Rate the collection of the poster above you

[Zandery]

Originally Posted by koover

Really nice collection. Very personal tastes and off the beaten path for the most part. Like your TV box sets. Overall I like it even though we differ in so many ways. That's what's great about taste!
9/10

Damn man! You're collection is epic! 9/10, soo many awesome films

[TheGentlemanBat]

Originally Posted by Zandery

Damn man! You're collection is epic! 9/10, soo many awesome films

It's hard to rate your collection cause we really have different tastes (never been very fond of Christmas movies, I'm not a big comedy lover and even if I'm French, apart from a few directors I like, I'm not very interested in the films we produce). Give you a 6,5/10, hope you won't hold a grudge against me.

[Jack Webb]

Originally Posted by TheGentlemanBat

It's hard to rate your collection cause we really have different tastes (never been very fond of Christmas movies, I'm not a big comedy lover and even if I'm French, apart from a few directors I like, I'm not very interested in the films we produce). Give you a 6,5/10, hope you won't hold a grudge against me.

Very cool. Small but lots of interesting stuff. 9/10

[zorbonaut]

Originally Posted by Jack Webb

Very cool. Small but lots of interesting stuff. 9/10

Great collection- love the categories! 9/10

[AstroChicken]

Originally Posted by zorbonaut

Great collection- love the categories! 9/10

Interesting categories. Nice variety of films. Needs more 80's movies

8/10

edit: Your DVD collection is not too shabby either! Glad to see Out of Sight there, I've been wanting to rewatch that movie after revisiting the great Jackie Brown recently.

[tiger_qc]

Originally Posted by AstroChicken

Interesting categories. Nice variety of films. Needs more 80's movies

8/10

edit: Your DVD collection is not too shabby either! Glad to see Out of Sight there, I've been wanting to rewatch that movie after revisiting the great Jackie Brown recently.

With 150 matching titles it would be hard to give a bad score but you lose half a point for each of the original Star Wars missing.

8.5/10

[zorbonaut]

Originally Posted by AstroChicken

Interesting categories. Nice variety of films. Needs more 80's movies

8/10

edit: Your DVD collection is not too shabby either! Glad to see Out of Sight there, I've been wanting to rewatch that movie after revisiting the great Jackie Brown recently.

Thanks for looking at my DVD collection- Have several titles that I have yet to upgrade or they are either OOP or have yet to get HD treatment. Also have decent amount of Digital Copies.

Love your collection. 9/10

Originally Posted by tiger_qc

With 150 matching titles it would be hard to give a bad score but you lose half a point for each of the original Star Wars missing.

8.5/10

Rated it before and giving it a 9/10- Nice collection

[poke smot]

Originally Posted by zorbonaut

Thanks for looking at my DVD collection- Have several titles that I have yet to upgrade or they are either OOP or have yet to get HD treatment. Also have decent amount of Digital Copies.

Love your collection. 9/10




Rated it before and giving it a 9/10- Nice collection

A great collection that not only spans many genres but also many decades of cinema. 8/10

[AstroChicken]

Originally Posted by tiger_qc

With 150 matching titles it would be hard to give a bad score but you lose half a point for each of the original Star Wars missing.

8.5/10

Check again, I own The Empire Strikes Again.

I refuse to buy A New Hope and Return of the Jedi though because they each contain one change that I cannot abide. I don't sweat the cosmetic stuff but when a change ****s with characterization, that's a real problem. As such I get my fix of those films via Harmy's Despecialized Editions.

That said I'm still hoping Disney will release something closer to the theatrical versions on blu-ray at some point...

[Badas]

Originally Posted by AstroChicken

Check again, I own The Empire Strikes Again.

I refuse to buy A New Hope and Return of the Jedi though because they each contain one change that I cannot abide. As such I get my fix of those films via Harmy's Despecialized Editions.

Geez. Nice collection. 10/10

[TwinCitiesBluFan]

Originally Posted by Badas

Geez. Nice collection. 10/10

Wow! Awesome array of titles and really well-organized!

10/10!

[Walts Ghost]

Originally Posted by TwinCitiesBluFan

Wow! Awesome array of titles and really well-organized!

10/10!

Huge collection with a lot to love!

10/10

[tiger_qc]

Originally Posted by AstroChicken

Check again, I own The Empire Strikes Again.

I refuse to buy A New Hope and Return of the Jedi though because they each contain one change that I cannot abide. I don't sweat the cosmetic stuff but when a change ****s with characterization, that's a real problem. As such I get my fix of those films via Harmy's Despecialized Editions.

That said I'm still hoping Disney will release something closer to the theatrical versions on blu-ray at some point...

The Empire Strikes Back, I missed that, I guess I expected to see A New Hope in your 70s titles and didn't check further. 9/10

TFA isn't great but it brought some of the nostalgia about the first trilogy back IMHO.

[alexroubaix]

Originally Posted by tiger_qc

The Empire Strikes Back, I missed that, I guess I expected to see A New Hope in your 70s titles and didn't check further. 9/10

TFA isn't great but it brought some of the nostalgia about the first trilogy back IMHO.

9/10: A giant collection with many great titles!

[blurayfriend]

Originally Posted by alexroubaix

9/10: A giant collection with many great titles!

You've got pretty much everything, a nice variety of titles and old favorites instead of just new stuff. 9/10!

[kylec123]

Originally Posted by blurayfriend

You've got pretty much everything, a nice variety of titles and old favorites instead of just new stuff. 9/10!

A fine collection. You are quite lacking on older stuff and/or non-English Language film. Overall, Some definite good titles and quite a few I personally would never consider to own. 7/10

[145gtw]

Originally Posted by kylec123

A fine collection. You are quite lacking on older stuff and/or non-English Language film. Overall, Some definite good titles and quite a few I personally would never consider to own. 7/10

While a bit small; that's a quality collection.

8.5/10

[malakaheso]

^^Great collection. 9/10

[grape_jelly]

Originally Posted by malakaheso

^^Great collection. 9/10

Aside from the impressive Criterions, the thing I enjoy most about your collection is that you really have some niche titles in there. It's a great way to make a collection unique and really stand out. Shows you have your own taste and don't just follow what everyone else seems to like. Lots of horror and sci-fi as well.

I give your collection a solid A, my friend.

Just do me a favor and throw The Nightmare Before Xmas in the trash for me. Thanks. lol

[blurayfriend]

^ You have a superb collection, it's tailored to you. So many great niche titles, love the Kevin Smith section in particular. I'm the same way, I likes what I likes and my collection just screams "me." 9/10