Rate the collection of the poster above you

[happydood]

Originally Posted by zorbonaut

Too large for my taste (my only knock) but I think I've looked at this collection before.

Very well rounded.

Very nice! 9.5/10

You're totally on the level. 9.75/10.

[ZeTi]

Originally Posted by happydood

You're totally on the level. 9.75/10.

Awesome collection Sir. Easy 9,5 / 10 ... only lacks in Asian cinema (personal preference of course). Rest is superb. We have classics we have Lynch we have Horror we have Western and with that "The Proposition" which is like a whole extra point just for this one.

Which makes the final score a 10.5 / 10. Nicely done.

[rockinrick]

Originally Posted by ZeTi

Awesome collection Sir. Easy 9,5 / 10 ... only lacks in Asian cinema (personal preference of course). Rest is superb. We have classics we have Lynch we have Horror we have Western and with that "The Proposition" which is like a whole extra point just for this one.

Which makes the final score a 10.5 / 10. Nicely done.

Interesting 8.5/10

[malakaheso]

9.5/10

[Darth Marcus]

Originally Posted by malakaheso

9.5/10

Damn near perfect. 9/10

[nancyjane]

Originally Posted by darth marcus

damn near perfect. 9/10

9/10

[Le samouraï13]

Originally Posted by nancyjane

9/10

A solid collection I like it...9/10

[Walts Ghost]

Originally Posted by Le samouraï13

A solid collection I like it...9/10

10/10

[145gtw]

Originally Posted by Walts Ghost

10/10

A phenomenal collection that offers something for everyone.

9.5/10

[L.J.]

Originally Posted by 145gtw

A phenomenal collection that offers something for everyone.

9.5/10

Lot of titles not that interested in but you a lot of hard to obtain price wise films. Great organization and several must haves for any collector. 7.5/10 based off our difference of taste in film. Collection wise an easy 9/10.

[ncraft]

Originally Posted by L.J.

Lot of titles not that interested in but you a lot of hard to obtain price wise films. Great organization and several must haves for any collector. 7.5/10 based off our difference of taste in film. Collection wise an easy 9/10.

9/10. Great variety of titles in every genre. Gotta love "Squint with Clint"

[Dark Detective]

Originally Posted by ncraft

9/10. Great variety of titles in every genre. Gotta love "Squint with Clint"

8/10 Aside from not having a dedicated horror section I really enjoyed your picks, especially your favorites.


For whoever is going to review my collection please keep in mind I just recently began building it up.

[grape_jelly]

Originally Posted by Dark Detective

8/10 Aside from not having a dedicated horror section I really enjoyed your picks, especially your favorites.


For whoever is going to review my collection please keep in mind I just recently began building it up.

It's not the size of the collection, it's how you use it. The smaller a collection is, the more honest it feels. You really get to see what films matter to a collector most. Larger collections are just too damn bloated. With that being said, give me your Ginger Snaps blu ray, and your Ash vs Evil Dead Season 1

A-

[blufellas]

Originally Posted by grape_jelly

It's not the size of the collection, it's how you use it. The smaller a collection is, the more honest it feels. You really get to see what films matter to a collector most. Larger collections are just too damn bloated. With that being said, give me your Ginger Snaps blu ray, and your Ash vs Evil Dead Season 1

A-

Nice collection. 9/10

[Brutalizer79]

Originally Posted by blufellas

Nice collection. 9/10

Great collection, 10/10

[blufellas]

Originally Posted by Brutalizer79

Great collection, 10/10

Awesome horror collection. 10/10

[OneWayFilms]

Originally Posted by blufellas

Awesome horror collection. 10/10

OK, you have an interesting collection. Some decent films in there, but we have a different overall taste in movies.

A few comments on your categories: You have "D. The Walking Dead". Did you seriously just put the Waking Dead under D for DEAD? I don't get it. You don't have any of the other categories with letters, why for your Walking Dead? And why is it under D? It should be under W if anything.

I never saw anyone put a wishlist in the middle of their collection, but OK....whatever.

You only have one page under categories and everything else under OWNED.

If you're still in the process of categorizing them and it's just incomplete, then why not wait till it's done to post and request being rated? But if you're done, then it's just lazy.

For categories, I have to rate you a 3/10. You tried.
For films, I'll give you a 8/10, not too bad.
Your passion for films DOES show and you have committed yourself to a large collection, for that I give you a 10/10.

Your total is 6/10.

[koover]

Originally Posted by OneWayFilms

OK, you have an interesting collection. Some decent films in there, but we have a different overall taste in movies.

A few comments on your categories: You have "D. The Walking Dead". Did you seriously just put the Waking Dead under D for DEAD? I don't get it. You don't have any of the other categories with letters, why for your Walking Dead? And why is it under D? It should be under W if anything.

I never saw anyone put a wishlist in the middle of their collection, but OK....whatever.

You only have one page under categories and everything else under OWNED.

If you're still in the process of categorizing them and it's just incomplete, then why not wait till it's done to post and request being rated? But if you're done, then it's just lazy.

For categories, I have to rate you a 3/10. You tried.
For films, I'll give you a 8/10, not too bad.
Your passion for films DOES show and you have committed yourself to a large collection, for that I give you a 10/10.

Your total is 6/10.

The titles we have in common (what you own) is little less then half, but the
ones we differ in, "really" differs.

Musicals and theater is something I just can't get in to at all and would rather get out of the hobby or have hot needles piercing my eyes if I had to sit through these.

Even though I own a few like Sound of Music and a few others (don't even know what they are as they're my wife's and daughters films) I could never watch them unless they begged me.

I don't understand why you have your drama by years and nothing else. There must be something about drama that they must have years. I don't get it. Your Fathers day section? Don't get it. Gladiator? OK.
Lastly....Your Avatar. Yikes!

Overall a collection that's merely OK for "me" but obviously you love it and that's all that matters. Enjoy!

[Phil92]

Originally Posted by koover

The titles we have in common (what you own) is little less then half, but the
ones we differ in, "really" differs.

Musicals and theater is something I just can't get in to at all and would rather get out of the hobby or have hot needles piercing my eyes if I had to sit through these.

Even though I own a few like Sound of Music and a few others (don't even know what they are as they're my wife's and daughters films) I could never watch them unless they begged me.

I don't understand why you have your drama by years and nothing else. There must be something about drama that they must have years. I don't get it. Your Fathers day section? Don't get it. Gladiator? OK.
Lastly....Your Avatar. Yikes!

Overall a collection that's merely OK for "me" but obviously you love it and that's all that matters. Enjoy!

Unprecedented. 10/10. Your categories are sharp and you've got a wide selection, covering every genre. Good selection of TV series and 3D films, very envious of your collection. You have a few duds (Big Momma?), but so do I - including that title.

Brava. One of, if not, the best collection I've seen on here.

[happydood]

Originally Posted by Phil92

Unprecedented. 10/10. Your categories are sharp and you've got a wide selection, covering every genre. Good selection of TV series and 3D films, very envious of your collection. You have a few duds (Big Momma?), but so do I - including that title.

Brava. One of, if not, the best collection I've seen on here.

Good for what you're going for and makes sense. I lament the lack of 1920s-70s, but pretty thorough for what you like! 8/10