Should longer movies be given 1 disk for movies and 1 for extras

[Canada]

With Avatar and Saving Private Ryan getting perfect 5's for video from Blu ray.com and High Def digest, should films with a lot of extras and a long run time allow the first disk to be for video and audio only.

Aliens: Special Edition 154 min 2hrs 34
Das Boot: Directors Cut 209 min 3hrs 29 min
Titanic: 194 min 3hrs 14 min

[DetroitSportsFan]

In a perfect world, yes.

[steelcity24]

I don't think there is a correct answer to this one...

Manufacturers would say no...

Consumers would say yes....


Simple as that really.

[progers13]

Is there a vote for disc only and keep the extras (like Avatar)?

[42041]

Yes. And stop leaving half the disc empty when you're using half of the bitrate the BD spec allows

[DetroitSportsFan]

Originally Posted by 42041

Yes. And stop leaving half the disc empty when you're using half of the bitrate the BD spec allows

[kdo]

Originally Posted by detroitsportsfan

in a perfect world, yes.

Originally Posted by 42041

yes. And stop leaving half the disc empty when you're using half of the bitrate the bd spec allows

+1

[in2video2]

Originally Posted by DetroitSportsFan

In a perfect world, yes.

Totally agree. Quality counts.

[Flea77]

I would say as a general rule, yes. I would rather have maximum PQ and AQ and have the features (which I never look at anyway) on another disc. Now if you can run max PQ & AQ plus the special features on one BD50, then fine.

Allan