Blu-rays and DVDs with more extras than 4K UHD

[CourtlyHades296]

The Criterion release of Citizen Kane despite its incredibly comprehensive set of supplements is still missing some:

Citizen Kane in 5 Minutes (from the very first Criterion Laserdisc)
A unique commentary (from the Image Laserdisc)
Various interviews about the film (from the 50th anniversary Criterion Laserdisc)
The Battle over Citizen Kane (from the Warner UCE Blu-Ray and 2-Disc DVD)
RKO 231 (from the Warner UCE Blu-Ray)

[CourtlyHades296]

The BFI UHD of Watership Down is missing a couple Criterion exclusive supplements.

[CelestialAgent]

No Country for Old Men adds new conversations with the Coens and Deakins/Diliberto with Megan Abbott, making of featurettes and archival interviews (assume these are EPK but don’t know if they’ve appeared on other releases.) The collector’s edition extras aren’t included, with hours of press tour Q&As with David Poland, David Powell, Variety, EW, Creative Screenwriting, NPR, ABC, In-Store, Charlie Rose, WNBC, C4, KCRW and Spike Jonze.



Many of the films from the Essential Fellini boxset have never had standalone releases. The UK BD included unique interviews with Sandra Milo and Lina Wertmuller. The Umbrella release featured documentaries on Fellini, although they also have a separate DVD release.



The Criterion release of Scarface has new interviews with Abbott/Hader and Lea Jacobs. Not retained from the Imprint are a Drew Casper commentary and interviews with Matthew Sweet and Tony Rayns.



Thieves Like Us adds a new Nathaniel Thompson commentary, but doesn’t include the Geoff Andrew appreciation, radio plays or booklet from the Radiance.



Kino’s 4K release of Play Misty for Me adds a new commentary with Alan Spencer, while also retaining their BD extras (Tim Lucas commentary, Donna Mills interview, Howard S. Berger video essay, TFH) and retaining the Universal extras (Play It Again and Misty, Don and Clint). The Final Cut release featured a trio of interviews with Marc Eliot, Kim Newman and Allan Bryce.



Like Our Little Sister, the Korean 4K release of Blue is the Warmest Colour is apparently an AI upscale. There are no English friendly extras, but the Artificial Eye release included deleted scenes and interviews with Exarchopoulos and Kechiche.

[CourtlyHades296]

North by Northwest is missing the Criterion LD's storyboard to film comparison and Hitchcock interview, as well as the Blu-Ray first printing's isolated score and Cary Grant: A Class Apart documentaries even in the UK version.

[CelestialAgent]

The Brood and Scanners

Originally Posted by CelestialAgent

Extras comparison

New extras

Audio commentary by Martyn Conterio and Kat Ellinger
Anger Management: Cronenberg's Brood and the Shapes of Cinematic Rage - a video essay by Leigh Singer
120-page book with new essays

Carried over from Second Sight BD

Meet the Carveths, Producing the Brood, Look of Rage, Character for Cronenberg, Cronenberg - The Early Years

Carried over from Wicked Vision BD

Audio commentary by William Beard
Scoring the Brood

Missing from Criterion BD

Crimes of the Future (also available on Arrow Early Films BD)
Birth Pains
Oliver Reed on The Merv Griffin Show
Carrie Rickey essay

Missing from Wicked Vision BD

Audio Commentary with Marcus Stiglegger and Kai Naumann (German)
Super 8 version
Childhood Memories with Cindy Hinds
Pierre David on... The Brood
Cronenberg Compositions: Mark Irwin on The Brood
Galleries, trailers

Plaion Pictures 4K includes Audiokommentare, Interviews, Trailer, 40-seitiges Booklet mit einem Text von Stefan Jung

Originally Posted by CelestialAgent

Not all the Wicked Vision extras are carried over.

Extras comparison

New extras

Audio commentary by Caelum Vatnsdal
Cronenberg's Tech Babies: video essay by Tim Coleman
120-page book with new essays

Carried over from Second Sight BD

My Art Keeps Me Sane, The Eye of Scanners, The Chaos of Scanners, Exploding Brains & Popping Veins, Bad Guy Dane

Carried over from Wicked Vision BD

Audio commentary by William Beard
Monster Kid, Mind Fragments, Method in his Madness

Missing from Criterion BD

The Scanners Way, Mental Saboteur, The Ephemerol Diaries
David Cronenberg on The Bob McLean Show
Stereo (also on Arrow Early Works)
Kim Newman essay

