The Lord of the Rings: The Motion Picture Trilogy (Extended Edition) (2001-2003)

[karlosfunkster]

Originally Posted by Boone_Carlyle

You do huh? Maybe that's why the green tint doesn't bother you???

It looks like art. When I paint I don't often use the correct palette, I go for vivacity. I like the look of the picture and think the colorization is more than acceptable and artistically credible..Anyway I'm sure you will be please to know that I am clocking off for the evening. Work in 6 hours, and apologies if my opinion offended anyone! I could have worded my statement a little better. G'night!

[Scooter1836]

Originally Posted by karlosfunkster

P.S. I didn't intend to be antagonistic, I'm just shocked at how great it looks after all this fuss!

It is not antagonistic.

the brina does handle pictures in motion differently. Still pics can and do look different than wathcing the actual movie. Which is why it could be intentional and PJ was looking at how it is viewd in it's proper setting.

[gstriftos]

Originally Posted by karlosfunkster

I

Good. And what are your thoughts then? Did you hate it or like it...or neither?

Some scenes are very disappointing,due to the new tint,while others are fabulous.
It would be an excellent presentation if it wasn't for the obvious blue/green/cyan tint in some scenes.
Even if they are intentional I 'll respect PJ choice but not change my view of perspective that they look ugly.


(I 've only quoted this part 'cause I don't want to continue answering to all other statements,so as to turn this to plain chatting).


Regargs,
George.

[karlosfunkster]

Originally Posted by mrpink134

Do I have to recall all your post? One of your post got deleted because it was an attack. If you don;t agree with them fine but don't make it personal .

Sorry my original post didn't make it clear that I was annoyed with all the opinions being made prior to almost anyone actually seeing the film. Perhaps that's what irritated some people.

I just wanted to put across a different opinion and that was to say that the pq was an improvement on the theatrical release and the colour changes looked acceptable to me. As promised I will new retire for the evening though...before I am drawn in again...the internet and sleep are not compatible.

Originally Posted by gstriftos

Some scenes are very disappointing,due to the new tint,while others are fabulous.
It would be an excellent presentation if it wasn't for the obvious blue/green/cyan tint in some scenes.
Even if they are intentional I 'll respect PJ choice but not change my view of perspective that they look ugly.


(I 've only quoted this part 'cause I don't want to continue answering to all other statements,so as to turn this to plain chatting).


Regargs,
George.

I can understand that opinion - as youclearly preferred the old colour theme, and that's fine. I loved it. Take care, sorry for any misunderstanding!

Originally Posted by Scooter1836

It is not antagonistic.

the brina does handle pictures in motion differently. Still pics can and do look different than wathcing the actual movie. Which is why it could be intentional and PJ was looking at how it is viewd in it's proper setting.

I hope that's what he wanted, I will of course stand in the corner facing the wall in embarrassment if he announces a re-call!

[frogmort]

I just find it odd that there is not one tiny little pixel of pure white in the entire movie, even though there are many shots of pure white in the other two movies. This more than anything just screams error to me.

[WorkShed]

Originally Posted by mrpink134

To be honest some of the stuff you posted was just rude. Trying to say that people who bought the disk are trying to justify the AV because they wasted money for instance.

You're telling me that you've never justified a purchase to yourself when something wasn't what you thought it would be? I do it all the time. I'm glad that people are watching it and some are liking it. However, I am positive that it would annoy me because I am very conscious about color temperatures and the effect on perception of tone and emotion.

[Todd Smith]

Originally Posted by frogmort

I just find it odd that there is not one tiny little pixel of pure white in the entire movie, even though there are many shots of pure white in the other two movies. This more than anything just screams error to me.

This strongly suggest error to me as well, along with blue snow, green soap suds, shirts, etc, etc....

[karlosfunkster]

Originally Posted by Roy Batty

Clearly somebody made a mistake...

They are set photo's not film, footage!

[J.Cornelius]

Originally Posted by Boone_Carlyle

There probably are people who like it "fo realz" but they aren't the ones here who feel compelled to defend it by telling everyone else to shut up. I'm sorry, but that's the truth.

I think you are mistaken, I think rational people are calmly saying don't rely on a still or a you tube clip on your computer to form your basis of opinion. Hypothectical you run into PJ at a 7-11 and you tell in the EE of FOTR new color timing sucks arse you hate it and he asks well did you actually watch the film in motion on your HD TV? What do you think his reaction would be when you say no but you have see internet stills and you tube clips? Don't tell me about Iona!

[karlosfunkster]

Originally Posted by Todd Smith

This strongly suggest error to me as well, along with blue snow, green soap suds, shirts, etc, etc....

Shirts are white throughout in daylight scenes - I have been whizzing through the film instead of sleeping to make sure!

[frogmort]

I'm going to go watch a movie. I will report back in afterward. You guys play nice!

[karlosfunkster]

Originally Posted by J.Cornelius

I think you are mistaken, I think rational people are calmly saying don't rely on a still or a you tube clip on your computer to form your basis of opinion. Hypothectical you run into PJ at a 7-11 and you tell in the EE of FOTR new color timing sucks arse you hate it and he asks well did you actually watch the film in motion on your HD TV? What do you think his reaction would be when you say no but you have see internet stills and you tube clips? Don't tell me about Iona!

Agreed.

Originally Posted by frogmort

I'm going to go watch a movie. I will report back in afterward. You guys play nice!

Don't blame you. I've turned it off now - quarter to 2 in the am here!

[frogmort]

Originally Posted by karlosfunkster

Shirts are white throughout in daylight scenes - I have been whizzing through the film instead of sleeping to make sure!

Looks like Peter Jackson whizzed through the movie too!

Have a good night.

[Todd Smith]

Originally Posted by Boone_Carlyle

http://www.firstshowing.net/2011/fir...ns-the-hobbit/

FOTG makes even less sense after viewing those few shots which did not have any nasty green tint..........this blu transfer has "mistake" written all over it.

[karlosfunkster]

Originally Posted by frogmort

Looks like Peter Jackson whizzed through the movie too!

Have a good night.

Very good!

[karlosfunkster]

Originally Posted by Todd Smith

FOTG makes even less sense after viewing those few shots which did not have any nasty green tint..........this blu transfer has "mistake" written all over it.

They are not from film footage, just set photo's - so that's not a great assumption to make. Most colours are changed in the edit suite...

[alex18]

I just logged in and saw the triology went down to $70!! I'm very happy.

[Petyr_Baelish]

Originally Posted by J.Cornelius

I think you are mistaken, I think rational people are calmly saying don't rely on a still or a you tube clip on your computer to form your basis of opinion. Hypothectical you run into PJ at a 7-11 and you tell in the EE of FOTR new color timing sucks arse you hate it and he asks well did you actually watch the film in motion on your HD TV? What do you think his reaction would be when you say no but you have see internet stills and you tube clips? Don't tell me about Iona!

How likely do you think it is that all this green tint stuff was invented? That it's all a hoax?

I'm sorry there is an alternate solution to the mind set of the "shut up naysayers" group. The others being they are crazy or they are Supernatural beings. If it is either of those cases: then I do not have the capacity to understand their motivations, and I will stop posting now.

[karlosfunkster]

Originally Posted by alex18

I just logged in and saw the triology went down to $70!! I'm very happy.

Clearing out all the miscoloured stock already? :-D

[alex18]

I've been waiting for these extended edition movies to release on BD forever.
As far as the picture issue everyone is complaining about BEFORE the release, I think we should watch the movies first and then judge.