Rate the collection of the poster above you

[koover]

Originally Posted by HD Goofnut

A few duds, but the steelbooks make up for that. 9/10.

We have a lot of the same titles so I think u have great taste. Many that I don't have but nothing in my opion that I personally wouldn't like. Nice collection man!
9.5

[El_Jay]

Originally Posted by koover

We have a lot of the same titles so I think u have great taste. Many that I don't have but nothing in my opion that I personally wouldn't like. Nice collection man!
9.5

Very, very strong collection.

Tons of titles, well-organized, and overall pretty decent quality control considering the sheer bulk. Some older action movies are pretty cheesy, but I appreciate that kind of cheese so it doesn't detract anything.

10/10.

Organization goes a little too far, though. I don't think "the classics" should be a genre in and of itself, the movies should just be listed in their genres like everything else. I was about to question your sanity when I didn't see any Leone movies in your western section, but then I saw them in "the classics". Just a small nitpick.

[BohemianGraham]

Originally Posted by El_Jay

Very, very strong collection.

Tons of titles, well-organized, and overall pretty decent quality control considering the sheer bulk. Some older action movies are pretty cheesy, but I appreciate that kind of cheese so it doesn't detract anything.

10/10.

Organization goes a little too far, though. I don't think "the classics" should be a genre in and of itself, the movies should just be listed in their genres like everything else. I was about to question your sanity when I didn't see any Leone movies in your western section, but then I saw them in "the classics". Just a small nitpick.

7.5/10 - A lot of titles I don't particularly care for.

[Phoenix Theory]

U guys skipped me.

[BohemianGraham]

Originally Posted by xphoenix23

U guys skipped me.

9/10. You need more classics.

[Todd_Gaines]

Originally Posted by BohemianGraham

9/10. You need more classics.

007 & cartoons are not my cup of tea, but your Criterion's help your score a lot 8 /10

[Le samouraï13]

Originally Posted by tama

You have a decent americanized collection but lack many contemporary, arthouse, an classic titles. You have a great steelbook and limited edition collection going but have several dugs alias Salt, Paul, Wanted, etc...your foreign title seems mostly tied to your criterion collection. No film-noir such as The Maltese Falcon or Kiss Me Deadly. Overall solid collection but many title just aren't my cup of tea. 7/10

I have plenty foreign films in my collection that I like to watch again from time to time it just seems like you took a quick look at my collection and missed some that are not Criterion. I have seen many “contemporary, arthouse, an classic titles” that you speak of and in many cases with me most are great films and should be viewed once but also for me most don’t have any replay value hence no reason for me to own them. I base my purchase of a Blu-ray on how entertain the film is to me because at the end of the day that’s what matters the most. I find it funny that a collection is rated high just because that person’s collection consist of many foreign films that an average person wouldn’t even know but automatically assume they are great films but most of the time they’re not and some are just plain boring and no I don’t just watch Michael bay films but just speaking from past experience. By looking at your collection it seems like you focus mainly on “Contemporary, arthouse, an classic titles” which is cool and most I’ve seen but on a entertainment level your collection suffers to name a few The Queen, 21 Grams, Sunrise, Winter’s Bone these are consider good films by many but for me they are movies I would never watch again or own but that’s just me.

Next person rate Todd_Gaines not me.

[Walts Ghost]

Originally Posted by Todd_Gaines

007 & cartoons are not my cup of tea, but your Criterion's help your score a lot 8 /10

Great collection, Todd. Always enjoy looking through it.

10/10

[Denoku]

Originally Posted by Walts Ghost

Great collection, Todd. Always enjoy looking through it.

10/10

Awesome collection Walt(pj) 10/10

[Anomaly]

Not all in my particular taste, but well rounded. 9/10.

[Blu Jedi Master]

Originally Posted by Anomaly

Not all in my particular taste, but well rounded. 9/10.

8/10 You could use some more Box-sets, but at least you have the Star Trek Box-set.

[Anomaly]

Originally Posted by dallascowboys1

8/10 You could use some more Box-sets, but at least you have the Star Trek Box-set.

I generally don't like box sets. I hate the packaging. I'd rather buy individual titles. You would have had to pay me to own the Alien box.

[BohemianGraham]

Originally Posted by Anomaly

I generally don't like box sets. I hate the packaging. I'd rather buy individual titles. You would have had to pay me to own the Alien box.

9/10. Throw some Criterions in the mix, there's quite a few you might like.

[Blu Jedi Master]

Originally Posted by BohemianGraham

9/10. Throw some Criterions in the mix, there's quite a few you might like.

8/10 Nice Fantasy section

[m_burlock]

Originally Posted by dallascowboys1

8/10 nice fantasy section

10/10.

[alexroubaix]

Originally Posted by m_burlock

10/10.

8.5/10. You have a superb collection of both classics and cult classics. I especially like your taste in horror.

[Habsfan77]

Originally Posted by alexroubaix

8.5/10. You have a superb collection of both classics and cult classics. I especially like your taste in horror.

9.5/10. What a great collection!

[Walts Ghost]

Originally Posted by Habsfan77

9.5/10. What a great collection!

9.5/10

[Si1entElegy]

Originally Posted by Walts Ghost

9.5/10

9/10 Very diverse!

[HD 335]

A nice overall collection albeit a bit heavier on anime than I personally would like to have in my own collection. It does has some good Criterion titles and excellent TV show sets. For a collection nearing 300, it has minimal filler movies. There are some blockbuster movies I'm surprised to see missing and even a Battlestar Galactica and/or Band of the Brothers set would round out your TV collection. I'd give it an 8.9/10