Index of pop-outs by 3D movie with time stamps

[Damon1281]

Geostorm

Not a big pop-out fest but there were some okay ones and the 3d overall was pretty good. I noticed around the 56 min mark, the character Dana incorrectly corrects someone's grammar.

I will continually update my first post to reflect what order I rate the movies as far as pop-outs are concerned. The emboldened titles will have links to the posts that enumerate them.

no.   	Time           	Subject			Apparent strength
--------------------------------------------------------------
1.	2.40		pellets			medium
2.	7.31		Gerards hand		mild
3.	9.30		snowflakes		mild
4.	14.10		Satellite section	mild
5.	16.48		man			medium
6.	19.14		suspended car part	medium
7.	19.45		finger point		mild
8.	29.00		shuttle			medium
9.	41.13		finger point		mild
10.	41.30		finger point 		medium
11.	41.44		part of satellite	strong
12.	44.53		part of satellite 	mild
13.	49.39		Agent Wilson's gun	mild
14.	55.13		agent Wilson's gun 	mild +
15.	58.24		gun			mild
16.	1.02.53		finger point		medium
17.	1.12.35		gun			mild
18.	1.16.36		Agent Wilson's gun 	medium
19.	1.18.52		President's hand	mild
20.	1.22.35		shuttles		mild
21.	1.24.26		rocket launcher 	mild
22.	1.32.52		object			medium

[cinerama]

Originally Posted by Damon1281

The Bubble

This is easily the king of pop-outs in my list so far. Not only are they numerous, they are also well defined and often quite strong which also makes them gimmicky, but I say bring it on!
I will continually update my first post to reflect what order I rate the movies as far as pop-outs are concerned. The emboldened titles will have links to the posts that enumerate them.

no.   	Time           	Subject			Apparent strength
--------------------------------------------------------------
1.	.47		Wing of Plane		Strong
2.	1.45		Wing again		Strong
3.	3.47		wing again		Strong
4.	5.14		wing again		Stronger
5.	6.13		lamp			mild
6.	6.36		Pillowcase corner	medium
7.	9.10		Street lamp		medium
8.	10.41		finger/hand		mild
9.	11.10		Dancing girl feet	medium
10.	11.20		Dancing girl feet	strong
11.	13.45		Tray with beer		Very Strong *
12.	14.21		Woman's hands		strong
13.	16.52		Hand/glasses		medium +
14.	19.41		Hand/tweezers 		strong
15.	20.00		table			mild
16.	21.43		hand/cigarettes		strong
17.	22.47		pipe			medium +
18.	23.33		carnival ride		strong
19.	24.14		Piece off plane		strong
20.	26.12		masks			strong
21.	31.35		carnival ride		medium
22.	31.45		tweezers		medium
23.	31.53		mannequin hand		Very Strong
24.	33.21		flowers 		medium
25.	33.56		tree branches		mild
26.	35.34		windshield		mild
27.	39.48		rock			medium
28.	49.57		tree branch		medium
29.	50.09		glass and hands		strong
30.	50.23		basket with baby	mild
31.	56.05 		ladder			Very Strong
32.	56.21		brush			Very Strong
33	1.00.04		steering wheel		mild
34.	1.01.29		feet			medium
35.	1.30.02		statue			medium
36.	1.10.00		thrown dirt		medium
37.	1.10.09 	infant's mobile		medium
38.	1.10.26		man on ladder		medium +
39. 	1.12.10 	rope and pail		strong
40.	1.12.28 	4x4 timber		strong
41.	1.12.44		rope			strong
42.	1.13.11		man with log 		medium +
43.	1.13.17		carnival ride		medium
44.	1.17.11		hose/fluid squirting	medium +
45.	1.19.39 	ladder			medium

Should have even more when the roadshow (112 minutes) version is released next year.

[Damon1281]

Originally Posted by cinerama

Should have even more when the roadshow (112 minutes) version is released next year.

There were some I didn't count because they crossed the edge of the screen too much to truly appreciate. If I would have counted all these "bulges", there may have been over 100. This is certainly the one to beat!

