The Criterion Collection

[DarkRyder]

Originally Posted by Joe Dalek

I have both the BRDVD3 and BRDVD4 models and can recommend them.

I've only had the BRDVD3 for a few months, but so far, so good.

I've had the BRDVD4 for nearly a year, and no complaints. Currently I have retired it to back-up status, as I prefer it over the BRDVD3 (smaller size and proven reliability). Best Buy did not have the BRDVD4s in stock when I went to purchase a back-up, otherwise I would have bought a second one.

The BRDVD2 model linked above seems to have universally poor reviews, so it may be worth the extra $10 or $20 for a more reliable model.

I'm curious as to starting a region free collection; are both BRDVD3 and BRDVD4 the best values? I've looked both up and them seem to have less than stellar reviews.

[HyperRealist]

Originally Posted by DarkRyder

I'm curious as to starting a region free collection; are both BRDVD3 and BRDVD4 the best values? I've looked both up and them seem to have less than stellar reviews.

You should ask in this thread.
https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=190357

Anyways there is a bunch of info in this thread I don't agree with. The one I linked to (WBRDVD2) is the best one and the best deal. WBRDVD2 and BRDVD4 are the same but the 2 has WiFi. BB just so happens to have it cheaper than the 4 at moment. BRDVD3 is the oldest player. Ya they have bad reviews. That's why you buy a refurb that has been fixed and use it only to watch other region discs. Use your regular player for region A. I have two BRDVD4 and they work fine for me. For $40 you can't go wrong.

[keldons]

Originally Posted by SpiderBaby

Does that mean we should expect a couple people to take over the Anger praise for me in the future? If so, then I'm happy.

considering he is a huge figure in experimental filmmaking, he already has a pretty big fanbase.

Originally Posted by SpiderBaby

On a serious note, I was actually recommending Anger for a Lynch fan since Lynch was highly influenced, I don't think someone got the connection.

[BohemianGraham]

Well, I finished Peyton Place, and loved it. It was deliciously trashy and borderline ridiculous, but despite all that, it was well written and is still shocking in some parts today. I'm now moving onto Rosemary's Baby, as believe it or not, it's a novel I haven't read yet. I enjoy Ira Levin's work.

Canadian preorders are still cheap of the film version, or they were 3 hours ago.

[rkish]

I apologize for this, but I wanted to alert those that haven't heard the news. There was a shooting at a movie theater in Colorado at a midnight showing of The Dark Knight Rises. 12 to 15 Peolple dead and 38 to 50 people injured (numbers vary from source to source).

It's pretty sad when it's not even safe to see a film out these days. My thoughts are with the survivors and their families.

[fdm]

Originally Posted by rkish

I haven't read ANY of the posts since early this morning, as Network Man got tied up all day with VLAN and printer configuration issues...all part of my summer projects.

For those that weren't aware...DirecTV now has TCM-HD. VERY psyched!

I'm sure BG will keep me/us informed about films worth mentioning.

Thanks for pointing that out! Been pretty tied up with things myself, good to know.

can be added to the list

Griffin & Phoenix (2006)
The Notebook (2006)
The Green Mile (1999)

[BohemianGraham]

Originally Posted by rkish

I apologize for this, but I wanted to alert those that haven't heard the news. There was a shooting at a movie theater in Colorado at a midnight showing of The Dark Knight Rises. 12 to 15 Peolple dead and 38 to 50 people injured (numbers vary from source to source).

It's pretty sad when it's not even safe to see a film out these days. My thoughts are with the survivors and their families.

My aunt and uncle were posted in Aurora back when he was in the Canadian Air force back in the 1960s. What is wrong with people to do things like this?

[Sinthetic]

My favourite film in ages (Le Havre) has a review up on DVD Beaver.

Counting down the days till it arrives.

[Squall835]

Hey everyone, I know Criterion no longer has the rights to The Third Man, but is it still possible to get a replacement case from them? I still have the original cardboard release.

[dsman71]

Originally Posted by Squall835

Hey everyone, I know Criterion no longer has the rights to The Third Man, but is it still possible to get a replacement case from them? I still have the original cardboard release.

Mine is cardboard too I think, it came with their usual case for blurays ?

[Mac Norton]

Originally Posted by BluPix

If you have more books in mind (and it's not too much of a bother) I'd be happy to see them.

I agree that French films at the time also had a certain flair (and I love the two Melvilles you mentioned, especially Army of Shadows) but it seems the French are better known for that generally than most anyone else. I don't think most people realize that there were stylish and intriguing films that fit into what could be called a Japanese New Wave or a Czech New Wave, as Criterion has been calling them.

Not a problem. I will send you a PM with those soon.

I agree with your statement. The French get all the credit and the other are made out to be imitators. Another excellent example of the French would be Le Samouraï, which really owes itself more to Japanese cinema then anything. But in a twist of irony, Le Samouraï launched some of the greatest hitman movies (from all regions) of all time.

I got to say, you know your stuff. A big to you.

[Joe Dalek]

Originally Posted by DarkRyder

I'm curious as to starting a region free collection; are both BRDVD3 and BRDVD4 the best values? I've looked both up and them seem to have less than stellar reviews.

I don't have experience with the BRDVD2 but its reviews are consistently worse than the other models. I prefer the BRDVD4 over the BRDVD3 simply because of the size and menu, but both have been problem-free for me thus far.

The only "drawback" has been that I am now spending a lot on region B discs.

[Joe Dalek]

Originally Posted by HyperRealist

Anyways there is a bunch of info in this thread I don't agree with. The one I linked to (WBRDVD2) is the best one and the best deal. WBRDVD2 and BRDVD4 are the same but the 2 has WiFi.

But why would WiFi be a selling point if you need to preserve out-of-date firmware to access the configure menu? I use my BRDVD3 for non 1/A discs exclusively and do not have it networked.

[ShellOilJunior]

Originally Posted by Squall835

Hey everyone, I know Criterion no longer has the rights to The Third Man, but is it still possible to get a replacement case from them? I still have the original cardboard release.

Several months ago they sold the remaining plastic cases.

[HyperRealist]

Originally Posted by Joe Dalek

But why would WiFi be a selling point if you need to preserve out-of-date firmware to access the configure menu? I use my BRDVD3 for non 1/A discs exclusively and do not have it networked.

Netflix, Pandora, Cinemanow, Napster

[BohemianGraham]

Originally Posted by ShellOilJunior

Several months ago they sold the remaining plastic cases.

Did I miss poll results?

[Squall835]

Originally Posted by ShellOilJunior

Several months ago they sold the remaining plastic cases.

I kinda figured I was too late. Oh well, thanks for the info!

[jrsl76]

Originally Posted by Sinthetic

My favourite film in ages (Le Havre) has a review up on DVD Beaver.

Counting down the days till it arrives.

I really wish this was part of the sale.

[Akijama]

Originally Posted by Simple Lines

So what's definite in the future from CC?

Apu Trilogy
Badlands
The Blob
Breaking the Waves
On the Waterfront
Pasolini Trilogy

...what else?

Heaven's Gate