Missing from Wicked Vision BD

Scanners II-III
CD soundtrack
Audio commentaries with Rolf Giesen and Gerd Naumann and Marcus Stiglegger (German)
Isolated Score
Telepathic Visions
Pierre David on Scanners
The Ephemerol Diaries (also on Criterion BD)
Inside Scan: Scanners 1
Interview with Cronenberg and Shore
Trailers

[CelestialAgent]

According to willo007 in the comments on the Kingdom of Heaven announcement page

Soo, only this is missing: Original Theatrical Version
The Pilgrim's Guide (Theatrical Version Only)
Interactive Production Grid (480i; 1:23:45)
A&E Movie Real (480i; 44;28)
History vs. Hollywood (480i; 42:55)
Ridley Scott - Creating Worlds (480i; 2:37)
Production Featurette (480i; 2:18)
Wardrobe Featurette (480i; 2:12)
Paradise Found: Creating the Director's Cut (480i; 8:29)
Creative Accuracy: The Scholars Speak (480i; 26:38)
Unholy War: Mounting the Seige (480i; 17:04)
Production Design Primer (480i; 6:52)
Colors of the Crusade (480i; 32:14)
Cast Rehearsals (480i; 13:23)

Also, Fabulous Stains has new extras and archival extras but not the Imprint extras.

Originally Posted by whiteberry

Someone on Facebook asked Fun City Editions about the extras on the Imprint blu-ray:



I think this just applies to the new extras that Imprint created. The extras taken from the Rhino DVD (the audio commentary by Lou Adler and the audio commentary by Diane Lane/Laura Dern) will probably be included on the Fun City Editions release.

The extras produced by Imprint were:

Audio Commentary with Lee Gambin and Allison Wolfe
Video essays by Kat Ellinger and Sara Marcus
Interviews with Marin Kanter and Debbie Rochon



The Imprint release of Drugstore Cowboy includes isolated score, Chris O'Neill visual essay, score featurette and a different shorter interview with Kelly Lynch



Thief doesn’t include the Arrow extras (Directors: Michael Mann documentary, James Caan interview and Ciné Regards episode, F.X. Feeney analysis and theatrical cut and isolated score)



Ugetsu is missing from the Eureka release Oyu-Sama, Rayns interview and booklet



Chungking Express doesn’t include the Rayns commentary from the original Criterion release, and from the Artificial Eye release Tarantino introduction, On Location with Christopher Doyle and WKW interview



Godzilla doesn’t include the additional films from the boxset, and from the Classic Media release the Ryfle/Godziszewski commentary and Story Development and Godzilla Suit featurettes



Cherbourg doesn’t include the additional films from the Demy boxset, and from the StudioCanal BD Catherine Deneuve audio interview and Virginie Ledoyen and Geoff Andrew interviews



Darling adds several new extras (Sofia Coppola, Frederic Raphael and John Schlesinger interviews and costuming featurette), but doesn’t include the Umbrella extras (Berger/Thompson commentary, Melanie Williams visual essay and Kim Newman interview)



The 4K release of Tommy is barebones, and doesn’t include any of the Odeon Entertainment extras (Russell/Kermode commentary, interviews with Russell, Townshend, Daltry and Ann Margaret, sound featurette and The Tube excerpt)



Aguirre retains the two commentary tracks, but doesn’t include from the BFI release the booklet and additional Herzog films (Fata Morgana, The Unprecedented Defence of the Fortress Deutschkreuz, Last Words, Precautions Against Fanatics)



36 Quai des Orfèvres only includes English subtitles for the main feature but not the extensive extras, however the Tartan BDs include Olivier Marchal interview, making of and costumes and weapons featurettes



Similarly, Crimson Rivers only includes English subtitles for the main feature. The Imprint release includes more extensive extras than the Kino with commentary, isolated score and featurettes.

[CelestialAgent]

New Criterion announcements

You Can Count On Me doesn’t include A Look Inside from the DVD or the 10 minutes of EPK interviews from the Momentum DVD



The Truffaut set includes some new extras with Introducing My Father interview. The BFI release of The 400 Blows has some minor exclusive extras like Catherine Wheatley presentation and Paris archive shorts. The Fox Lorber DVD included a Glenn Kenny commentary. The Artificial Eye BDs of Stolen Kisses and Bed and Board includes a French language commentary with Claude de Givray and Claude Jade, and Marie-France Pisier commentaries on Antoine and Colette and Love on the Run.



The Big Heat has several new extras (Silver/Ursini commentary, Nehme video essay, Bachmann/Bogdanovich audio interview), but is missing from the Twilight Time and Indicator a different commentary with Dobbs/Kirgo/Redman, isolated score, Rayns interview and booklet.