[Paul H]

Originally Posted by mrjafunk

Question, when you say pop out do you mean it comes close your face or just barely out of the screen? i have a top of the line 2014 samsumg 3d tv and i have yet had a movie look like it is mere inches from my face.

Pop out distance is variable. The closest to-my-face 3D display experience was from a Blu-ray 3D Jaws 3-D title credit.
Snapshot-2016-06-14 at 06_44_38 PM-1074924132.jpg
The red boarder came out of the display to the point where the black lettering "Jaws 3-D" traveled 9ft; past my feet on an ottoman, half way up my stretched legs.

[mrjafunk]

What kind of hardware you using? TV or projector? Also, what kind of 3d player you using? I either use my 3d PS3, Sony 3d player or my LG region free 3d player. I do remember Jaws 3d was very good 3d, especially when the fish head comes out of the screen. Any suggestions? Please and thanks.

[mrjafunk]

Originally Posted by Paul H

Pop out distance is variable. The closest to-my-face 3D display experience was from a Blu-ray 3D Jaws 3-D title credit.
Attachment 201560
The red boarder came out of the display to the point where the black lettering "Jaws 3-D" traveled 9ft; past my feet on an ottoman, half way up my stretched legs.

What kind of hardware you using? TV or projector? Also, what kind of 3d player you using? I either use my 3d PS3, Sony 3d player or my LG region free 3d player. I do remember Jaws 3d was very good 3d, especially when the fish head comes out of the screen. Any suggestions? Please and thanks.

[Damon1281]

Originally Posted by mrjafunk

Question, when you say pop out do you mean it comes close your face or just barely out of the screen? i have a top of the line 2014 samsumg 3d tv and i have yet had a movie look like it is mere inches from my face.

I mean anything that appears to be in the space between me and the screen. I've not experienced anything just inches from my face either. I don't think my eyes would be capable of fusing the two images to make that possible. There were some instances in Jaws 3 and Comin' at Ya where I just saw two images though they were clearly meant to be close to me.

[mrjafunk]

Originally Posted by Damon1281

I mean anything that appears to be in the space between me and the screen. I've not experienced anything just inches from my face either. I don't think my eyes would be capable of fusing the two images to make that possible. There were some instances in Jaws 3 and Comin' at Ya where I just saw two images though they were clearly meant to be close to me.

I had such high hopes for Comin' At Ya but the ghosting is so bad I gave up on watching it. It is disappointing some people have all these great 3d effects and it appears I am not one of them. My glasses are active, my TV is awesome, or so I thought. Are some tv's better at t3d than thers?

[Damon1281]

Originally Posted by mrjafunk

I had such high hopes for Comin' At Ya but the ghosting is so bad I gave up on watching it. It is disappointing some people have all these great 3d effects and it appears I am not one of them. My glasses are active, my TV is awesome, or so I thought. Are some tv's better at t3d than thers?

They must be; my projector is certainly better than my TV. For example, in Jaws 3, just before the title (the pic Paul posted above) there is a fish head that comes floating out of the screen. On my TV, the image came about half-way across the room but on my projector, it was closer to 7/8ths with the fish head even with my knees. I picked that specifically because it matched Paul's experience with the title but I couldn't fuse the title on either of my displays. It appeared as two images to me.

[Damon1281]

Although this one had a ton of pop-outs, many of which were very strong, I don't rate it as highly as others because of the poor quality. Too many times the left image had a shadow on a portion which drove me nuts. Still, this one has the strongest pop-outs so far, many that zoomed in to the point where the images split (for me, anyway)

I will continually update my first post to reflect what order I rate the movies as far as pop-outs are concerned. The emboldened titles will have links to the posts that enumerate them.

