Rate the collection of the poster above you

[Batman1980]

Originally Posted by P@t_Mtl

Tai Chi is a comedy so be warned it's a bit silly and can surprise people who don't know anything about it.

Mulan is good but I am a great fan of Zhao Wei so I am biase. If you can sort of overlook how anyone can think she is a man then you are ok

9/10 for the odd duck, Pat.

[Nightshade]

Originally Posted by Gandalf Stormcrow

9/10 for the odd duck, Pat.

10/10 wow very nice !




-itswez

[P@t_Mtl]

Originally Posted by Gandalf Stormcrow

9/10 for the odd duck, Pat.

Odd is my middle name

[Johnny Vinyl]

Originally Posted by P@t_Mtl

Odd is my middle name

9.9999/10

I normally only rate that high for peope with massive collections, but you deserve the same for the diversity of titles. There are movies there I haven't ever heard of and some nice Criterions as well. Keep growing your collecting...it's fantastic.

John

[Ite]

Originally Posted by P@t_Mtl

Odd is my middle name

Wow great variety. 8.5/10.

[Ite]

Originally Posted by John72953

9.9999/10

I normally only rate that high for peope with massive collections, but you deserve the same for the diversity of titles. There are movies there I haven't ever heard of and some nice Criterions as well. Keep growing your collecting...it's fantastic.

John

Odd collection lol. 6/10.

[hidef al]

Originally Posted by Ite

Odd collection lol. 6/10.

Cool collection. Need more blus though.

7/10

[Xtrem3]

Originally Posted by hidef al

Cool collection. Need more blus though.

7/10

You have a good collection and a big collection,keep going blu owns 8/10

[Taipan]

Originally Posted by P@t_Mtl

Tai Chi is a comedy so be warned it's a bit silly and can surprise people who don't know anything about it.

Mulan is good but I am a great fan of Zhao Wei so I am biase. If you can sort of overlook how anyone can think she is a man then you are ok

Really.... interesting! I'll have to watch a trailer for Tai Chi.

I knew she looked familiar from the review stills. I'll keep Mulan on my future list.

Thanks Pat!

[frightism]

Taipan
I like your collection
8/10

[The Blu Knight]

Originally Posted by frightism

Taipan
I like your collection
8/10

Good start, good wishlist. 8/10

[Gamma_Winstead]

Very good! 9/10

[thodafett]

Oh man!!! Batman and Robin? Are you kidding me? that drops you to 8/10, very nice collection otherwise!!!

[ScarredLungs]

Originally Posted by thodafett

Oh man!!! Batman and Robin? Are you kidding me? that drops you to 8/10, very nice collection otherwise!!!

I'd give you a 8 of 10. You have some good movies, but still a small, yet growing collection. Also, the twilight film had to drop you some points as well

[Jezza]

Originally Posted by thodafett

Oh man!!! Batman and Robin? Are you kidding me? that drops you to 8/10, very nice collection otherwise!!!

Apart from a few titles I would never care for, I'd pretty much agree with everything you have and you also have a nice variety - 10/10.

[Ernest Rister]

CloneT, you have a fledgling collection, but you've already secured most of the essential hand-drawn Disney titles currently available. I'd suggest some more PIXAR and Roving Mars, which contains all of Walt Disney and Ward Kimball's sensational "Mars and Beyond" short animated feature. Very jealous that you have Dumbo.

My collection isn't much bigger than yours - I'd suggest some more variety, but you're on your way to having a complete Disney animated feature blu-ray collection.

I give you only a 7/10, but only for size. Can't argue with your titles.

[Jezza]

Originally Posted by Ernest Rister

CloneT, you have a fledgling collection, but you've already secured the essential hand-drawn Disney titles. I'd suggest some more PIXAR and Roving Mars, which contains all of Walt Disney and Ward Kimball's sensational "Mars and Beyond" short animated feature. Very jealous that you have Dumbo.

My collection isn't much bigger than yours - I'd suggest some more variety, but you're on your way to having a complete Disney animated feature blu-ray collection.

I give you 7/10, only for size. Can't argue with your titles.

OK I'll look into it.

I would have a lot more titles, but I'm very short of cash and have been trying to get all the possible animated classics first since they're only out for a short period, but now that I have them I'll move onto other titles and get more variety.

10/10 for you though.

[Lope de Aguirre]

It's hard to give recommendations cause as for now the collection has a small range of mocve types.

best:
- Dumbo
- Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
- Toy Story

worst:
- Star Wars: Clone Wars
- Bean
- Pirates of the Carribean: Dead Man's Chest

needed:
- Firefly
- Star Trek
- Lost


I'll give you a 5/10.
Not cause it's a small collection but I give you a high rating for the Disney movies and a low rating for most of the Action/Sci-Fi movies and Comedies.

[Jezza]

Originally Posted by Lope de Aguirre

It's hard to give recommendations cause as for now the collection has a small range of mocve types.

best:
- Dumbo
- Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
- Toy Story

worst:
- Star Wars: Clone Wars
- Bean
- Pirates of the Carribean: Dead Man's Chest

needed:
- Firefly
- Star Trek
- Lost


I'll give you a 5/10.
Not cause it's a small collection but I give you a high rating for the Disney movies and a low rating for most of the Action/Sci-Fi movies and Comedies.

Sorry to give another reply, but I think you've been very harsh on me by only giving me 5/10, when most everyone else gives me 7-10/10.

As for my "worst" selection, well I got POTC for free from DMR and there was nothing else at the time of redeeming it. The Clone Wars - I'll agree isn't a great film, but the TV series is and because I want all of The Clone Wars I got the movie when it was extremely cheap in the sale. As for Bean, well I don't know if you mean both films or just the first, but since I have the TV show on DVD and wanted Mr Bean's Holiday on Blu-ray, I just thought I might as well have both in HD if I'm getting one.

And then on the "needed" selection, well I don't want any of them, so I don't need them. Star Trek just doesn't interest me anymore, Firefly I've never even seen and isn't out on Blu-ray in the UK and I don't import Blu-rays, and I haven't even seen Lost either. It might be an award winning series, but I don't have the money to go out and buy a complete set, and I never buy blind.

I'll give you 5/10 as well, not because you gave me the same mark, but because there's so little there that actually interests me.

[hobgoblin]

Originally Posted by Clone Trooper

Sorry to give another reply, but I think you've been very harsh on me by only giving me 5/10, when most everyone else gives me 7-10/10.

As for my "worst" selection, well I got POTC for free from DMR and there was nothing else at the time of redeeming it. The Clone Wars - I'll agree isn't a great film, but the TV series is and because I want all of The Clone Wars I got the movie when it was extremely cheap in the sale. As for Bean, well I don't know if you mean both films or just the first, but since I have the TV show on DVD and wanted Mr Bean's Holiday on Blu-ray, I just thought I might as well have both in HD if I'm getting one.

And then on the "needed" selection, well I don't want any of them, so I don't need them. Star Trek just doesn't interest me anymore, Firefly I've never even seen and isn't out on Blu-ray in the UK and I don't import Blu-rays, and I haven't even seen Lost either. It might be an award winning series, but I don't have the money to go out and buy a complete set, and I never buy blind.

I'll give you 5/10 as well, not because you gave me the same mark, but because there's so little there that actually interests me.

CT, I'd rate yours 8/10.

Plenty of Disneys (which I really need to start buying), Piranha on it's way (a guilty pleasure if ever there was one) and T2 (need I say more). Your comedies are not really my sort of thing, but hey, everyones entitled to their own opinion.