Bluray menus vs dvd

[vortexx]

Originally Posted by jeffm2016

I know this may be unrealistically possible but I hate how the dvds had great menus and now they are boring on bluray. Is there anyway to rip the dvd menu and place the hd movie in them to a digital file?

Or other solution.

I really liked having the menus and tons of extras (that didn’t make it to bluray in many cases) and would love anyway to merge them into one file to have or burn back to a recordable disk.

It can be done but you would need to separate all the elements from the bluray and DVD onto your computer. Then you're pretty much going to be authoring a bluray almost from scratch. I've authored dvds with menus and submenus etc for movies that were getting released. It's quite time consuming and not fun. I would just keep both versions if I were you as it can take days to do and then you have to be your own beta tester and play everything to see if it all works. Not fun.