The Criterion Collection

[puffyrock2]

Originally Posted by lefty23

It's never been an issue for me. My opinion is that if the 'victim' has forgiven him and believes that he shouldn't be prosecuted, etc. then there's no reason for me to be upset with the guy. Of course, i've never really looked into all the details of the case, as in if he knew her age, etc.

What Polanski did was despicable. Drugged and raped a 13 year old girl and ran from punishment. However, I can still watch and enjoy his work because I regard his personal life as a different matter from his art. I don't know how much of a cut he gets from a Blu-Ray sale...a few pennies perhaps? Not enough to keep me from buying the movies of his I want on Blu-Ray.

[blkhrt]

Originally Posted by greekak229

I in no way embrace what he did, but come on, the man has apologized countless times, and the girl has said herself that she is very over it and forgives him. I buy my Polanski with confidence. He made a stupid decision, and that shouldn't at all affect whether we should like his movies or not. His films are brilliant regardless of what he did, and I have had no problem buying them.

Unfortunately, in this day and age, an apology doesn't exactly cut it. Let's not forget that by pretty much all definitions, he is guilty of rape.

As for buying his films, I have some, and I will probably buy more at some point, but I do think about it. I also think it is important to keep in mind that a lot of artists have done some pretty horrible things...heck, Burroughs shot his wife in the face. Does that mean they aren't good artists? No. Does it mean that it might be worth thinking about the larger questions raised by these issues? Absolutely.

[blkhrt]

On another note, I am really curious about today's announcement, especially after Ryan Gallagher tweeted something about how there is going to be some debate about the covers...Does this mean more illustrations and "comic book" covers? If so, I wonder what titles that would go with...

Edit: Here is his tweet: "I predict an interesting discussion of some cover art tomorrow."

[Beta Man]

Originally Posted by blkhrt

On another note, I am really curious about today's announcement, especially after Ryan Gallagher tweeted something about how there is going to be some debate about the covers...Does this mean more illustrations and "comic book" covers? If so, I wonder what titles that would go with...

Edit: Here is his tweet: "I predict an interesting discussion of some cover art tomorrow."

Perhaps it's something "racey"

[PowellPressburger]

Originally Posted by blkhrt

On another note, I am really curious about today's announcement, especially after Ryan Gallagher tweeted something about how there is going to be some debate about the covers...Does this mean more illustrations and "comic book" covers? If so, I wonder what titles that would go with...

Edit: Here is his tweet: "I predict an interesting discussion of some cover art tomorrow."

Does that mean that Criterion will still be trying to decide on a cover art for that said title meaning just a BLACK square in place of the cover? or a Cover art some may find either shocking?

[blkhrt]

Originally Posted by Beta Man

Perhaps it's something "racey"

Racey? You mean something like this:

[greekak229]

Originally Posted by blkhrt

Unfortunately, in this day and age, an apology doesn't exactly cut it. Let's not forget that by pretty much all definitions, he is guilty of rape.

As for buying his films, I have some, and I will probably buy more at some point, but I do think about it. I also think it is important to keep in mind that a lot of artists have done some pretty horrible things...heck, Burroughs shot his wife in the face. Does that mean they aren't good artists? No. Does it mean that it might be worth thinking about the larger questions raised by these issues? Absolutely.

I agree, but there's not much more he can do.

People like Kobe Bryant get away with rape, yet people seem not to care about that. At least Polanski has regret for his actions about that, unlike douchebags like Bryant.

[The Theory]

Originally Posted by blkhrt

Racey? You mean something like this:

[Show spoiler]

Oh man, I thoroughly chortled. Nicely played!

[blkhrt]

Originally Posted by greekak229

I agree, but there's not much more he can do.

People like Kobe Bryant get away with rape, yet people seem not to care about that. At least Polanski has regret for his actions about that, unlike douchebags like Bryant.

He could come back and face trial.

And there is a reason I hate the Lakers...and it isn't just because I am a Nuggets fan.

This whole discussion is kind of timely. I was thinking about watching my old DVD copy of Repulsion tonight to decide if I want to buy the Criterion blu tomorrow.

[greekak229]

Originally Posted by blkhrt

He could come back and face trial.

And there is a reason I hate the Lakers...and it isn't just because I am a Nuggets fan.

This whole discussion is kind of timely. I was thinking about watching my old DVD copy of Repulsion tonight to decide if I want to buy the Criterion blu tomorrow.

Well, I'm a Celtics fan, soo...

And I recommend you get Repulsion on Blu-ray. Great quality.

[horseflesh]

Originally Posted by PowellPressburger

Does that mean that Criterion will still be trying to decide on a cover art for that said title meaning just a BLACK square in place of the cover? or a Cover art some may find either shocking?

I wonder if they'll offer a few cover options for a title and accept "votes" via their Facebook page?
Or something along those lines

[puffyrock2]

Originally Posted by greekak229

Well, I'm a Celtics fan, soo...

And I recommend you get Repulsion on Blu-ray. Great quality.

Ditto on Repulsion. It has one of the most disturbing, unsettling ending shots of all time. Gave me chills.

[ShellOilJunior]

There's always debate on the covers.

People HATED the "Lil Senso" cover a few months ago.

[blkhrt]

Originally Posted by ShellOilJunior

There's always debate on the covers.

People HATED the "Lil Senso" cover a few months ago.

Yeah. It seems like people reserve the most scorn for the covers that feature drawings instead of film images.

[The Theory]

Originally Posted by blkhrt

Yeah. It seems like people reserve the most scorn for the covers that feature drawings instead of film images.

Even though the drawn covers are the best ones.

[blkhrt]

Originally Posted by The Theory

Even though the drawn covers are the best ones.

I definitely like a lot of them...

So here is a tidbit from Criterion Cast's twitter feed:

"While they haven't updated the art or release date, Criterion now lists the Fear and Loathing page with "Blu-ray special edition features"”

[Beta Man]

Originally Posted by blkhrt

I definitely like a lot of them...

So here is a tidbit from Criterion Cast's twitter feed:

"While they haven't updated the art or release date, Criterion now lists the Fear and Loathing page with "Blu-ray special edition features"”

The lizard in the suit could be coming to fruition.

[jcs913]

Originally Posted by blkhrt

I definitely like a lot of them...

So here is a tidbit from Criterion Cast's twitter feed:

"While they haven't updated the art or release date, Criterion now lists the Fear and Loathing page with "Blu-ray special edition features"”

Yeah, this should be announced in a bit. This is not a simple mistake, especiallly with the DTSHD-MA confirmation.

http://www.criterion.com/films/215-f...q=autocomplete

[biglou114]

Originally Posted by blkhrt

I definitely like a lot of them...

So here is a tidbit from Criterion Cast's twitter feed:

"While they haven't updated the art or release date, Criterion now lists the Fear and Loathing page with "Blu-ray special edition features"”

Sweet I'll have no problem upgrading this title on to a CC Blu.

[PowellPressburger]

Restored, complete, uncut version, with uncompressed monaural soundtrack
http://www.criterion.com/films/628-le-cercle-rouge