The Criterion Collection

[moviebuffed]

Originally Posted by RiFiFi1955

The Maltese Falcon with Bogart from 41' was actually the remake. The orginal was from 31'. There might even be one in the middle of those two making three versions total but I am not positive on that.

The one "in the middle" you mentioned is called "Satan Met A Lady" from 1936 starring the great Bette Davis. I happen to own it but I've got to say it's one of those thirties melodramas Warner Bros. churned out in high volume.

[retablo]

Originally Posted by runnersdialzero

True, the Coen's even said they never saw the John Wayne version.

Knowing the Coens, 1) I don't believe that for a second; and 2) maybe they should've, then their remake might have actually been good.

[P@t_Mtl]

Originally Posted by retablo

Knowing the Coens, 1) I don't believe that for a second; and 2) maybe they should've, then their remake might have actually been good.

Agreed! The remake is really not that amazing. Sure John Wayne was not the greatest actor that ever was but he was Rooster Cogburn and having anyone else trying to reprise the role was just not a good idea. Certain characters like that in movie history are just owned by the original actor and when someone else want's to revive them is a big mistake

[jrsl76]

Originally Posted by OrchidClub

Perhaps this has already been discussed, but whatever happened to Y Tu Mama Tambien? It was supposed to have been released this year but it hasn't even been officially announced yet.

It's another situation like Following. It's been a long time coming, but due most likely to Cuaron's schedule it has been pushed back several times. It was hinted at in at least 2 New Years drawings over the past 3 years.

[Cocophone]

Originally Posted by Cinemach

I'd just go ahead and get the Warner Archive DVD - I can't recall any of those titles being upped to blu thus far, and they certainly are not priorities for Warner's to do such.

You can pick up Warner Archive titles cheaper at ImportCDs and Deep Discount. Also WBShop does present opportunities from time to time to get it cheaper than this $18.95 price, too.

Thanks. ImportCds had the best price. There in California and I'm in Oregon, so I'm hoping for fast shipping.

[Member-167298]

Even though I said I wasn't going to spend anymore on Blus until I finished the big batch I just bought, I had to splurge on Quadrophenia. It is one of my favorite movies ever so, even though I already own the UK disc, I need the exclusive Criterion extras (the improved picture and sound won't hurt either)!

[ElliesDad]

Originally Posted by P@t_Mtl

Agreed! The remake is really not that amazing. Sure John Wayne was not the greatest actor that ever was but he was Rooster Cogburn and having anyone else trying to reprise the role was just not a good idea. Certain characters like that in movie history are just owned by the original actor and when someone else want's to revive them is a big mistake

That could be rule number one in a list of criteria to consider when contemplating a remake (or a reinterpretation). In the same sense Vivien Leigh is Scarlett O'Hara, Greg Peck is Atticus Finch, and Tony Perkins is Norman Bates. James Arness as The Thing, on the other hand, probably not so much.

[GenPion]

But True Grit was based on a book... and from what I remember reading at the time the Coen Brothers film came out, that was what had inspired them to make a movie. They wanted to do an adaption of the book (which they loved) and they did not set out to make a remake of the earlier film.

[GenPion]

Originally Posted by Lutz

As Tears Go By, Days of Being Wild and Ashes of Time are all region free. That leaves the only region locked movie of his that hasn't had a region A release at My Blueberry Nights.

I wonder if WKW would still be interested in making The Lady From Shanghai now? Goodness knows Nicole Kidman's career has changed a great deal in the proceeding years.

Days of Being Wild has the worst English subtitles I have ever seen on an official Blu-ray release. I know it's an import, and that it was probably not done with English speakers in mind the same way... but it is really a bad translation. It should be re-released by Criterion or Kino on Blu-ray.

A few relatively minor errors exist on the "As Tears Go By" Blu-ray from HK but it's barely noticeable or distracting. It's worthwhile as a purchase. That Blu-ray only had a few translation hiccups and it was barely an issue.

[drbikeshorts]

Originally Posted by Abdrewes

Then i can finally have my The American / Solaris double feature in HD! Awesome films.

Yeah, I love The American. Two really good performances from Clooney.
Both The American and Solaris are slick and stylish films that never lose sight of drama, whilst satisfying genre expectations.

