Who would win in a fist fight, Riggs or McClane?

[samdvd1]

[Tony208]

Riggs is always more of a gun guy, see Lethal Weapon 1

[samdvd1]

Riggs is also more mentally unstable, so I went with Riggs.

[Al_The_Strange]

Riggs may be more "dangerous," but in terms of physique and resilience (and perhaps mental stability), I went with McClaine. In a fight between the two, I think he'd win.

[wormraper]

are we talking about McClane from Die hard 1-3 or the Superman McClane that was in DH 4 and 5?

[Trekkie313]

McClane, he can take a blow to the head and keep on ticking. Riggs has gotten kidnapped like 3 times throughout the series.

[Canada]

Riggs of course he knows a lot of martial arts. Plus he's excellent with a rifle, "When I was 19, I did a guy in Laos from a thousand yards out. It was a rifle shot in high wind. Maybe eight or even ten guys in the world could have made that shot. It's the only thing I was ever good at. Well, see ya tomorrow."

[Steve]

I can't help but think Riggs could take McClane. Especially the McClane of the first 3 movies.

[Tony208]

DH5 McClane would survive a couple of headshots.

[Captain Kirk]

Riggs. He is way too unstable that a few blows to the head wouldn't really do much.

Lethal Weapon - Riggs - Joshua Fight.wmv - YouTube

[Ill_Be_Back]

Definitely McClane, he can take a beating and a few gun shots and still fight back. Well McClane from Die Hard 1 - 3...

[AGH]

I have to go with McCane on this one. I'm a bit bias considering I watch the Die Hard films much more often. Love me some Riiiiiiigggggssss! though.

[Trigger89]

Both put up a good fight but I would lean more towards McClane (1-3) as he takes a lot of beatings, yet he always comes back for more and wins the brawl.

[SixSpeedSamurai]

The Energizer Bunny himself, John McClane. He's taken some harsh poundings from some way overmatched opponents before.

[L-Rouge]

I think I identify with the Riggs mannerisms and sense of humour, I'll vote for Riggs!.

[X400]

oh man what a fight! i dont know i like both very much, both are resilient but Riggs has the better training being a hand-to-hand expert, spec ops, vietnam war vet, so i'll have to go with Riggs with this one

[beadelf]

Originally Posted by samdvd1

riggs is also more mentally unstable, so i went with riggs.

+1

[tigertron]

Originally Posted by Tony208

DH5 McClane would survive a couple of headshots.

and a massive amount of radiation...

[AnimalChin]

but Riggs took out Gary Busey!

[Trekkie313]

Originally Posted by AnimalChin

but Riggs took out Gary Busey!

Meatloaf nearly took out Gary Busey, I'm sure Bruce Willis could handle him.