no.   	Time           	Subject			Apparent strength
--------------------------------------------------------------
1.	:35		fish			mild
2.	1:02		blood			mild
3.	1:05		fish head		very strong *
4.	1:38		Jaws 3d title		extreme I couldn't resolve 
to one image. I don't normally add titling
 but I did here because it was so extreme. 
You can add 17 more titles to the list if you like.
5.	4.45		ribbons			mild
6.	5.17 		floral arrangement	mild
7.	5.34		part of model 		medium
8.	9.20		dolphin			medium
9.	13.21		hands on lock		mild
10.	13.39		bubbles			medium
11.	13.40		machine			medium
12.	14.00		arm			very strong *
13.	18.44		Plant			strong
14.	18.51		turtle			medium
15.	24.17		coral/shrimp?		extreme
16.	24.13		flashlight		mild
17.	25.49		megaphone		mild
18.	29.00		dolphin			medium +
19.	32.47		bubbles			medium
20.	32.50		propeller		mild
21.	32.55		dolphin			medium
22.	33.25		submarine		strong
23.	34.33		skeleton hand		medium +
24.	34.58		dolphin			medium
25.	35.50		dolphin			medium
26.	35.57		eel			medium +
27.	40.52		needle and vial		strong
28.	41.00		needle squirts		extreme
29.	47.01		crossbow		medium
30.	47.06		crossbow 		mild
31.	47.13 		crossbow shot		extreme
32.	51.48		water splash		strong
33.	53.33		flags			strong
34.	54.34		dragon tongue		medium to extreme
35.	54.59		eel prop		strong
36.	55.13		octopus arm		medium to extreme
37.	58.44		fish			mild
38.	59.57		man's face		extreme (1)
39.	1.03.46		bubbles			medium
40.	1.08.45		debris			mild
41.	1.13.18		torch sparks		medium
42.	1.21.55		rod			strong
43.	1.24.10		torch			extreme (2)
44.	1.27.41		torch			strong
45.	1.30.08		water on camera lense	strong
46.	1.31.22		shark			mild approaching to strong
47.  	1.32.42		finger point		mild
48.	1.33.57		exploding shark		strong

(1) I could tell by how cross-eyed I was getting that this was intended to pop-out but the image is clipped by all four sides of the screen. booo

(2) It was this extreme pop-out that I realized I could get the images to appear as one by standing up. But no, I did not go back and check the others.

[cinerama]

Originally Posted by mrjafunk

I had such high hopes for Comin' At Ya but the ghosting is so bad I gave up on watching it. It is disappointing some people have all these great 3d effects and it appears I am not one of them. My glasses are active, my TV is awesome, or so I thought. Are some tv's better at t3d than thers?

It all depends how close you are sitting from your TV or projector. I sit about 12 feet from my 55 inch 3DTV. To get the same 3d effect as I get from my projector, I would have to sit about 6 feet from the TV - about 1.3 times 55. For my projected 138 inch wide image, I sit about 15 feet from it - 1.3 times 138.

[mar3o]

Originally Posted by mrjafunk

I had such high hopes for Comin' At Ya but the ghosting is so bad I gave up on watching it. It is disappointing some people have all these great 3d effects and it appears I am not one of them. My glasses are active, my TV is awesome, or so I thought. Are some tv's better at t3d than thers?

Active tends to have more ghosting than passive in general. I tried a Panasonic plasma active set years ago and the ghosting was terrible. The Samsung active LCD was much better. I've heard a lot of complaints with Sony active sets. A later Samsung active set had more ghosting than one I had tried a couple years earlier. The passive LG LCD I own now has the least ghosting, as long as you sit in the proper "zone" of course.

[Damon1281]

Lot's of pop-outs of Spider-man, probably many more than I counted. As the movie progressed they came fast and furious although seldom really strong. However, considering this was in scope, the framing of most of the shots was excellent, making this a pleasure to watch.

I will continually update my first post to reflect what order I rate the movies as far as pop-outs are concerned. The emboldened titles will have links to the posts that enumerate them.

