Rate the collection of the poster above you

[Travis]

Originally Posted by Kakashi Sensai

10/10 without even a detailed look. You have a very very good collection. The fact that you have Akira deserves a 10 by itself. I'm still waiting for it to come down in price......

Kakashi Sensai,

Solid. 10/10

*Has Wayne's World held up, or is it really dated. Love SNL in the early 90's and Wayne's World too, but so long ago, it is almost a blind buy now. And I find stuff I thought was funny years ago isn't funny now.

[Sagacious Koreo]

Originally Posted by Travis

I know what you mean, that's why I got Pearl Harbor and why The Rock is on my wishlist. Luckily my wife's tastes aren't that far from my, she just likes the Bruckheimer Blockbuster Action flicks, I could live with out them.

I could give you a 10/10 just for your concerts alone. Love 'em. 10/10 for the whole thing though. Top notch collection with plenty of diversity.

[kings35]

Originally Posted by Sagacious Koreo

I could give you a 10/10 just for your concerts alone. Love 'em. 10/10 for the whole thing though. Top notch collection with plenty of diversity.

9/10

aside from the japanese, anime, foreign stuff everything else is top notch. I'm not into that kinda stuff but everyone has different tastes

[csdot]

kings35
you have a ton of movies i cant stand, but there are quite a few redeeming titles mixed in there too! different strokes for different folks!
7/10

[ts0323]

Nice, varied collection. I love some of the trilogies you have.
9/10

[kevjan]

7/10. We have sorta the same taste but your collection is small and lacks variance. A bit kiddy. You are starting off well though.

[ts0323]

Originally Posted by kevjan

7/10. We have sorta the same taste but your collection is small and lacks variance. A bit kiddy. You are starting off well though.

Thanks.
I'd get more mature films if my parents would let me . Just look at my wishlist.

9.5/10 for your collection - you have a lot of great stuff in there!

[Dragon Lee]

Cool cool cool. 9/10

[bluearth]

Dragon Lee,

Quanity: 8/10

Quality: 8/10 - OK variety, but its obvious your still building your collection and are working on the movies you really liked first

Overall: 8/10 - Collection looks good in the early going

[The Rock]

Originally Posted by Dragon Lee

Cool cool cool. 9/10

Awesome start 10/10

[L32GTPCompG]

Originally Posted by aggienader08

You also have a great collection! Aside from the Batman Anthology! But my opinion, you obviously like it.

10/10

I only enjoy the first two, just for the record.

[Siri]

Originally Posted by L32GTPCompG

I only enjoy the first two, just for the record.

Very nice! 10/10 You have more Star Trek than I do, I've been meaning to get the first couple seasons.

[jhiggy23]

Originally Posted by Sirius389

Very nice! 10/10 You have more Star Trek than I do, I've been meaning to get the first couple seasons.

I give you an 9/10. The greatest asset of your collection is its size, obviously. However, with a large selection you have many titles I consider "throw aways." Of course, while I consider them that you obviously like them enough to buy and that's all that matters. I like the diversity of your collection and think you have a decent but not great number of foreign films. I think you lack in classics and with such a large collection, not having Criterions is astonishing!

[Siri]

Originally Posted by jhiggy23

I give you an 9/10. The greatest asset of your collection is its size, obviously. However, with a large selection you have many titles I consider "throw aways." Of course, while I consider them that you obviously like them enough to buy and that's all that matters. I like the diversity of your collection and think you have a decent but not great number of foreign films. I think you lack in classics and with such a large collection, not having Criterions is astonishing!

A couple years ago I would have used my age as an excuse for not having some classics, lol. I never understood the whole Criterion craze, some of the titles that you consider throw aways I might too but just cant see selling them to someone else for a few $$, so I just end up keeping them. I would love to have more foreign titles but dislike having to import BDs. More titles like The Warlords and Red Cliff need to be released here.

