3D Blu-ray Forum Improvement Suggestions, Admin & Moderator Discussion

[BLMN]

Paul should activate his collection on his avatar, lot better than a pinned post.

[ryanmcv]

It would be nice if the site appointed an additional moderator to the 3D forums. I think we're all pretty civil in here, but there are definitely some things that need to be cleaned up (posts in the wrong forum, duplicate threads, threads that should be stickied, etc.). Just my 2 cents.

[Damon1281]

There is a list of moderators at the bottom of the page where the threads are listed. They have responded fairly quickly when messaged directly.

I would also like to see some of the sticky threads to be unstickied and maybe thrown in a FAQ

[wildbill722]

Originally Posted by Damon1281

There is a list of moderators at the bottom of the page where the threads are listed. They have responded fairly quickly when messaged directly.

I would also liked to see some of the sticky threads to be unstickied and maybe thrown in a FAQ

Thank you. I will contact them directly. I hope we can get a sticky that will let us figure out how many 3d blu ray titles there are; I thought Paul's list would be a good start to say the least.

[wildbill722]

Ok. I have sent a message to Scottie concerning help from the13thman, hdgoofnut and Paul H, to either moderate the 3d section, if they would do so, and threads concerning, native, region b, and how many 3d blu ray titles exist. Thank you everyone for your help and input.

And word for or against this to Scottie would be appreciated.

[petergee]

I’m willing to volunteer to help moderate this forum if other people aren’t too keen. I’ve been a mod on several other forums including several in the UK and tehparadox.com (now defunct).

I’ve already messaged staff offering my assistance but heard nothing back. I assumed that they weren’t looking for extra help at that time.

I’m aware that this forum section is often plagued by less-than-helpful posts from trolls or those seeking to undermine the love of stereoscopic titles. There is a place for general ‘will 3D die?’ discussions but this particular section is not it.

Thanks.

[reewinder]

The moderators don't actively moderate this forum. And to get anything stickied I believe an Admin has to do it.....not a moderator. Not sure why we don't have any moderators for the 3D forums that actually hang out here. Of all the ones listed at the bottom of the page I haven't seen any of them post in here since the time I started. I have asked several times for them to promote at least one dedicated 3D user to moderator status but so far to no avail.

[wildbill722]

Sounds like we can post anything we want then. Woo Hoo!! Anyone want to read my life story? Ha.ha.

[the13thman]

I agree with much of this thread, particularly about the stickies. I'd personally get rid of the last five. If you want to know if something is native, check the native 3D blu ray list or the thread for the film. Or create one if there isn't one.

If need be I'm happy to help moderate or administrate the 3D movies forum, I've been visiting for years and already maintain the two threads most important to me.

[Joe D.]

Originally Posted by wildbill722

Sounds like we can post anything we want then. Woo Hoo!! Anyone want to read my life story? Ha.ha.

Hi wildbill,

Nah, I'll wait till the movie comes out.

(in 3D of course)

[Brandon K]

If it's replacing an existing one, cool. Otherwise, there are too many stickies already. Some of them are just cluttering up the top and are unnecessary.

Forums need active moderation, not just moderators that can be contacted. Seen lack of active moderation on too many forums.

[wildbill722]

I have asked all 11 moderators to make the13thman a moderator, with his kind permission. I don't know what else to do. We need him to make the 3d section more streamlined and to help all new (and old) fans of 3d to understand what is out there in 3d blu ray format.

Please help me in any way you can.

Long Live 3d!

[Interdimensional]

Personally I've found this a very friendly subforum with some great regular members and very little need for active moderation. I can't say I've witnessed much in the way of flamewars and trolling (although there was one exception, which was ultimately dealt with).

The main thing that will occasionally bother me is when people create new threads for movies that have existing threads without checking first. In those situations, I sometimes bump the old thread and hope people will ignore the unnecessary duplicate thread, - but this doesn't always work.

The other thing that is a nuisance is the ongoing series of threads by folks who seem to be ever on the lookout for signs of a 3D apocalypse. The 'dead/doomed' threads. It is endlessly tedious to constantly have to justify the ongoing existence of something we all love. I feel nothing good ever comes from this particular line of inquiry, and it is counter-productive to our interests to dwell on it, but I don't believe moderation should be used to suppress discussion.

In a forum full of reasonable, civil individuals, I'm in favour of light-touch moderation. Only when absolutely neccesary.

Originally Posted by Brandon K

If it's replacing an existing one, cool. Otherwise, there are too many stickies already. Some of them are just cluttering up the top and are unnecessary.

I'd agree with that. I tend to ignore sticky threads, I always end up scrolling passed them.

The really good threads tend to remain active and resurface regularly. If it's a popular thread, it doesn't have to be stickied, and will never be too hard to find. Some of these threads are like old friends, I love when they make a reappearance.

[Interdimensional]

Originally Posted by wildbill722

the13thman a moderator, with his kind permission.

I think the13thman would make a very fine moderator, I can't think of anyone better suited.

I'm just not crazy about the idea, because I sometimes end up resenting moderators, and I really like the13thman!

[Joe D.]

This is a great group we have here and I think placing anybody in the position of a moderator might on occasion put one in an uncomfortable position since we are all getting to know each other so well. Is it possible to have one from outside this group?

[Damon1281]

Originally Posted by Joe D.

This is a great group we have here and I think placing anybody in the position of a moderator might on occasion put one in an uncomfortable position since we are all getting to know each other so well. Is it possible to have one from outside this group?

That would defeat the purpose. We already have a 11 moderators that don't participate in this group. If it requires an administrator to move a thread, I'm not sure having a dedicated moderator would help except to have quicker access to an administrator.

[wildbill722]

I believe the13thman would do exactly what you are suggesting. Bring some needed help to our stickies so novices looking for help about 3d movies would have a wonderful place to turn to for their answers. I am sure he is not wanting to ride roughshod over anyone, but we do need occasionally someone who can bring a little order to the sight. Bottom line is he is willing to do so, and his knowledge is impeccable. A rare combination.

I have every confidence that the13thman would reach a happy medium, and would be the last person to use censorship.

I am just afraid the sight might be turning off new 3d patrons when we need them very much right now. The world of 3d blu rays is rather confusing to the uninitiated(region b, native vs. conversion, german auto conversion, etc.) This is really the only sight that caters to us and explains 3d. It just needs a little TLC.

[reewinder]

Most forums also have a stickied section.....I'll use the steelbook forum as an example:Steelbook Questions That Don't Deserve Their Own Threads. Seems to be kinda a "junkdrawer" for all threads that don't meet the criteria and mods there are quick to merge any undeserving threads in the normal section into that stickied thread. We need a 3D Posts That Don't Deserve Their Own Threads stickied and someone to actively moderate.
If a thread isn't about a specific movie or upcoming release it just doesn't belong in the normal threads section.

[Scottie]

We are in the process of discussing the 3D forums.

I have passed along a couple of recent requests (including Bill's) to the rest of the moderation team and am awaiting several responses.

In the meantime, please report any posts or threads in question and we will try our best to make the 3D forums a little less chaotic.

[reewinder]

Originally Posted by iScottie

We are in the process of discussing the 3D forums.

I have passed along a couple of recent requests (including Bill's) to the rest of the moderation team and am awaiting several responses.

In the meantime, please report any posts or threads in question and we will try our best to make the 3D forums a little less chaotic.

Beam me up Scottie

Thank you for looking into it.