no.   	Time           	Subject			Apparent strength
--------------------------------------------------------------
1.	18.10		Spider hologram		mild
2.	28.04		foot			very mild
3.	34.51		gum bubble		very mild
4.	30.47		lizard hologram		medium
5.	52.40		Peter's foot		medium +
6.	53.02		Gargoyle?		mild
7.	54.35		pigeons			mild
8.	1.13.54		The Lizard's claw 	strong
9.	1.14.13		car			strong
10.	1.20.21		spire on building	very strong
11.  	1.25.22		camera monitor		mild
12.	1.25.30		Spider-man web pop-in	medium
13.	1.27.56		not sure what it is but	Strong
14.	1.32.58		Gwen & Spider-man	very mild
15.	1.35.22		smoke trail/explosion	mild
16.	1.35.29		The Lizards head	mild
17.	1.37.27		Books on table		mild (also Stan Lee cameo)
18.	1.40.35		helicopter tail		mild
19.	1.41.15		gun			mild
20.	1.43.36		Spider-man		medium
21.	1.45.23		gun			mild
22.	1.46.21		sparks?			medium
23.	1.47.15		The Lizards claw	medium
24.	1.50.40		Spider-man		mild
25.	1.51.04		Spider-man		strong
26.	1.51.09		Spider-man		medium
27.	1.51.17		Spider-man		medium +
28.	1.52.29		Spider-man		medium
29.	1.52.57		Spider-man / web shot	medium
30.	1.54.05		shotgun			medium +
31.	1.56.08		particles of something	mild
32.	1.56.21		debris			strong
33.	2.01.00		rain (pop-in)		mild +		
34.	2.07.25		Spider-man		mild
35.	2.07.30		Spider-man		medium +
36.	2.07.47		Spider-man		medium +  *

(*) This closing pop-out is framed perfectly making it my favorite.

[Damon1281]

With 52 pop-outs, why isn't this one of the pop-out kings you might ask? Most of the po's in this film are mild and come in quick succession not allowing much time to appreciate.



Many more pop-outs than the first Spider-man though maybe not quite as strong. Like the first, the most pop-outs come in the heat of battle and happen rapidly. Although I liked more of the pop-outs in the first one, I'm going to rank this above for the stronger 3d overall which makes the pop-outs work better. That and the number is far greater. On the other hand, this loses points for the "blue-man group" treatment of Electro and the mechanization of the Rhino. On the other hand, it gets points for the

[Show spoiler]death of Gwen Stacy

. We'll see.

I will continually update my first post to reflect what order I rate the movies as far as pop-outs are concerned. The emboldened titles will have links to the posts that enumerate them.

no.       Time               Subject            Apparent strength
--------------------------------------------------------------
1.    1.53        raindrops        medium
2.     4.06        gun            mild
3.    6.12        gun            medium
4.    6.18        Airplane debris        medium
5.    7.08        Nose of airplane    medium
6.    7.31        Spider-man        medium
7.    7.45        Spider-man        medium
8.    7.53        Spider-man        medium
9.    8.23        Spider-man        mild +
10.    8.26        Spider-man        medium
11.    9.19        blueprint        mild
12.    10.15        Spider-man        mild
13.    11.09        hydrant            mild
14.    12.40        Spider-man        mild    
15.    13.10        several object pop-in    medium
16.    13.15        street lamp and vial    mild
17.    13.47        Spider-man        mild +    
18.    13.49        bullets            medium
    14.21        Stan Lee cameo
19.    20.18        Spider-man        mild
20.    22.12        Spider-man        mild
21.    23.17        Aunt May's finger    mild
22.    36.34        eel            mild    
23.    36.38        eel            mild
24.    36.41        eel            medium
25.    42.45        rock skip on water     medium
26.    51.01        spire on building    mild
27.    52.16        gun/cop            medium
28.    52.46        Electro's arm        mild
29.    53.30        man's leg        mild
30.    54.22        Spider-man's hand    mild
31.    55.03        rifle             medium
32.    55.34        rifle              mild
33.    57.48        Shattered glass/hydrant    Strong
34.    1.02.32        lamp            mild
35.    1.13.44        camera            mild +
36.    1.36.53        glass breaking        mild
37.    1.48.27        megaphone        mild
38.    1.51.04        Electro and el. bolts    medium
39.    1.51.28        Elec. bolts        medium
40.    1.51.30        debris            medium
41.    1.51.58        Electro's legs        medium
42.    1.52.40        Spider-man        mild +
43.    1.53.25        Spider-man fingerpoint    mild
44.    1.53.59        Spider-man        medium
45.    1.54.25        debris            medium
46.    1.57.00        Goblin pop-in        mild
47.    1.58.43        Goblin and Gwen     medium
48.    2.00.22        debris            medium
49.    2.01.03        Spider-man's hand    mild
50.    2.01.06        Slo-mo web shot        medium +
51.    2.12.24        Rhino            medium
52.    2.12.33        debris            medium

