The Criterion Collection

[jw007]

Originally Posted by Abdrewes

It's safe to say you should give it a rent first. I kinda liked it, but then again I'm not like everybody else: I give automatic points for strangeness.

I'm a sucker for post-apocalyptic films and accept every title on general principle (and it doesn't matter if its The Postman or Waterworld or some other overblown post-apocalyptic epic like 2012). But other than Lars Von Trier's recent string of overly depressing post-apocalyptic films and now this old, experimental Malle film Black Moon, I would have normally kept the film in my collection. We shall see.

[jw007]

Originally Posted by Joe Dalek

Don't feed the troll, kids.

No, no, I only have 101 Criterion films in my collection so nowhere near the 600+ titles (on DVD and BD). I'm a selective, non-impulsive/compulsive consumer! I have mastered the troll and turned him/her into a hobbit!

[Cinemach]

Originally Posted by jw007

So who here in this forum ever goes to their local library and rents Criterion films before purchasing them?

Now if only they had BD's to rent! But hey, at least if you watch the DVD first, you can get a better idea if you're gonna invest $ into the BD edition.

I definitely use my closest librar(ies) as resources for films and TV, Criterion or not...though as you mention, yes DVD only. As Joe Dalek mentions above Netflix and Hulu+ are godsends for checking out pictures, too.

These libraries are also great for film books!

Originally Posted by Abdrewes

Wow, I couldn't imagine a Nolan film worse than The Dark Knight Rises. His worst by a mile. It's the film where I noticed what he's piss poor at sometimes: everything regarding time and space (who edited the thing) and lighter emotions (does everything have to be laden with mythology, gloom and portent)

I haven't seen Following, but I'd have to agree that there's no way it's worse than The Dark Knight Rises. What a clunky, bloated, overindulgent mess of a film. And you're right, the editing is downright atrocious.

[Abdrewes]

Originally Posted by jw007

I'm a sucker for post-apocalyptic films and accept every title on general principle (and it doesn't matter if its The Postman or Waterworld or some other overblown post-apocalyptic epic like 2012). But other than Lars Von Trier's recent string of overly depressing post-apocalyptic films and now this old, experimental Malle film Black Moon, I would have normally kept the film in my collection. We shall see.

In that case get it. Its strange in a dry, matter of fact way and has some pretty startling images of military control. Do you own Weekend? It has a very apocalyptic feel?

[Abdrewes]

Originally Posted by Cinemach

I haven't seen Following, but I'd have to agree that there's no way it's worse than The Dark Knight Rises. What a clunky, bloated, overindulgent mess of a film. And you're right, the editing is downright atrocious.

Might I suggest having a Flash Gordon/TDKR double bill. You'll be in a better mood to laugh at the heavy handedness and enjoy the inept/rushed filmmaking of TDKR (Although shots beforehand does the job in less time).

[octagon]

Originally Posted by Abdrewes

Might I suggest having a Flash Gordon/TDKR double bill. You'll be in a better mood to laugh at the heavy handedness and enjoy the inept/rushed filmmaking of TDKR (Although shots beforehand does the job in less time).

Ah, you must be a scholarship student at AWSA. Or do the bills just go directly to your people?

Either way, that's gotta be sweet.

[retablo]

Originally Posted by iScottie

I want to ask for a few Criterions for Christmas and I don't know which ones are a waste of money or not. I'm definitely asking for Brazil, Following, and Purple Noon, but as far as the other ones go, I'm unsure. Any help is appreciated.

1. Alambrista
2. And Everything Is Going Fine
3. Beauty And The Beast
4. Branded To Kill
5. Children Of Paradise (the best film on the list, but a suspect transfer)
6. David Lean Directs Noel Coward
7. Gray's Anatomy
8. In The Realm Of The Senses
9. Les Visiteurs Du Soir
10. Naked
11. Stagecoach
12. Three Outlaw Samurai
13. Tokyo Drifter
14. Vanya On 42nd Street
15. Walkabout
16. White Material
17. World On A Wire

I'm not a fan of Japanese New Wave, or Naked, and to me, the Soderberg/Gray films are not cinematic enough to really benefit from blu-ray, although they are interesting and entertaining films. So you might not want to listen to me, lol.

[runnersdialzero]

Originally Posted by Kevin Holly

Oddly enough, I am the opposite. I usually like movies with "no narrative" but I hated The Tree of Life. And I loved The Master.

We probably shouldn't hang out. .

I'm sorry but The Master is mind numbingly bad. PTA has directed some of my favorite films. I was dying to love this movie. I saw it with a packed crowd and I could tell the theater had the same feeling I had....please let this uncomfortableness be over finally.

[Scottie]

What are the chances of a Criterion release of Leon? Although it's already available on Blu-Ray.

