Oscar Winners - Agree or Disagree?

[jimmystewart]

Okay so at the moment I am currently going through the Best Picture Oscar films and watching all the ones that were nominated in the same year. Reason being is because I want to see if I agree with the actual winner. I was wondering which Oscar winners you guys have seen that didn't deserve to win, and what film nominated in the same year should have won?

I will do a few:

1940 - WINNER: Rebecca - Should have been Winner: The Philadelphia Story
1941 - WINNER: How Green was my Valley - SHBW: The Maltese Falcon
1946 - WINNER: The Best Years of Our Lives - SHBW: It's a Wonderful Life
1948 - WINNER: Hamlet - SHBW: The Treasure of the Sierra Madre
1950 - WINNER: All About Eve - SHBW: Sunset Boulevard
1951 - WINNER: An American in Paris - SHBW: A Place in the Sun
1958 - WINNER: GIGI - SHBW: Cat on a Hot Tin Roof
1961 - WINNER: West Side Story - SHBW: The Hustler
1962 - WINNER: Lawerence of Arabia - SHBW: To Kill a Mockingbird
1963 - WINNER: Tom Jones - SHBW: Cleopatra
1976 - WINNER: Rocky - SHBW: Taxi Driver
1990 - WINNER: Dances with Wolves - SHBW: Goodfellas
1997 - WINNER: Titanic - SHBW: LA Confidential
2001 - WINNER: A Beautiful Mind - SHBW: Lord of the Rings: FOTR
2002 - WINNER: Chicago - SHBW: Lord of the Rings: TTT