[Damon1281]

Stuffed with pop-outs of all sorts. Crispin Glover never looked so good. Angelina Jolie never looked so good and Ray Winstone absolutely never looked so good. 3d is fairly strong through-out and if there is any complaint, many of the backgrounds and background figures lack individual volume. Cardboard cut-outs comes to mind as a term used here often.

Watch this on as big a screen as you can find. Many of the camera angles are at ground level so if you can minimize the amount of peripheral edges, you may feel like you are in the same room sometimes standing just behind another person. I didn't list those times as pop-outs so consider that a bonus which as of this writing, puts this movie at the top of my list for pop-outs. Another bonus is that it is actually a good movie!


I will continually update my first post to reflect what order I rate the movies as far as pop-outs are concerned. The emboldened titles will have links to the posts that enumerate them.

no.   	Time           	Subject			Apparent strength
--------------------------------------------------------------
1.	1.33		chair			medium +
2.	3.43		coins			strong
3.	5.10		bird and rat		strong
4.	5.30		bridge post		strong
5.	5.45		branches		medium
6.	5.55		branches		medium
7.	6.06		Grendel			medium +
8.	6.56		dog			medium
9.	7.04		hands and cup		medium
10.	9.21		body			medium
11.	10.00		legs			medium
12.	10.40		torch			medium
13.	12.30		water spray		medium
14.			snow			mild
15.			rain			medium
16.	16.36		roasting varmint	mild
17.	17.00		rocks			strong
18.	17.37		spear			strong
19.	17.51		spear			strong and more centered *
20.	21.18		sparks			mild
21.	25.24		blood			strong
22.	25.34		more blood		strong
23.	27.54		finger			medium
24.	35.10		pulley			medium
25.	38.23		spear			medium +
26.	39.41		Beowulf's arm		mild
27.	41.30		Grendel's arm		medium +
28.	43.54 		bed divider		medium
29.	44.51		Grendel			mild
30.	46.08		rain and flames		mild
31.	51.17		hands			mild
32.	55.42		sword			medium
33.	56.49		horn			mild
34.	57.09		horn			medium
35.	57.35		sword			medium
36.	57.45		sword			strong
37.	1.00.00		sword			strong
38.	1.08.49		arrow			strong
39.	1.09.08 	battle axe		medium
40.	1.10.58		Beowulf's arm		mild
41.	1.12.50		snow			mild
42.	1.15.52		fake blood (ribbon)	medium
43.	1.28.20		Beowulf's arm		mild
44.	1.28.45		Beowulf			medium
45.	1.29.34		snow			medium
46.	1.30.06		arrows			strong
47.	1.30.48		spear			medium
48.	1.30.56		spear popping-in	strong
49.	1.31.45		man falling		strong	
50.	1.32.01		rocks			medium
51.	1.32.23		dragon's head 		mild
52.	1.33.05		dragon			medium
53.	1.33.23		sparks			medium
54.	1.34.06		dragon-fire blast	medium +
55.	1.34.45		Beowulf			strong
56.	1.34.51		Beowulf's feet		strong
57.	1.34.52		flagpole		medium
58.	1.35.41		dragon chin		medium
59.	1.36.57		Beowulf's hand 		medium +
60.	1.37.28		rocks pop-in		medium
61.	1.41.24		boats mast		medium

* = my favorite pop-out

[Freakyguy666]

Originally Posted by cinerama

It all depends how close you are sitting from your TV or projector. I sit about 12 feet from my 55 inch 3DTV. To get the same 3d effect as I get from my projector, I would have to sit about 6 feet from the TV - about 1.3 times 55. For my projected 138 inch wide image, I sit about 15 feet from it - 1.3 times 138.