Originally Posted by retablo

I'm not a fan of Japanese New Wave, or Naked, and to me, the Soderberg/Gray films are not cinematic enough to really benefit from blu-ray, although they are interesting and entertaining films. So you might not want to listen to me, lol.

[Abdrewes]

Originally Posted by octagon

Ah, you must be a scholarship student at AWSA. Or do the bills just go directly to your people?

Either way, that's gotta be sweet.

Were having shrimp cocktails with Bret Ratner (in the middle of a shot by shot by shot analysis of Xanadu). McG's up next, I wonder what he's gonna say.

[Abdrewes]

Originally Posted by runnersdialzero

We probably shouldn't hang out. .

I'm sorry but The Master is mind numbingly bad. PTA has directed some of my favorite films. I was dying to love this movie. I saw it with a packed crowd and I could tell the theater had the same feeling I had....please let this uncomfortableness be over finally.

Seen 60+ films in theaters this year. The Master's at the top...shhhh dont tell professor white. It'll be our secret.

[BohemianGraham]

Originally Posted by Abdrewes

My post was to be taken playfully. But seriously, he's a hell of an interesting character (however misguided). Many of his trashings contain nuggets of truth and kudos to him for having such a distinct voice. Hey and don't trash on the Bay, some pretty intelligent critics like his work.

Unrelated but speaking of auteurs many love to hate: Mubi.com has some pretty good essays on the late great Tony Scott.

Wasn't Sure As some people make those Comments ina serious manner. You should use a smilie.That's how I knew the black Orpheus post was a joke. thus I apologise. And my smartphone comments was towards myself as Autocorrect is doing all sorts of weird and wonderful things on my new phone. Swipe is new to me.

[shadedpain4]

Anyone snag a copy of 99 Reasons?

[Sukuri]

Originally Posted by retablo

I'm not a fan of Japanese New Wave, or Naked, and to me, the Soderberg/Gray films are not cinematic enough to really benefit from blu-ray, although they are interesting and entertaining films. So you might not want to listen to me, lol.

I've listened, and I give you +1

[Abdrewes]

Originally Posted by BohemianGraham

Wasn't Sure As some people make those Comments ina serious manner. You should use a smilie.That's how I knew the black Orpheus post was a joke. thus I apologise. And my smartphone comments was towards myself as Autocorrect is doing all sorts of weird and wonderful things on my new phone. Swipe is new to me.

Sure. Maybe you'll like the latest Malick: To the Wonder:/

[exolstice]

Originally Posted by Abdrewes

Wow, I couldn't imagine a Nolan film worse than The Dark Knight Rises. His worst by a mile. It's the film where I noticed what he's piss poor at sometimes: everything regarding time and space (who edited the thing) and lighter emotions (does everything have to be laden with mythology, gloom and portent)

I know it's fun to immediately dismiss anything that's popular or entertaining, but you have to at least commend Nolan for trying (and often succeeding) in elevating the super-hero film, and by association the blockbuster, to something more artful and intelligent than most of the 3D dreck that fills movie theatres these days. Even if he sometimes misses the mark, at least you can tell he puts a lot of careful thought into everything that goes on screen.

Think of him as a "gateway drug" to art house cinema. I know at least two people (anecdotal evidence, I know) who've watched and enjoyed Battle of Algiers based on the fact that Nolan mentioned it as an inspiration for TDKR in interviews.

[bingtau]

I would like to request that Criterion releases P.T. Anderson's first film on BD, Hard Eight. Who else loves Hard Eight?[/QUOTE]

Hard Eight is great. It seems to be a perfect fit for Criterion. Anyone who hasn't seen this film and has any interest in the Casino lifestyle then this if a must see. I love the fact that There's a line in the film where they talk about some of Sydney's old aquaintinces. They mention names that I can't think of off the top of my head, (my bad) but however these same names (charachters) show up in some of his later films such as Boogie Nights and Magnolia. Pure Genius.

[TheHighRoller]

Originally Posted by CoopFilm

I think I understand what you mean...yeah, you most definitely (well, probably) want to watch it alone the first time. I'd strongly advise that

I think I'd want to watch it alone anytime I see it!

[tonylopez]

Leon would be great but I don't believe Criterion could do much more with it considering the bluray has enough extras as is. Sure the transfer can be improved. Hard Eight would be great but I remember a DVD having a nice collection of special features. Two great films that I would love to have a Criterion of but I doubt it will happen.

[Abdrewes]

Originally Posted by tonylopez

Leon would be great but I don't believe Criterion could do much more with it considering the bluray has enough extras as is. Sure the transfer can be improved. Hard Eight would be great but I remember a DVD having a nice collection of special features. Two great films that I would love to have a Criterion of but I doubt it will happen.

You mean Leolo. That would be great!