Rate the collection of the poster above you

[FrodoBagginz]

Originally Posted by tuck301

8/10 nice stuff but like me, you could use more classics.

9/10

You have quite a few of movies that I have and have lots that I would love to have but cannot afford right now.

[Ite]

Originally Posted by FrodoBagginz

9/10

You have quite a few of movies that I have and have lots that I would love to have but cannot afford right now.

6.5/10 needs alot more movies and you have 2012.

[adgegavkyle]

Originally Posted by Ite

6.5/10 needs alot more movies and you have 2012.

8.5/10 cool collection plus you have hatchet.

[Scarriere]

Originally Posted by Ite

6.5/10 needs alot more movies and you have 2012.

That was a bit harsh and I disagree with your rating.
I'd give it an 8.5 to 9.5.

[koover]

Originally Posted by Scarriere

That was a bit harsh and I disagree with your rating.
I'd give it an 8.5 to 9.5.

There was absolutely nothing harsh about his comments. Nothing a couple hundred other people have'nt said on this site before. Plus it's his opinion.

To your collection. I think overall very solid. I Like a lot of your titles. You have very few sci-fi's and really no classics.
Still will give it an 8 anyhow!

[KrugerIndustrial]

Originally Posted by koover

There was absolutely nothing harsh about his comments. Nothing a couple hundred other people have'nt said on this site before. Plus it's his opinion.

To your collection. I think overall very solid. I Like a lot of your titles. You have very few sci-fi's and really no classics.
Still will give it an 8 anyhow!

Don't really care for 3D at all. I'd add more classics and maybe some imports too. Quite a few films I wouldn't purchase but overall a solid collection with fine titles. 7/10.

[koover]

Originally Posted by KrugerIndustrial

Don't really care for 3D at all. I'd add more classics and maybe some imports too. Quite a few films I wouldn't purchase but overall a solid collection with fine titles. 7/10.

Funny.............you don't care for 3D and I'm not a fan of imports. Just not my thing. To each his own which is what it's all about anyway. Next poster please rate KrugerIndustrial.

[Le samouraï13]

Originally Posted by KrugerIndustrial

Don't really care for 3D at all. I'd add more classics and maybe some imports too. Quite a few films I wouldn't purchase but overall a solid collection with fine titles. 7/10.

An OK collection I’ve seen most of the movies in your collection and IMHO most of them don’t have any replay value also there are very few comedies (most don’t even count) and very few animation also I’m not going to look through your wishlist since there so many and you don’t own them yet so overall…6/10

[KrugerIndustrial]

Originally Posted by Le samouraï13

An OK collection I’ve seen most of the movies in your collection and IMHO most of them don’t have any replay value also there are very few comedies (most don’t even count) and very few animation also I’m not going to look through your wishlist since there so many and you don’t own them yet so overall…6/10

There are not that many comedies worth buying these days and especially region free/b-releases. I have almost all of Pixars titles and I don't really care for Disney's stuff except for those classics that are on my wishlist.

Lastly, I purchase a film mainly because I like it and if it offers an upgrade from the previous release. And I feel most of my films indeed have replay value though not if you watch them every month. I'm not into modern Hollywood crap, steelbooks or other similar nonsense so I understand why my collection might get lower ratings from some users. But I appreciate your opinion and thanks for the rating.

[The Duke]

Originally Posted by KrugerIndustrial

There are not that many comedies worth buying these days and especially region free/b-releases. I have almost all of Pixars titles and I don't really care for Disney's stuff except for those classics that are on my wishlist.

Lastly, I purchase a film mainly because I like it and if it offers an upgrade from the previous release. And I feel most of my films indeed have replay value though not if you watch them every month. I'm not into modern Hollywood crap, steelbooks or other similar nonsense so I understand why my collection might get lower ratings from some users. But I appreciate your opinion and thanks for the rating.

I'll offer a second opinion, as I was going to rate your collection and then got busy with something else. 9/10 - Very nice collection, a great mix of Classics and good contemporary films. Did you make those categories your self (Foreign Language, Music, TV, etc.)? I was thinking of sorting my collection that way, but awfully time consuming. And kudos for scoring a copy of the UK SC Collection of Mulholland Drive, very hard to get. I gave up after a month and got the Italian version from eBay. And I agree 100% on comedies, I love comedy but what they pass off as comedy these days is just dumb and dumber. Rented & hated Hangover, it wasn't funny, just stupid.

[LuFeng]

Excellent collection Duke, I also see you are a fan of John Wayne so much props...

10/10

Originally Posted by The Duke

I offer a second opinion, as I was going to rate your collection and then got busy with something else. 9/10 - Very nice collection, a great mix of Classics and good contemporary films. Did you make those categories your self (Foreign Language, Music, TV, etc.)? I was thinking of sorting my collection that way, but awfully time consuming. And kudos for scoring a copy of the UK SC Collection of Mulholland Drive, very hard to get. I gave up after a month and got the Italian version from eBay. And I agree 100% on comedies, I love comedy but what they pass off as comedy these days is just dumb and dumber. Rented & hated Hangover, it wasn't funny, just stupid.

[Le samouraï13]

Originally Posted by KrugerIndustrial

There are not that many comedies worth buying these days and especially region free/b-releases. I have almost all of Pixars titles and I don't really care for Disney's stuff except for those classics that are on my wishlist.

Lastly, I purchase a film mainly because I like it and if it offers an upgrade from the previous release. And I feel most of my films indeed have replay value though not if you watch them every month. I'm not into modern Hollywood crap, steelbooks or other similar nonsense so I understand why my collection might get lower ratings from some users. But I appreciate your opinion and thanks for the rating.

No problem about the rating that’s what this thread is all about. I don’t rate a collection solely on the fact that a collection has any steelbooks or special editions or not but on how entertaining the collection is (to me of course) it makes me laugh when other members rate someone’s collection high just because there collection contains nothing but foreign films or classical titles. But in reality most of those films after one viewing feel like work to sit though again for me at least but I also consider that people have their own taste.

[lowsilv]

really nice collection. nicely organised. dig it. n u have nut up or shut up. WOW. 10/10

[adgegavkyle]

I really like your collection. 9/10

[poke smot]

Originally Posted by adgegavkyle

I really like your collection. 9/10

9/10- one of the bigger comedy collections ive seen. u could use more classics.

[tama]

Originally Posted by tuck301

9/10- one of the bigger comedy collections ive seen. u could use more classics.

You have alot of fun action movies 8/10

[prkprkprk]

Originally Posted by tama

You have alot of fun action movies 8/10

Big collection filled with excellent movies. 10/10.

[Blu Jedi Master]

Originally Posted by adgegavkyle

I really like your collection. 9/10

9.8/10 Nice amount of Horror. I do not like Horror movies but respect those who do just the same.

Originally Posted by prkprkprk

Big collection filled with excellent movies. 10/10.

8/10 Like that Indiana Jones Digi

[Hucksta G]

Originally Posted by dallascowboys1

9.8/10 Nice amount of Horror. I do not like Horror movies but respect those who do just the same.




8/10 Like that Indiana Jones Digi

7/10 just too many titles I wouldn't want to own but still there are some good ones there that i do own eitehr on Blu or DVD.

[Rudeboy2025]

Originally Posted by Hucksta G

7/10 just too many titles I wouldn't want to own but still there are some good ones there that i do own eitehr on Blu or DVD.

Great collection! I had no idea The Deer Hunter was already released on Blu in other countries.

9.5/10