Are you sure you projected image is 138" WIDE? Or is that the DIAGONAL measurement? If you were, in fact, referring to WIDTH, then you need to correct your arithmetic....a 55" 16x9 tv is actually ~46.6" wide. If you multiply that by 1.3, you get ~60", or ~5 feet.

[cinerama]

Originally Posted by Freakyguy666

Are you sure you projected image is 138" WIDE? Or is that the DIAGONAL measurement? If you were, in fact, referring to WIDTH, then you need to correct your arithmetic....a 55" 16x9 tv is actually ~46.6" wide. If you multiply that by 1.3, you get ~60", or ~5 feet.

138 inches wide. 55" 16 by 9 is 47.9" wide. So, your right, about 5 feet.

[Damon1281]

Do not adjust your television set! This gets nasty. If you just want pop-outs, this is your film (so far), but be prepared for some eyestrain. I'm sure that not even an OLED can fix the problems with this entry but it is not all a tale of woe. For every extreme pop-out that doesn't quite work, whether it goes too far or has some alignment issue or color mismatch, there is one or more strong pop-out that does.

The story is very weak but digestible and the acting is bad; maybe not "A*P*E" bad, or is it? There is some dubious use of black and white mixed with color that doesn't add anything in my book, but the 3d is anything but weak. Everything but the kitchen sink is thrown or dropped towards the camera. It even has depth! If you can find it for less than 10 dollars, then I say buy it.

I will continually update my first post to reflect what order I rate the movies as far as pop-outs are concerned. The emboldened titles will have links to the posts that enumerate them.

no.   	Time           	Subject			Apparent strength
--------------------------------------------------------------
1.	1.11		snake				strong	
2.	1.48		piece of wood			strong
3.	2.04		falling coffee beans		strong	
4.	2.26		metal pitcher			medium
5.	2.38		meat?				strong	
6.	2.43		knife				strong
7.	3.11		shotgun				strong
8.	3.15		track?				strong	
9.	3.46		horse hoof			strong	
10.	3.59		pistol				strong
11.	4.34		gold chain			strong	
12.	5.00		preachers hand			strong
13.	7.10		hands				very strong
14.	9.00		grass				medium
15.	11.52		gun barrel			very strong
16.	13.50		hand				medium
17.	14.06		ladle				very strong
18.	14.53		cup				strong
19.	14.55		horse head			medium
20.	15.37		finger pointing			medium
21.	17.32		bat				strong	
22.	19.07		straw				medium	
23.	19.32		wooden rail			medium +
24.	21.54		babies foot, then butt		strong
25.	22.02		varmint on branch		medium +
26.	22.09		falling berries			strong
27.	24.18		bird on perch			strong
28.	25.58		crow and turkey			medium
29.	26.58		guitar headstock		mild
30.	27.06		finger point and birds		mild-medium
31.	31.04		falling torch			strong
32.	33.29		gun barrel and hand		very strong
33.	33.57		cigar				medium	
34.	34.01		hands				strong
35.	35.25		gun barrel			strong
36.	35.33		ammo belt			strong
37.	36.38		whip				very strong
38.	37.33		burning stick			very strong
39.	37.42		burning stick			medium
40.	37.49		hand burn			strong
41.	37.41		stick				medium +
42.	39.27		falling coins			strong
43.	41.47		rat on stick			medium +
44.	42.43		rat on stick			strong
45.	46.52		branch				medium
46.	49.10		feet and water			medium
47.	52.38		several spears			strong
48.	53.18		arrows				strong
49.	54.43		arrow				strong
50.	54.49		pitch fork			very strong
51.	55.00		pitch fork handle		very strong
52.	58.04		hat brim			medium
53.	58.18		hand				medium +
54.	58.44		hand				very strong
55.	1.10.06		yo-yo				extreme
56.	1.10.15  	corn falling			strong
57.	1.10.20		fruit peel			strong
58.	1.10.45		scorpion?			extreme
59.	1.11.03		playing cards			strong
60.	1.11.21		gun barrel			strong
61.	1.11.38		knife throw			strong
62.	1.11.47		darts				strong
63.	1.12.04		dangling rope			medium
64.	1.12.33		gun barrels			strong
65.	1.13.33		gun barrels			strong
66	1.15.05		hat brim			medium	
67.	1.16.10		gun barrel			medium
68.	1.16.38		gun				strong
69.	1.17.31		gun				strong
70.	1.18.21		gun barrel			strong
71.	1.18.23		knife				strong
72.	1.18.41		gun barrel			medium +
73.	1.20.30		piece of wood			strong
74.	1.24.14		gun barrel			strong