[CourtlyHades296]

It seems the Arrow of The Great Escape lacks the Criterion LD commentary.

[Hedrox]

Mission Impossible 3 had the Tom Cruise / J.J. Abrams commentary as a picture in picture track on the HD-DVD release.

Also missing are the extras from the Best Buy exclusive DVD:
- The Hunt Is On (12:08) - interviews with J.J. Abrams, Tom Cruise and the rest of the cast highlighting the mission given to the IMF team;
- Countdown Begins (21:30) - story concept and history of the IMF team that includes a look at Tom Cruise's movie stunts from Top Gun to the Mission: Impossible series;
- Evolution Of A Blockbuster (21:55) - traces the making of Mission: Impossible III from script conception to choosing the director to the final cut;
- Designing The Mission (10:37) - a look at the production design for Mission: Impossible III.

[CourtlyHades296]

The Bond Sean Connery Collection 4K lacks the banned Criterion Laserdisc commentaries for Dr. No, From Russia With Love and Goldfinger, as well as the music and effects tracks from the MGM Connery Collection I Laserdisc box.

[JackyJacquard]

Originally Posted by CourtlyHades296

The Bond Sean Connery Collection 4K lacks the banned Criterion Laserdisc commentaries for Dr. No, From Russia With Love and Goldfinger, as well as the music and effects tracks from the MGM Connery Collection I Laserdisc box.

Banned?

[CourtlyHades296]

Originally Posted by JackyJacquard

Banned?

The Criterion Laserdiscs of Dr. No, From Russia With Love and Goldfinger were recalled because they had unfiltered commentaries where Terence Young, Guy Hamilton, Richard Maibaum and Peter Hunt went into great detail that EON didn't approve of (and they didn't show EON the commentary tracks in advance), and one instance EON hated had Terence Young call Ian Fleming a bit of a prick. I have the From Russia With Love Criterion, and am still looking for the other two.

[Hedrox]

Originally Posted by CourtlyHades296

The Criterion Laserdiscs of Dr. No, From Russia With Love and Goldfinger were recalled because they had unfiltered commentaries where Terence Young, Guy Hamilton, Richard Maibaum and Peter Hunt went into great detail that EON didn't approve of (and they didn't show EON the commentary tracks in advance), and one instance EON hated had Terence Young call Ian Fleming a bit of a prick. I have the From Russia With Love Criterion, and am still looking for the other two.

If you just want to listen to the commentaries themselves, or sync them up to whatever copy of the movie you have, they're available on youtube.

Dr. No - Criterion Laserdisc Commentary - Slideshow Version - YouTube

From Russia With Love - Criterion Laserdisc Commentary - Slideshow Version - YouTube

Goldfinger - Criterion Laserdisc Commentary - Slideshow Version - YouTube

[PonyoBellanote]

Originally Posted by Hedrox

Mission Impossible 3 had the Tom Cruise / J.J. Abrams commentary as a picture in picture track on the HD-DVD release.

Also missing are the extras from the Best Buy exclusive DVD:
- The Hunt Is On (12:08) - interviews with J.J. Abrams, Tom Cruise and the rest of the cast highlighting the mission given to the IMF team;
- Countdown Begins (21:30) - story concept and history of the IMF team that includes a look at Tom Cruise's movie stunts from Top Gun to the Mission: Impossible series;
- Evolution Of A Blockbuster (21:55) - traces the making of Mission: Impossible III from script conception to choosing the director to the final cut;
- Designing The Mission (10:37) - a look at the production design for Mission: Impossible III.

Not even the BD bonus disc has those? Weird.. I don't know why they'd skip them. Here I thought I had all bonus features.

Originally Posted by CelestialAgent

According to willo007 in the comments on the Kingdom of Heaven announcement page

Man, really? With all the extras it had, I thought it was most complete. Hate it when they make me buy more than one release for that.

[Hedrox]

Originally Posted by PonyoBellanote

Man, really? With all the extras it had, I thought it was most complete. Hate it when they make me buy more than one release for that.

Actually, from that list the only things missing are A&E Movie Real and History vs. Hollywood. These were licensed programs from TV networks, specifically A&E and History Channel, and the rights probably lapsed.

[CelestialAgent]

Master and Commander doesn’t include the extras from the 2 disc DVD/French BD.

