IGN's Top 25 Blu-Rays

[Chordata]

Sarah Marshall is easily in my Top 25...but I only own like 40.

[Scooby Blu]

Originally Posted by Blu Titan

Someone just made up that list because someone else thought it was a good idea . I am a big fan of Star Trek 2009, but the #1 Blu-ray? Don't think so.

Hey Titan! I agree 100%! I could make up a list and if just might differ depending on my state of mind. IGN is engaged in some old fashioned grandstanding!

[Freekman]

Um, what about Black Hawk Down? One of the best transfers I've seen yet. No BoB or Iron Man, either? Who made this crap list?

[Squall835]

I can't believe they included Star Trek (2009) but left out the original series sets. Those things are amazing.

[toef]

Originally Posted by Barnolde

Iron Man was completely average, but then again it's IGN, they love average superhero movies.

I'm disappointed at the lack of The Fall, absolute must-own Blu-ray. Also Braveheart.

Forgetting Sarah Marshall? really? REALLY??

I think Iron Man is better than The Fall.

Of the two, The Fall is the completely average movie. It seemed like it was trying too hard to be better than it was.

[Steve]

I agree with about half the list. Star Trek is right where it should be, but as others have pointed out I think Iron Man should have gone on the list.

[DangerousG]

IGN is comprised of a bunch of fanboys, nobody should take their lists seriously.

Just look at their list of the best movies of the decade. http://www.ign.com/decade/best-movies-decade.html

[Freekman]

Wow. Gladiator didn't even make that least. The list was too occupied by Spider-Man films.

[neo_reloaded]

Oh no! Opinions I disagree with!

[bboisvert]

Forgetting Sarah Marshall?

The lack of Band of Brothers or Black Hawk Down is odd.

[Batman1980]

Top 25 lists like this are subjective and reactions are why I would never make a top 25 list of my own.

[Blu Titan]

#1 BD release...Blade Runner or Close Encounters of The Third Kind. They included fully restored, multiple versions of the movies with as many extras as anyone can possibly bear.

[ArmyOfDarknessAW]

Why the hell is Speed Racer on there. Sure it looks and sounds great, but the movie makes it not even deserve top 50. There are about 10 i would take off and replace to make my top 25.

[Kryptonic]

And...IGN continues to suck...

[Beta Man]

people shouldn't get all worked up about anything IGN does......

This list doesn't compare to my list:

TOP 25 MOVIES OFF THE TOP OF MY HEAD.

[MosHighDef]

Heres 20 or something that are musts in my opinion

Blade Runner
I Robot
Baraka
Planet Earth
3:10 to Yuma
Rambo
Casino Royale
The Matrix
Band of Brothers
Sin City
The Dark Knight
Apocalypto
Braveheart
Casino
Pirates of The Caribean
Godfather Collection
No Country for Old Men
Fight Club
Forrest Gump

[Beta Man]

Originally Posted by MosHighDef

Heres 20 or something that are musts in my opinion

Blade Runner
I Robot
Baraka
Planet Earth
3:10 to Yuma
Rambo
Casino Royale
The Matrix
Band of Brothers
Sin City
The Dark Knight
Apocalypto
Braveheart
Casino
Pirates of The Caribean
Godfather Collection
No Country for Old Men
Fight Club
Forrest Gump

I bolded the ones I disagree with

[mikejet]

Speed Racer!

I feel so lonely in my love for this movie.

[MosHighDef]

Originally Posted by Beta Man

I bolded the ones I disagree with

those movies would be alot more entertaining than the original top 25.

[Gone2HiDef]

Well to be fair, the list definitely skews toward sci-fi/fantasy with a pinch of classics, probably for good measure. So from that standpoint, if you're gonna start out biased, why not go all the way?