[drbikeshorts]

Originally Posted by retablo

Knowing the Coens, 1) I don't believe that for a second; and 2) maybe they should've, then their remake might have actually been good.

Whoa!
I disagree! A fantastic film that grows on you with repeated viewings.
I'm a fan of John Wayne, but I much prefer Jeff Bridges as Rooster Cogburn.
Although, I'm sure you're right about the Coens and they have seen the first version of True Grit.

[drbikeshorts]

Originally Posted by GenPion

Days of Being Wild has the worst English subtitles I have ever seen on an official Blu-ray release. I know it's an import, and that it was probably not done with English speakers in mind the same way... but it is really a bad translation. It should be re-released by Criterion or Kino on Blu-ray.

A few relatively minor errors exist on the "As Tears Go By" Blu-ray from HK but it's barely noticeable or distracting. It's worthwhile as a purchase. That Blu-ray only had a few translation hiccups and it was barely an issue.

Yeah, Days of Being Wild has dreadful subtitles. I'll definitely get it again if produced by Criterion, Kino or even one of the UK producers, like Artificial Eye or Studio Canal.

[RiFiFi1955]

Originally Posted by drbikeshorts

I watched Fanny and Alexander in four parts with Mrs Drbikeshorts and we loved it.
Recently I wanted to watch it in one session. I invited over 3 friends who are film buffs to watch it with me.
We had breaks for coffee and a break for lunch halfway through.
Everyone loved it.
Seeing it all in one day is amazing. Highly recommended.

Wow that is so awesome that you had people over and watched Fanny and Alexander over some coffee and what not. I virtually don't know a single person that I am acquainted with that would be up for doing something that.

[RiFiFi1955]

Yeah we all know the Coens saw John Wayne's True Grit. They aren't fooling anybody I still need to see this Coen version, I have had the blu-ray since July and still have yet to watch it. Should probably get on that.

[RiFiFi1955]

You think we will ever get an upgrade on La Dolce Vita any time soon??? I'm hoping so.

[retablo]

Originally Posted by ElliesDad

That could be rule number one in a list of criteria to consider when contemplating a remake (or a reinterpretation). In the same sense Vivien Leigh is Scarlett O'Hara, Greg Peck is Atticus Finch, and Tony Perkins is Norman Bates. James Arness as The Thing, on the other hand, probably not so much.

Agreed, however I'd watch a Gone With the Wind remake, especially if it was done like a mini-series on HBO or something. Which is how I predicted movies would go a few years back. TV, the cinema's bastard step child, is now the more creative of the two, and offers up way more freedom and originality these days.

[Snicket]

With all the praise Purple Noon is getting I will have to consider a pick up. My list is so long already...guess that's what B&N sales are for.

[drbikeshorts]

Originally Posted by RiFiFi1955

Wow that is so awesome that you had people over and watched Fanny and Alexander over some coffee and what not. I virtually don't know a single person that I am acquainted with that would be up for doing something that.

I've also organised some of the same guys, plus Mrs Drbikeshorts, to see The Master in 70mm at The Astor Theatre in Melbourne tomorrow afternoon.
A couple of us already saw it in 70mm at the same theatre, with an introduction and a follow up Q&A with P.T. Anderson. Fantastic experience.
The film is a lot to take in, so I've been looking forward to seeing it again
Just so I'm still on topic: it would be great if Criterion releases it on blu-ray

[ElliesDad]

Originally Posted by retablo

Agreed, however I'd watch a Gone With the Wind remake, especially if it was done like a mini-series on HBO or something. Which is how I predicted movies would go a few years back. TV, the cinema's bastard step child, is now the more creative of the two, and offers up way more freedom and originality these days.

Blasphemy sir!! Unthinkable! even if it were eventually to be a Criterion release (to stay on topic). But I must agree there's some really stunning productions coming out of the cable network system these days.

[retablo]

Originally Posted by ElliesDad

Blasphemy sir!! Unthinkable! even if it were eventually to be a Criterion release (to stay on topic). But I must agree there's some really stunning productions coming out of the cable network system these days.

Yes, and hopefully one of them is the show I'm currently developing and wrote the pilot for, LOL.