Originally Posted by HD Goofnut

2004 2 Disc DVD - "The Hundred Days" documentary (68:38), "In The Wake of O'Brian" featurette (19:24), "Cinematic Phasmids" (30:02), "On Sound Design" (17:47), Interactive Cannon Demonstration, HBO First Look (25:02), Multi-camera Shooting
Best Buy Bonus Disc - "Behind the Scenes: A Filmmaker's Journey — A Look at Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World" (19 min)

The Curse of Frankenstein is comprehensive in both territories, except for The World of Hammer (which at least has a separate DVD)



Some of the Optimum extras for This is Spinal Tap aren't carried over: 25 Years of Spinal Tap: Turn It Up To 11, Live Earth performance, Reg Presley and Nigel Tufnel Interviews, featurettes. International Sony release TBC



Eyes Wide Shut adds interviews with Lisa Leone, Georgina Orgill and Christiane Kubrick, press conference and Never Just a Dream from the UK theatrical reissue, but drops interviews with Cruise, Kidman and Spielberg, and from the Masterpiece boxset, Stanley Kubrick in Focus. The original DVD also included an open matte version.



Both the Wild East DVD and Koch BD of Kill Them All and Come Back Alone included interviews with Ken Wood (Giovanni Cianfriglia) and Alberto Dell'Acqua, while the StudioCanal BD carries over the Alex Cox commentary but adds interviews with Castellari and Romolo Guerrieri and a retrospective.

Unlike the Kino only including a commentary, the StudioCanal BD of The Hellbenders includes interviews with Howard Hughes and Ruggero Deodato and introduction by Jean-Baptiste Thoret. Koch included Troy Howarth commentary and super 8 version.

[CelestialAgent]

Come Drink With Me 4K is more comprehensive than 88’s earlier BD, but it doesn’t include all the Arrow extras (Audio Commentary by Tony Rayns, Talk Story with Cheng Pei-pei and Cinema Hong Kong: Swordfighting) or a booklet, and a couple of the Dragon Dynasty extras (Audio commentary with Cheng Pei-pei and Bey Logan and A Classic Remembered).



Hard Boiled has a lengthy amount of extras, but doesn’t include the Bey Logan commentary, older interviews with Woo, Philip Chan and Kwok Choi and Location Guide from Dragon Dynasty (Terence Chang interview on the DVD), Accidentally student film from the Criterion DVD, individual Woo commentary from the Winstar DVD, half hour Woo interview from the Tartan DVD. Arrow release is forthcoming and may have different extras. The French DVD including a 75 minute making of and Tony Leung interview that were English subtitled for the HKR bootleg, alongside Body Count, analysis, location guide and Stranglehold comparison.



A Better Tomorrow doesn’t include all the DVD extras, including the alternative score, Bey Logan commentary, Crossings documentary and Woo and Fat interviews from the Optimum steelbook. The WCL 4K includes a Fantasia panel with Woo, but this can also be found on YouTube. The HKL DVD of the sequel included a Tsui Hark interview.

YouTube

The Imprint of Midnight Cowboy adds a Matthew Asprey Gear commentary, Desperate Souls documentary and Adam Holender interview, and carries over the separate Jerome Hellman commentary and Celebrating Schlesinger from the MGM BD, but it lacks the Criterion exclusive extras: Schlesinger/Hellman group commentary, Michael Childers gallery, Adam Holender video essay, The Crowd Around the Cowboy, Schlesinger BAFTA interview/tribute, David Frost interview with Voight, screen tests and Waldo Salt: A Screenwriter's Journey.

Kidnapped includes a director interview not present on the Italian 4K.

The DVD of Human Traffic includes a Remixed cut, Making Of and Boom Boom short film.

[CelestialAgent]

La Notte 4K adds a new commentary and interview (booklet is the same as the previous Eureka BD), but doesn’t include the Criterion extras (interviews with Adriano Apra, Carlo di Carlo and Giuliana Bruno and Brody booklet).

[CourtlyHades296]

Sound of Music seems to be missing the text gallery about the history of Salzburg, the Anchluss and other material related to the film from the 30th Anniversary Laserdisc. I also think Salzburg Sight & Sound from that same LD (which reappeared on the 2010 Blu-Ray) is missing as well.

[RBBrittain]

Originally Posted by CourtlyHades296

Sound of Music seems to be missing the text gallery about the history of Salzburg, the Anchluss and other material related to the film from the 30th Anniversary Laserdisc. I also think Salzburg Sight & Sound from that same LD (which reappeared on the 2010 Blu-Ray) is missing as well.

Meanwhile, the international 4K releases of TSoM will omit the third bonus disc in the U.S. 4K version (which may be a limited edition, perhaps why its price on most sites including Amazon has jumped up since its announcement), which is supposed to contain all the extras from TSoM's previous BD releases.

Also, the OP's comparison of the Kino Lorber 4K of The Apartment to its Arrow UK/US BD may need to be revised, as Arrow will be releasing its UK 4K in December.