Combining LG passive 3D TV w/ Sony player?

[BluChris]

So I'm ready to jump into 3D with both feet. Tried to do my research, but it's a lot to digest and most of it is new to me. I was able to discern the difference between passive & active technology though.

Based on my understanding of the respective techs, I think I would prefer the passive and it's battery-less glasses. I am aware of the drawbacks in picture quality though. I also understand that, if I want passive, I need an LG. I've selected the LG Infinia 55LW5600.

For the blu-ray player I selected (with the help of a forum member) the Sony BDP-S780. I based this selection on two things: 1) past positive experience with Sony blu players, and 2) its ability to convert 2D blus to a pseudo 3D (I realize this will never be as good as a true 3D blu, but it still intrigues me).

My question is this: are the two compatible? Some people said that, if I get an LG TV, I need an LG player. I was also concerned that the Sony 2D to 3D conversion will only work on an active 3D TV. Do you think this is a valid concern? or will the conversion still work on a passive 3D TV? I am very interested in that feature, and its absence could be a deal breaker.

Thank you in advance!

[banibale]

Originally Posted by BluChris

So I'm ready to jump into 3D with both feet. Tried to do my research, but it's a lot to digest and most of it is new to me. I was able to discern the difference between passive & active technology though.

Based on my understanding of the respective techs, I think I would prefer the passive and it's battery-less glasses. I am aware of the drawbacks in picture quality though. I also understand that, if I want passive, I need an LG. I've selected the LG Infinia 55LW5600.

For the blu-ray player I selected (with the help of a forum member) the Sony BDP-S780. I based this selection on two things: 1) past positive experience with Sony blu players, and 2) its ability to convert 2D blus to a pseudo 3D (I realize this will never be as good as a true 3D blu, but it still intrigues me).

My question is this: are the two compatible? Some people said that, if I get an LG TV, I need an LG player. I was also concerned that the Sony 2D to 3D conversion will only work on an active 3D TV. Do you think this is a valid concern? or will the conversion still work on a passive 3D TV? I am very interested in that feature, and its absence could be a deal breaker.

Thank you in advance!

You wont have any problems, the 2D to 3D convertion comes from the player... Besides that the LG passive 3D tvs has a button on the controller for 2D to 3D.. And dont worry about picture drawbacks as soon as the tv gets a internet conection it will download a firmware update to fix the picture to wow!!. im really happy with my tv, here is a link to let you know why passive LG 3D is not a bad choice.. Good luck http://www.sacbee.com/2011/09/13/390...mpetition.html

[slickkeng]

Originally Posted by BluChris

So I'm ready to jump into 3D with both feet. Tried to do my research, but it's a lot to digest and most of it is new to me. I was able to discern the difference between passive & active technology though.

Based on my understanding of the respective techs, I think I would prefer the passive and it's battery-less glasses. I am aware of the drawbacks in picture quality though. I also understand that, if I want passive, I need an LG. I've selected the LG Infinia 55LW5600.

For the blu-ray player I selected (with the help of a forum member) the Sony BDP-S780. I based this selection on two things: 1) past positive experience with Sony blu players, and 2) its ability to convert 2D blus to a pseudo 3D (I realize this will never be as good as a true 3D blu, but it still intrigues me).

My question is this: are the two compatible? Some people said that, if I get an LG TV, I need an LG player. I was also concerned that the Sony 2D to 3D conversion will only work on an active 3D TV. Do you think this is a valid concern? or will the conversion still work on a passive 3D TV? I am very interested in that feature, and its absence could be a deal breaker.

Thank you in advance!

The LG55LW5600 is a fantastic TV set. You dont have to worry about compatibility on 3D content (ie Bluray 3D) - it will work whether active or passive. The same goes for players and TVs - as long as they are 3D capable you will be fine. Also, the LG has a 3D conversion option which will convert any source including files you downloading off the internet so you're set in terms of 2D to 3D conversion. Finally, what banibale was alluding to with the latest firmward update, I believe it is 04.01.30 there is new algorithm for the 3D that makes 3D content essential 1080p. You can still see a tiny difference but the 3D is for all practical purposes 1080p (not half the resolution as you may have been lead to believe). Anyhow, it is a solid choice for a TV.

[Rupert305]

I currently have a LG42PW350 in my room hooked up to a Sony BDP-480 and have had no issues whatsoever. My TV uses the active style glasses. When I have the Blu-ray player on and I turn off the TV the player actually shuts off with the TV. It will not switch inputs automatically though when you put a disc into the player when there is no other source present. (If you have the TV on HDMI 1 and your player is HDMI 2, you would need to manually switch it over to HDMI 2). I've had this set up for about 4 months with no issues.

[BluChris]

Thanks for the info guys! Good stuff... Sounds like I don't need the Sony player for 2D to 3D conversion since the TV will do it for me. I wonder what happens when you set the player to convert AND the TV to convert? Would I get "super" 2D to 3D conversion?

[bluflu]

Originally Posted by BluChris

I wonder what happens when you set the player to convert AND the TV to convert? Would I get "super" 2D to 3D conversion?

Don't give Toshiba any ideas.

[BluChris]

Originally Posted by bluflu

Don't give Toshiba any ideas.

LOL. All kidding aside though, what would happen? Would it just become a jumbled mess that your glasses couldn't sort out? Would the TV take priority over the player's conversion and do all the work (or vice versa)? or would it cancel out and you'd be left with just plain 2D?

[banibale]

Originally Posted by BluChris

Thanks for the info guys! Good stuff... Sounds like I don't need the Sony player for 2D to 3D conversion since the TV will do it for me. I wonder what happens when you set the player to convert AND the TV to convert? Would I get "super" 2D to 3D conversion?

If the tv is getting converted 3D signals from the player, the 2D to 3D wont be available on the tv because it only works when 2D signals are displaying on the screen. 3D to 3D wont work.. But good idea lol.

[BluChris]

Originally Posted by banibale

If the tv is getting converted 3D signals from the player, the 2D to 3D wont be available on the tv because it only works when 2D signals are displaying on the screen. 3D to 3D wont work.. But good idea lol.

Haha. It was worth a shot. Thanks again for the help!