[Damon1281]

One of my favorites doesn't have a lot, but what it does have are well done . Plus it has one of my favorite pop-outs, "Jerry catches an arrow", perfectly framed and is shot just to the right side of the viewers head but then slowly pans more to center. It is also one of the better remakes I've seen of a movie that didn't need one.


I will continually update my first post to reflect what order I rate the movies as far as pop-outs are concerned. The emboldened titles will have links to the posts that enumerate them.

no.   	Time           	Subject			Apparent strength
--------------------------------------------------------------
1.	.58		for sale sign 			mild
2.	13.00		cellphone/hand			mild
3.	19.47		can/broken glass		medium +
4.	22.18		cross				medium +
5.	25.38		trashcan / lid			mild
6.	43.15		Doris explodes			Strong
7.	57.55		debris				medium
8.	1.00.31		hand				medium
9.	1.01.57		blood spurt			medium
10.	1.03.20		blood spurt			strong
11.	1.10.22		hand/crucifiction nail		medium
12.	1.10.33		blood spurt			medium +
13.	1.12.27		breaking glass			mild
14.	1.13.55		blood spurts / gun		mild	
15.	1.15.43		stake and sparks		strong
16.	1.17.12		t-shirt				medium 
17.	1.25.34		crossbow			mild
18.	1.26.57		Jerry catches an arrow		medium +
19.	1.28.04		Jerry flicks a pebble		strong
20.	1.29.18		body explodes/sparks/gun	medium +	
21.	1.29.23		gun				medium +
22.	1.34.45         sparks and stuff that continue on to	
23.	1.35.30						strong

[Damon1281]

This flick is a perfect example for showing the difference between a projector and TV, assuming the projector screen is very large. So many large items, people, objects, which are cut off by the edge of the screen make it very hard to view as pop-outs on a TV, but with a very large screen you can focus on a part of an object and realize that it comes out of the screen pretty pronounced. Our hero John Putnam, for instance, stands in our theatre room on a few occasions, an effect that is destroyed by a small screen where the framing is so obvious (and my small screen is 60in.) A classic that should be in everyone's collection

This film makes it into my upper tier for pop-outs for how well done they are. And there are several!


I will continually update my first post to reflect what order I rate the movies as far as pop-outs are concerned. The emboldened titles will have links to the posts that enumerate them.

no.   	Time           	Subject			Apparent strength
--------------------------------------------------------------
1.	.25		Meteor			medium
2.	2.25		telescope		strong (very nice)
3.	3.51		meteor/debris		strong
4.	4.05		debris			medium
5.	4.17		telescope		strong
6.	6.15		creature		mild
7.	9.55		John Putnam		mild - medium
8.	11.16		rock slide		medium to strong over time
9.	16.20		bottom of helicopter	medium
10.	16.28		windshield		mild
11.	18.18		creature		strong
12.	19.39		Joshua tree		medium
13.	27.43		Joshua tree		medium
14.	29.30		telephone pole		strong
15.	30.00		truck ladder		strong
16.	33.00		creature		strong
17.	36.45		John Putnam		mild - medium
18.	39.36		spotlight fixt. on car	mild
19.	43.10		gun			mild
20.	47.24		books on table		mild
21.	52.13		John Putnam		medium
22.	52.55		Frank			mild
23.	53.48		telephone		mild
24.	56.59		John Putnam		mild
25.	1.03.17		hangers			medium
26.	1.09.12		pistol			medium +
27.	1.09.17		rifles			medium +
28.	1.11.30		John Putnam		medium
29.	1.11.54		alien weapon		very strong
30.	1.18.27		sparks			medium