INCEPTION Review Thread (SPOILERS!!)

[cajmoyper]

[Show spoiler]But even in the "first" limbo, he knew Saito was there. How could they have left one limbo together only to join again in another?

[Batman1980]

Originally Posted by cajmoyper

[Show spoiler]But even in the "first" limbo, he knew Saito was there. How could they have left one limbo together only to join again in another?

That's really odd, may actually just be a continuity error on the part of Nolan and his posse.

[Buddy Christ]

[Show spoiler]The limbo is left over from Mal and Doms "trip" Whenever someone goes to limbo its a limbo of someone who had one in that same shared dream. Meaning if Cobb was not there Saito's limbo would have been void of all consciousness.
It was the same place that Mal and Dom were. But because Saito died in his dream at such a deep level, time slowed down the most for him and since Dom was there voluntarily he did not age as much

[cajmoyper]

[Show spoiler]I remember when they had just got done with the first car chase, they said everyone "could" fall into limbo and it would be the same limbo if someone of the dreamshare had been there before. So that's how they got into the first, I guess. Even though Fischer arrived first.

[cajmoyper]

Originally Posted by Buddy Christ

[Show spoiler]The limbo is left over from Mal and Doms "trip" Whenever someone goes to limbo its a limbo of someone who had one in that same shared dream. Meaning if Cobb was not there Saito's limbo would have been void of all consciousness.
It was the same place that Mal and Dom were. But because Saito died in his dream at such a deep level, time slowed down the most for him and since Dom was there voluntarily he did not age as much

[Show spoiler]I don't think voluntarily or not has to do with the progression of time in limbo. Besides, like I said, it was Fischer who arrived first in limbo. And it couldn't have been Cobb's because it was a projection that would have had to take him there. That projection being Mal.

[SquidPuppet]

Originally Posted by opterasis

I wish CJackson would post about why he gave it one star. I'm curious if he's just trolling or legit reasons why he didn't like it when everyone so far seems to have loved it.

Trolling. Hes the Armond White of Blu-ray.com. Does it all the time.

[Batman1980]

retablo gave it one star also, would love to hear his reasoning behind that.

[Buddy Christ]

Originally Posted by cajmoyper

[Show spoiler]I don't think voluntarily or not has to do with the progression of time in limbo. Besides, like I said, it was Fischer who arrived first in limbo. And it couldn't have been Cobb's because it was a projection that would have had to take him there. That projection being Mal.

It was Cobbs, I'll get the quote tonight.

[cajmoyper]

Originally Posted by Buddy Christ

It was Cobbs, I'll get the quote tonight.

Ok, you're right about that part. I confused myself. But still,

[Show spoiler]I think whatever happened between Cobb "letting his wife go" and him waking up on the beach was quick. I just want to know how that happened.

[Batman1980]

Originally Posted by cajmoyper

Ok, you're right about that part. I confused myself. But still,

[Show spoiler]I think whatever happened between Cobb "letting his wife go" and him waking up on the beach was quick. I just want to know how that happened.

[Show spoiler]Limbo struck me as a place that's always in flux, even if the time there is different from any other place/dimension.

[cajmoyper]

I'd accept that. But I need some justification from the movie. But then again,

[Show spoiler]Cobb pretty clearly said he had spent 50 years or the equivalent down there with his wife.

[Batman1980]

Originally Posted by cajmoyper

I'd accept that. But I need some justification from the movie. But then again,

[Show spoiler]Cobb pretty clearly said he had spent 50 years or the equivalent down there with his wife.

Odd then that

[Show spoiler]they were able to get back out and were clearly nowhere near as aged as 50 years should've made them become.

[cajmoyper]

[Show spoiler]No, no, no. I meant 50 years in limbo. Sorry. Remember when it showed them walking through their creation as old people?

[Batman1980]

Originally Posted by cajmoyper

[Show spoiler]No, no, no. I meant 50 years in limbo. Sorry. Remember when it showed them walking through their creation as old people?

Yeah unless your head was turned or you just weren't paying attention, there's no way you could miss that.

[Versatil]

Originally Posted by SquidPuppet

Trolling. Hes the Armond White of Blu-ray.com. Does it all the time.

Don't forget Beast

[Batman1980]

Originally Posted by Versatil

Don't forget Beast

Beast isn't a troll per se, he just doesn't like Nolan's Batman films as much as most of us. WB better do this movie justice on blu-ray or I will be very upset. Come on give us a steelbook!

[cajmoyper]

Originally Posted by Gandalf Stormcrow

Yeah unless your head was turned or you just weren't paying attention, there's no way you could miss that.

[Batman1980]

Originally Posted by cajmoyper

Just saying it only happened for about 10-15 seconds but it was obviously done to show that

[Show spoiler]they did in fact spend 50 years down there creating their own worlds and growing old together.

[Foggy]

Originally Posted by Versatil

Don't forget Beast

Beast doesn't like The Dark Knight, he doesn't troll about any movie, just that one!

[Versatil]

Originally Posted by Foggy

Beast doesn't like The Dark Knight, he doesn't troll about any movie, just that one!

From what I know and what i discussed with him, he doesn't like all Nolan movies.