Please help me with an HDTV...need help ASAP...please!!!

[Veronica Mars]

I am looking to get a new HDTV for my living room. This is my primary home theater viewing space. I have a 42 panny S1 in the bedroom. We don't watch a lot of tv in there, so it's not as big of a deal what we got. We just picked up this one because of a great BF deal and panansonic's great rep.

Ok, I'm replacing an old CRT 57" and I like that viewing size.

My choices are a 58" panny S1. BB has a deal right now for $1599 and they deliver and take away my old tv at no charge. Amazon is matching with no tax, but I could go through Bing and get the taxes covered at BB too.

The S1 does have color issues. I'm not a REAL videophile and don't notice every little thing, but I wonder if it will be an issue on a bigger screen that we use for almost everything, even though it's fine in the bedroom. The S1 also doesn't handle 24p, but I've never noticed a problem on my bedroom tv.

The other choice is the 54" g10. This model has the THX mode and the reviewers claim this helps with colors a lot. It also handles the 24p from what I've read.

Sears has this for $1499 right now and I could also offset taxes with Bing. No free delivery and I would be going down in size from the 57".

Also, if people who really have these models know, if the differences between the two aren't really that big of a deal, I'd be getting the larger size for only $100 more.

I'm really conflicted and I think the sale may be ending soon.

PLEASE any feedback about what to do would be much appreciated.

[Batman1980]

I would go with the 54" trust me, color issues and the like become GLARING at that size. Hopefully you can get them to throw in free delivery but that's the way I would go and I imagine most here would as well.

[HAMP]

I would get the 58" panny S1... Larger is always better...