Stanford)
B
Thunderbolt Ross (Elliott)
B
Punisher (Jane)
B
Typhoid Mary (Malthe)
B
Beast (Grammer)
B
Juggernaut (Jones)
B
Silver Surfer
B
Iron Monger (Bridges)
B
Pepper Potts (Paltrow)
B
Betty Ross (Connelly)
B
Betty Ross (Tyler)
B
Thunderbolt Ross (Hurt)
B
Silk Spectre II (Akerman)
B
Silk Spectre I (Gugino)
B
Moloch (Frewer)
B
Styker (Huston)
B
Gambit (Kitsch)
B
War Machine (Cheadle)
B
Black Widow (Scarlett)
B
Whiplash (Rourke)
B
Sif (Alexander)
B
Destroyer
B
Beast (Hoult)
B
Sebastian Shaw (Bacon)
B
Green Lantern (Reynolds)
B
Red Skull (Weaving)
B
Hulk (Ruffalo)
B
Maria Hill (Smulders)
B
Spiderman (Garfield)
B
Catwoman (Hathaway)
B
Zod (Shannon)
B
Lois Lane (Adams)
B
Mariko (Okamoto)
B
Yukio (Rila)
B
Viper (Sveta)
B
Falcon (Mackie)
B
Styker (Helman)
B
The Collector (del Toro)
B
Ant-Man (Rudd)
B
Negasonic (Hildebrand)
B
Weasel (Miller)
B
Angel Dust (Carano)
B
Apocalypse (Isaac)
B
Psylocke (Munn)
B
Deadshot (Smith)
B
Killer Croc (Adewale)
B
Enchantress (Cara)
B
Katana (Fukuhara)
B
Flash (Miller)
B
Wong (Wong)
B
The Ancient One (Swinton)
B
Caliban (Merchant)
B
Ayesha (Debeicki)
B
Hippolyta (Nielsen)
B
Doctor Poison (Anaya)
B
Etta Candy (Davis)
B
Punisher (Lundgren)
B-
Kitty Pryde (Page)
B-
Emma Frost (Jones)
B-
Hawkeye (Renner)
B-
Lex Luthor (Hackman)
C+
Batman (Kilmer)
C+
Robin (O'Donnel)
C+
Batman (Clooney)
C+
Mr. Freeze (Arnold)
C+
Rogue (Paquin)
C+
Angel (Foster)
C+
Ozymandias (Goode)
C+
Havoc (Till)
C+
Dr. Hammond (Saarsgard)
C+
Supergirl (Slater)
C
Riddler (Carrey)
C
Poison Ivy (Thurman)
C
Jean Grey (Janssen)
C
Cyclops (Marsen)
C
Elektra (Garner)
C
Iceman (Ashmore)
C
Hulk (Bana)
C
Constantine (Reeves)
C
Colossus (Cudmore)
C
Superman (Routh)
C
Lex Luthor (Spacey)
C
Ghost Rider (Cage)
C
Caretaker (Elliott)
C
Venom (Grace)
C
Hulk (Norton)
C
Punisher (Stevenson)
C
Jigsaw (West)
C
Justin Hammer (Rockwell)
C
Azazel (Flemyng)
C
Lizard (Ifans)
C
Gwen Stacey (Stone)
C
Talia al Ghul
C
Lois Lane (Kidder)
C
Silver Samurai
C
Electro (Foxx)
C
Rhino (Giamatti)
C
Bolivar Trask (Dinklage)
C
Bishop (Sy)
C
Blink (Bingbing)
C
Sunspot (Canto)
C
Warpath (Stewart)
C
Ronan (Pace)
C
Ultron (Spader)
C
Quicksilver (Taylor-Johnson)
C
Scarlet Witch (Olson)
C
Yellowjacket (Stoll)
C
Human Torch (Jordan)
C
Invisible Girl (Mara)
C
Ajax (Skrein)
C
Doomsday
C
Zemo (Bruhl)
C
Cyclops (Sheridan)
C
Jean Grey (Turner)
C
Nightcrawler (McPhee)
C
Storm (Shipp)
C
Archangel (Hardy)
C
Caliban (Lemarquis)
C
Rick Flag (Kinnaman)
C
Mordo (Ejiofor)
C
Ego (Russell)
C
Ares (Thewlis)
C
Captain America (1990s)
D
Red Skull (1990s)
D
Fantastic Four Cast (1990s)
D
Two-Face (Jones)
D
Batgirl (Silverstone)
D
Bane (Swenson)
D
Steel (O'Neil)
D
Storm (Berry)
D
Mister Fantastic (Gruffudd)
D
Doctor Doom (McMahon)
D
Blackheart (Bentley)
D
Mephistopheles (Fonda)
D
Mary Jane (Dunst)
D
Silverfox (Collins)
D
Blob (Durand)
D
Jonah Hex (Brolin)
D
Arnim Zola (Jones)
D
Green Goblin (DeHaan)
D
Thing (Bell)
D
Mister Fantastic (Teller)
D
Catwoman (Berry)
F
Invisible Girl (Alba)
F
Green Goblin (Franco)
F
Deadpool (X-Men Origins)
F
Parallax (Brown)
F
Galactus
F
Mandarin (Kingsley)
F
Lois Lane (Bosworth)
F
Doctor Doom (Kebbell)
F