Thanks

[RampageIceman]

Originally Posted by Sirius389

A couple years ago I would have used my age as an excuse for not having some classics, lol. I never understood the whole Criterion craze, some of the titles that you consider throw aways I might too but just cant see selling them to someone else for a few $$, so I just end up keeping them. I would love to have more foreign titles but dislike having to import BDs. More titles like The Warlords and Red Cliff need to be released here.

Thanks

im giving you the full boat 10/10

I agree with the Criterion titles as there are many that are over rated or just plain dont have replay value

[gener]

To jihiggy: I like that you don't have Godfather 3 and that it is not even on your wishlist. You have a solid start to your collection. It's good to see that you have the Third Man Blu in your collection before you pay an arm and a leg for it later. The My cousin Vinny BD seems a little out of place in your collection as a whole...although it's not a bad movie by any means.

[jhiggy23]

Originally Posted by Sirius389

A couple years ago I would have used my age as an excuse for not having some classics, lol. I never understood the whole Criterion craze, some of the titles that you consider throw aways I might too but just cant see selling them to someone else for a few $$, so I just end up keeping them. I would love to have more foreign titles but dislike having to import BDs. More titles like The Warlords and Red Cliff need to be released here.

Thanks

It's all good, all that matters is you liking your collection and I must say, it's envious. I understand the import thing, but if you notice I only have one import (Downfall). There are many great domestic, Non-Criterion, foreign releases, such as Sophie Scholl, The Orphanage, and The Lives of Others. Red Cliff is domestic btw, idk if you knew that. It's the full length, 4 hour version and I got it on Amazon.

[jhiggy23]

Originally Posted by RampageIceman

im giving you the full boat 10/10

I agree with the Criterion titles as there are many that are over rated or just plain dont have replay value

Def understand the Criterion thing--they're not for everyone!

[jhiggy23]

Originally Posted by gener

To jihiggy: I like that you don't have Godfather 3 and that it is not even on your wishlist. You have a solid start to your collection. It's good to see that you have the Third Man Blu in your collection before you pay an arm and a leg for it later. The My cousin Vinny BD seems a little out of place in your collection as a whole...although it's not a bad movie by any means.

Thank you for looking and commenting. I despise Godfather III, like I do for Alien 3. I just think they're unnecessary and drag the series down as a whole. My wishlist is more indicative of my taste than what I own! (The Lives of Others is arguably my favorite film). My sig, which has my top unreleased blus is even more indicative of my taste haha

I got The Third Man during the Criterion sale last November for $14. I reserved it for three weeks, because the manager was a nice guy. It's still sealed! Love the film though, so I'd never sell it.

I'm surprised you think My Cousin Vinny is out of place--I would've thought you'd say The Transporter (it has a special place for me bc my grandfather and I watch martial arts/action films together and we like this one). My Cousin Vinny is considered a comedy classic and come on, it even won an Oscar (Tomei, deservedly so). It's actually my favorite pure comedy, followed by National Lampoon's Vacation and Playtime.

Sorry to derail the thread

[RampageIceman]

Originally Posted by jhiggy23

Thank you for looking and commenting. I despise Godfather III, like I do for Alien 3. I just think they're unnecessary and drag the series down as a whole. My wishlist is more indicative of my taste than what I own! (The Lives of Others is arguably my favorite film). My sig, which has my top unreleased blus is even more indicative of my taste haha

I got The Third Man during the Criterion sale last November for $14. I reserved it for three weeks, because the manager was a nice guy. It's still sealed! Love the film though, so I'd never sell it.

I'm surprised you think My Cousin Vinny is out of place--I would've thought you'd say The Transporter (it has a special place for me bc my grandfather and I watch martial arts/action films together and we like this one). My Cousin Vinny is considered a comedy classic and come on, it even won an Oscar (Tomei, deservedly so). It's actually my favorite pure comedy, followed by National Lampoon's Vacation and Playtime.

Sorry to derail the thread

I will go 10/10 as I see nothing for throw a way titles.. and I love the organization you have there... think I will be re doing mine like that... also good reviews and I am adding The New World to my NF Q as it sounds amazing!!