Rate the collection of the poster above you

[happydood]

Originally Posted by robert2339

Your collection is okay. Some nice steel books. But overall it's pretty basic. 4/10

You have a lot of great movies, but also a lot that are kind of disposable to me.

But 7/10.

[Blu Jedi Master]

8/10 You have some Dramas (Quiet Man) I would like to get.

[KillaCam]

Originally Posted by Blu Jedi Master

8/10 You have some Dramas (Quiet Man) I would like to get.

7/10 You have a decent selection of war and westerns for a collection of your size. A bit too much romance for my taste though and I would prefer to see more horror and at least a little anime

[robert2339]

Originally Posted by KillaCam

7/10 You have a decent selection of war and westerns for a collection of your size. A bit too much romance for my taste though and I would prefer to see more horror and at least a little anime

You have a lot of great stuff. Epic amount of Criterion's. Some titles were meh. But almost everyone has a great number of meh's in their collection. 8.5/10

[rockinrick]

Originally Posted by stigdu

A fan of steelbooks and comedies from the looks of things. And very modern tastes!

7.5/10

You have a great collection ! 9.5/10

[Phil92]

Originally Posted by robert2339

You have a lot of great stuff. Epic amount of Criterion's. Some titles were meh. But almost everyone has a great number of meh's in their collection. 8.5/10

Straight 10/10.

[rockinrick]

Originally Posted by robert2339

You have a lot of great stuff. Epic amount of Criterion's. Some titles were meh. But almost everyone has a great number of meh's in their collection. 8.5/10

9/10 Some categories would be nice.

[rockinrick]

Originally Posted by phil92

straight 10/10.

8/10

[nancyjane]

Originally Posted by rockinrick

8/10

10/10

[nerdy916]

Originally Posted by nancyjane

10/10

10/10

[KeithVK]

Originally Posted by nerdy916

10/10

Smaller collection but great horror titles. I also have to give you some bonus points for having the Pee-wee set 7/10

Originally Posted by Dirk504

10/10

He probably has every Blu Ray ever released. Awesome collection!

I wish... I'm just doing my part to stimulate the economy

[Dirk504]

Originally Posted by KeithVK

Smaller collection but great horror titles. I also have to give you some bonus points for having the Pee-wee set 7/10

10/10

He probably has every Blu Ray ever released. Awesome collection!

[kylec123]

Originally Posted by Dirk504

10/10

He probably has every Blu Ray ever released. Awesome collection!

7/10

Mostly stuff I'd never want to own. Got a few films I'd like to own though. Overall fine collection, just not my tastes.

[Walts Ghost]

Originally Posted by kylec123

7/10

Mostly stuff I'd never want to own. Got a few films I'd like to own though. Overall fine collection, just not my tastes.

Small collection. Quite a few good titles. But a lot of room for expansion.

6/10

[Lordy]

Originally Posted by Walts Ghost

Small collection. Quite a few good titles. But a lot of room for expansion.

6/10

I'll give you a 7/10, which is pretty good from a snob like me. Heck, last time I played this game I only got a 6 from some dude with less than 100 in his...pffft.......go figure!

[kylec123]

Originally Posted by Lordy

I'll give you a 7/10, which is pretty good from a snob like me. Heck, last time I played this game I only got a 6 from some dude with less than 100 in his...pffft.......go figure!

I mean.....just because someone only owns 30 blu's doesn't mean they don't have an opinion.

Yeah you have a shit ton of movies. You're definitely gaining points for that. That being said, most of the ones I looked at I wouldn't buy for a dollar. Coming from someone who have different tastes,doesn't see much wow in numbers, and is not really interested in standard blu ray collection, I'd rate you 7/10.

No harsh feelings. Just giving my opinion.

[Batman1980]

Originally Posted by kylec123

I mean.....just because someone only owns 30 blu's doesn't mean they don't have an opinion.

I only looked at the first two pages of your collection. Yeah you have a shit ton of movies. Your definitely gaining points for that. That being said, most of the ones I looked at I wouldn't buy for a dollar. Coming from someone who have different tastes and dosn't see much wow in numbers, I'd rate you 5-6/10 too.

No harsh feelings. Just giving my opinion.

6.5/10 for you, you have a very nice starter collection. Also I agree, sheer volume does not equal quality, which is what this thread is about last I checked.

[kylec123]

You can skip this post. I edited my last "rating" to more accurately reflect my opinion and fixed some typo's. haha

[ThatOneGuy]

Originally Posted by Batman1980

6.5/10 for you, you have a very nice starter collection. Also I agree, sheer volume does not equal quality, which is what this thread is about last I checked.

7/10 - Some really good movies mixed in with pretty bad movies and you lack older films.

I think it all just depends on the person looking at the collection, someone with a huge library might collect films because they love films enough that they are willing to build a house out of the terrible films' cases in their collection... or they simply want a library of all films they can get their hands on. Both are very respectful reasons to me, so if the huge collection is noticeably diverse, they get a high score from me even if they have a ton of horrible films (like those B-Rate horrors)... just don't have Frozen or if they are building a house, they can use that film as the toilet and I'll be happy with their collection.

[Le samouraï13]

Originally Posted by John Klein

7/10 - Some really good movies mixed in with pretty bad movies and you lack older films.

I think it all just depends on the person looking at the collection, someone with a huge library might collect films because they love films enough that they are willing to build a house out of the terrible films' cases in their collection... or they simply want a library of all films they can get their hands on. Both are very respectful reasons to me, so if the huge collection is noticeably diverse, they get a high score from me even if they have a ton of horrible films (like those B-Rate horrors)... just don't have Frozen or if they are building a house, they can use that film as the toilet and I'll be happy with their collection.

It's hard to rate your collection because you have some real gems in your collection and some real duds so I will give it a...8/10