Pet Semetary (2019) vs. Black Christmas (2019)

[Mikezilla3k]

Choose your poi.... I mean, which one do you think is the better remake?

[jess1581]

Well this poll is lopsided. It's not even a contest. Think what you want about Pet Semetary, but Black Christmas makes that film look like Shawshank.

[KManX89]

Originally Posted by jess1581

Well this poll is lopsided. It's not even a contest. Think what you want about Pet Semetary, but Black Christmas makes that film look like Shawshank.

Black Christmas 2019 was godawful from top to bottom, and it certainly didn't help that it was hampered with gutless, badly-edited PG-13 kills that make it impossible to tell WTF is going on.

Pet Sematary 2019 wasn't that good, either, but come on, it's by far the better movie.

[hockeyshark91]

Both are pretty dreadful, but PS is slightly less so.

[KManX89]

Originally Posted by hockeyshark91

Both are pretty dreadful, but PS is slightly less so.

Pet Sematary wasn't that great, either, but come on, it's a friggin' masterpiece compared to Black Christmas 2019.

[Damon1281]

Originally Posted by Mikezilla3k

Choose your poi.... I mean, which one do you think is the better remake?

I can't choose, the premise is flawed. All four were terrible.

[Zillamon51]

Pet Sematary isn't very good, but it had some things going for it. Black Christmas is abysmal trash.

[DR Herbert West]

Pet Sematary

[Dr Lenera]

It's no contest. Pet Sematary was still a half decent movie, if inferior to the first version. Black Christmas....I won't say any more because I'll get wound up again.

[originalHDphantom]

Pet Sematary...it wasn't near as bad as that Black Christmas reiteration.

[Alan T]

Ugh, voted to quickly - was thinking of Black Christmas 2006. BC 2019 is absolute tripe!

Pet Sematary all the way

[formula_nebula]

Both are bad. But, at least I enjoyed Pet Sematary some what.

[kylor]

Dislike both, but voted Pet Semetary. It is the lesser of the two evils.