Tagging Cast Members in Screenshots

[jscoggins]

I'm not sure if this should be crowdsourced to the entire forum membership.

Take, for instance, this shot from Noah.



Someone tagged Jennifer Connelly, Emma Watson, and Douglas Booth.

However, I believe that shot was taken from a sequence explaining the origins of the Watchers, and their arrival on Earth pre-dates the characters played by Connelly, et al.

(I've made edits to remove the tags, but the changes are pending approval -- which I know are subject to the site runners' time availability.)

Thanks for listening.

[iceman]

Originally Posted by jscoggins

I'm not sure if this should be crowdsourced to the entire forum membership.

Take, for instance, this shot from Noah.



Someone tagged Jennifer Connelly, Emma Watson, and Douglas Booth.

However, I believe that shot was taken from a sequence explaining the origins of the Watchers, and their arrival on Earth pre-dates the characters played by Connelly, et al.

(I've made edits to remove the tags, but the changes are pending approval -- which I know are subject to the site runners' time availability.)

Thanks for listening.

We decided to be somewhat flexible with cast & crew taggings, meaning we allow Cameron Diaz tagged as Princess Fiona in Shrek and screenshots where the actor is hard to see, but it's still him/her. I haven't seen Noah, but if it's Jennifer Connelly, Emma Watson, and Douglas Booth in the screenshot and not other actors, they should be tagged despite them portraying other characters. If it's other stand in characters, Jennifer Connelly, Emma Watson, and Douglas Booth should not be tagged. Personally I haven't got a clue in this case

[jscoggins]

Originally Posted by iceman

We decided to be somewhat flexible with cast & crew taggings, meaning we allow Cameron Diaz tagged as Princess Fiona in Shrek and screenshots where the actor is hard to see, but it's still him/her. I haven't seen Noah, but if it's Jennifer Connelly, Emma Watson, and Douglas Booth in the screenshot and not other actors, they should be tagged despite them portraying other characters. If it's other stand in characters, Jennifer Connelly, Emma Watson, and Douglas Booth should not be tagged. Personally I haven't got a clue in this case

Oh, I understand, which is why for the screenshots where there are only hands, I still tagged the actors if I knew whose hands they are, lol.

Having said that, Connelly, Watson, and Booth do not appear in that shot with the falling angels.

[iceman]

Originally Posted by jscoggins

Having said that, Connelly, Watson, and Booth do not appear in that shot with the falling angels.

Then they should not be tagged in that screenshot

[jscoggins]

Originally Posted by iceman

Then they should not be tagged in that screenshot

I noticed that my suggested changes were accepted. Thanks!